Document Repository - Phase 4

RHI Phase 4 Chronology - 19 November 2015 onwards 

Date  Document  Bates reference
2015/16 Internal Audit briefing note on
audit planning, identification of
audit coverage and non-
domestic RHI audit 2015/2016
19 Nov 2015 Email from Lee-Anne
Hutchinson to Eugene Rooney
and others re reminder
regarding updated casework
committee meeting minutes
19 Nov 2015 Shane Murphy confirms he is
content with the Energy
changes to the casework
committee meeting minutes
20 Nov 2015 Ofgem RHI Non-domestic
board meeting: scheme
board overview
20 Nov 2015 Letter from Chris Poulton to
John Mills re amendments to
the administrative
arrangements agreement
23-24 Nov 2015 Emails between Alison
Clydesdale, Chris Osborne and
Rodney Corrigan re response to
UFU; letter from Alison
Clydesdale to Gary Hawkes re
Freedom of Information request
24 Nov 2015 Email from Lee-Anne
Hutchinson to Trevor Cooper
sending casework committee
meeting minutes for review
24 Nov 2015 Email from Lee-Anne
Hutchinson attaching the
casework committee meeting
minutes of 21 October 2015
24 Nov 2015 President’s Report UFU
Executive Committee meeting
25 Nov 2015 UK Autumn Statement confirm
continuation of the DECC RHI
Scheme with overall funding of
some £1.15b available by
2020-21; DFP notified DETI
Finance
25 Nov to
3 Dec 2015
Email from Michelle Scott to
Trevor Cooper regarding
references in SR to the future
of RHI: it appears there is an
intention to keep the scheme
open in GB; further emails
following SR announcement
25 Nov 2015 Letter from Ian Marshall to
Jonathan Bell re proposed
solution for treatment of small
scale (non-cluster) wind
following consultation on
closure of NIRO to new onshore
wind in 2016
25 Nov 2015 Letter from UFU to Perceptive
Insight Market Research Ltd re
have your say on the future of
the electricity network
26-27 Nov 2015 Letter from Amber Rudd to
Jonathan Bell re spending
review 2015 with draft
submission from Stuart
Wightman to Timonty Cairns
and Jonathan Bell on response
to letter
26 Nov 2015 Email from Michelle Scott
to Pamela Galloway re RHI
references with SR-AME
26 Nov 2015 Seamus Hughes' handwritten
notes of telecon with Ofgem
27 Nov 2015 Input from Stuart Wightman
for Heads of Branch meeting
27 Nov 2015 Email from Chris Johnston to
Linda Walsh re Culmore
controller
27 Nov 2015 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Stuart Wightman and others
attaching note of DETI-Ofgem
RHI telecon meeting held on
26 November 2015
27 Nov 2015 Emails between Chris Osborne,
Angela McParland and Jim
McManus re ETI Committee –
Future of NIRO/Future Support
29 Nov 2015 Email from Tom Elliott to Chris
Osborne with answer from
DECC to written parliamentary
question
30 Nov 2015 Email from Stuart Wightman to
Iain McFarlane attaching RHI
paper for Audit Committee
1 Dec 2015 Email from Noel McNally to
Michelle Scott re Catagen –
Economics Branch comments
- 1 December 2015
1 Dec 2015 Signed copy of the amended
administrative arrangements
agreement
1 Dec 2015 Email from Eugene Rooney
responding to Lee-Anne
Hutchinson re Casework
Committee meeting minutes
1 Dec 2015 Email from Chris Johnston to
Cathal Ellis and Anne Fisher
re presentations
1 Dec 2015 Email from Lee-Anne
Hutchinson to Emer Morelli,
Michelle Scott and others
attaching minutes and seeking
comments on the Casework
Committee meeting minutes
1 Dec 2015 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Katy Read and Stuart Wightman
re administrative arrangements
2 Dec 2015 Agenda and papers for DETI
Departmental Audit
Committee meeting; draft
minutes of meeting
2 Dec 2015 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Trevor Cooper recirculating
synopsis paper
2 Dec 2015 Email from Angela McParland
to Chris Osborne re ETI
Committee – future of NIRO/
future support
3 Dec 2015 Email from Trevor Cooper to
Stuart Wightman re RHI
funding commitments
3 Dec 2015 Email from Chris Johnston to
Mark Anderson re link on RHI
funding
3 Dec 2015 Email from Jim Clarke to
Seamus Hughes re RHI meeting
4 Dec 2015 Email from Laura McCoy on
behalf of John Mills to Trevor
Cooper re draft response to
DFP queries on RHI
4 Dec 2015 Email from Stuart Wightman to
Bernie Brankin re RHI 2015/16
budget position
4 Dec 2015 HOD/CE assurance statement
for budget 2016-17
4 Dec 2015 Ofgem E-Serve finance review
4 Dec 2015 Emails between James Murray
and Stephen Beagan - biomass
7 Dec 2015 Email from Michelle Scott to
Bernie Brankin re the initial
notification from DETI that the
costs could rise to £42m in
2016-17
7 Dec 2015 Letter from Trevor Cooper to
Michelle Scott re business
case addendum for NI
non-domestic RHI
7 Dec 2015 Email from Michelle Scott to
Emer Morelli re business
case addendum for the NI 
non-domestic RHI
7 Dec 2015 Email from Michelle Scott to
Emer Morelli re thoughts on
business case addendum for
NI non-domestic RHI
7 Dec 2015 Email from Emer Morelli to
Michelle Scott re business case
addendum - concern at spike
in application numbers
7 Dec 2015 Email from Mark Anderson to
Chris Johnston re co-op launch
7 Dec 2015 Email from Trevor Cooper to
Michelle Scott attaching letter
responding to DFP approval of
business case addendum
7 Dec 2015 Emails between Trevor Cooper
and EugeneRooney re HMT
position on RHI
7 Dec 2015 Email from Iain McFarlane to
Rachel Linton attaching letter
from Michelle Scott with
approval of business case
addendum for NI RHI
7 Dec 2015 Submission from Stuart
Wightman to Timothy Cairns,
Jonathan Bell, and DARD re
COR 1297-2015 part input to
query on RHI
7 Dec 2015 Emails between Cathal Ellis and
Chris Johnston re biomass
event (CAFRE/AFBI)
7-8 Dec 2015 Internal emails on items for
Issues meeting on 8 December
2015: RHI to be added to the
agenda
8 Dec 2015 Email from Michelle Scott to
Emer Morelli re update on
meeting with Treasury
8 Dec 2015 Email from Trevor Cooper to
Michelle Scott re suggested
lines to take for HMT
8 Dec 2015 Email from Pamela Galloway to
Jeff  McGuinness re clarification
from HMT on RHI and cap
8 Dec 2015 DoF internal discussion re RHI
funding in advance of meeting
with HMT
8 Dec 2015 Email from Michael Woods to
Stuart Wightman, John Mills
and others re Internal Audit
review of the scheme being
brought forward
8 Dec 2015 Email from John Mills to Trevor
Cooper and Eugene Rooney re
lines to take for meeting with
HMT
8 Dec 2015 Email from Iain McFarlane to
Rachel Linton forwarding
emails on Treasury position
on RHI and lines to take
8 Dec 2015 Email from Bernie Brankin to
Trevor Cooper attaching email
between Jon Parker and Alison
Clydesdale of April 2011
8 Dec 2015 Email from John Mills to Chris
Stewart and others re Treasury
position on RHI and lines to
take
8 Dec 2015 Emails between Chris Stewart,
Andrew McCormick and John
Mills exploring time line for
closure
8 Dec 2015 Letter from Damien Hegarty
to Ian Marshall re proposed
solution for treatment of
small scale (non-cluster)
wind following consultation
on closure of NIRO to new
onshore wind in 2016
8-21 Dec 2015 Emails from DETI to Ofgem re
draft amendment regulations
9 Dec 2015 Email from Stuart Wightman to
Trevor Cooper re additional
lines to take on the spike in
response to email from Trevor
Cooper to Eugene Rooney with
update on RHI/HMT position
9 Dec 2015 Email from Lee-Anne
Hutchinson to Emer Morelli
and others re reminder about
minutes of Casework
Committee meeting
9 Dec 2015 Email from Trevor Cooper to
Eugene Rooney re update
on RHI/HMT position
9 Dec 2015 Email Stuart Wightman to
Trevor Cooper re lines to
take in response to HMT
9 Dec 2015 Letter from Stuart Wightman 
to Edmund Ward re RHI
inspection visits/audits
9 Dec 2015 Email from David Mark to Tom
McKeown re wood chip versus
wood pellet
9 Dec 2015 Emails from JCM Farms
suggesting date for 
meeting with DETI
9 Dec 2015 Emails from Chris Johnston to
John Martin re meeting with
DETI
10-17 Dec 2015 Emails from Noel McNally
confirming he is content with
Casework Committee minutes;
Michelle Scott committing to
return to DETI with comments
on Casework Committee
minutes
10 Dec 2015 Email from Chris Johnston to
Noel Gavigan re DBFG
document approved – action
required
10 Dec 2015 Input from Stuart Wightman
for Heads of Branch meeting
10-11 Dec 2015 Email from Michelle Scott to
HMT re high level note setting
out background to NI RHI and
funding issue
12 Dec 2015 Emails from Chris Johnston to
Mark Anderson re flue gas
emissions
13 Dec 2015 Emails between David Mark,
Alan Johnston, Tom McKeown,
John Harrison and Willy Patton
re wood pellet presentation
14 Dec 2015 Submission from Trevor Cooper
to Eugene Rooney, Andrew
McCormick, Timothy Cairns and
Jonathan Bell re budget 2016-17
- assessment of impact of 5%
and 10% reductions
14 Dec 2015 Email from Chris Johnston to
Nick Rackard re update on
members request for help
14 Dec 2015 Emails between Simon Oborn
and David Mark re wood pellet
and Moy Park financial
commitment
14 Dec 2015 Email from Chris Johnston to
Alistair McCracken re willow
drying
15 Dec 2015 Email from Teri Clifton to
Edmund Ward re costs
15 Dec 2015 Six monthly assurance
statement from John Mills
to Chris Stewart
16 Dec 2015 Emails between Emer Morelli
and Mike Brennan re clearance
of draft letter to DETI re
retrospective approval
16 Dec 2015 Memo from Celine Murray to
DETI HODs / Grade 6s re
performance monitoring to
Q/E 31 December 2015: DETI
corporate / business
plan 2015/16
16 Dec 2015 Emails between Seamus
Hughes, Cathal Ellis and Stacey
Speakman re burning of waste
wood
17 Dec 2015 Email from Michelle Scott to
Emer Morelli re draft paragraph
on RHI for First Day brief for
new Minister
17 Dec 2015 Email from Mark Millican
attaching Budget 2015
Database Guidance; 
forwarded by Bernie
Brankin to Trevor Cooper
18-21 Dec 2015 Emails between Michelle Scott,
Emer Morelli and others re the 
future of the scheme
18-21 Dec 2015 Email from Mike Brennan to
Andrew Crawford, copying
David Sterling re HMT has
confirmed that the NI DEL will
have to take the hit; emails
between Michelle Scott, Emer
Morelli and Mike Brennan re
timing of issuing refusal of
retrospective approval in case
there are views from Minister
and SpAd; letter refusing
approval and notes
18 Dec 2015 Email from Trevor Cooper to
David Conliffe  forwarding
email chain re lines to take
with HMT
18 Dec 2015 Letter from Stuart Wightman to
Edmund Ward re RHI extra
resource for 2015-16
18 Dec 2015 Email from Edmund Ward to
Teri Clifton and Seamus Hughes
re NI audits and inspections
21 Dec 2015 Email from Andrew McCormick
replying to Chris Stewart re
HMT stance on overspend and
urgency for closure
21 Dec 2015 Email from Stuart Wightman
to John Mills re options for
progressing RHI
21 Dec 2015 Email from Emer Morelli to
Trevor Cooper attaching letter
refusing retrospective approval
21 Dec 2015 Letter from DFP to Trevor
Cooper re non-domestic RHI
addendum
21 Dec 2015 Letter from Emer Morelli to
Trevor Cooper re non
-domestic RHI addendum
21 Dec 2015 Internal Ofgem email re actions
from biomass sustainability
meeting
21 Dec 2015 Email from Lee-Anne
Hutchinson to Michelle Scott
re reminder about Casework
Committee meeting minutes
22-25 Feb 2016 Emails between Tom Forgrave,
David Mark, David Gibson and
Alan Johnston re Tom Forgrave
– further additional shed
22 Dec 2015 Emails between Emer Morelli,
Trevor Cooper, Eugene Rooney,
Andrew McCormick, Chris
Stewart and John Mills re draft
Terms of Reference for Internal
Audit review of RHI scheme
within Energy Division
22 Dec 2015 Email chain between Francis
Crockford, John Mills, Sandra
Thompson and the Finance
Branch re January technical
monitoring round
22 Dec 2015 Emails between Eugene
Rooney, Andrew McCormick
and others re Terms of
Reference for Internal Audit
review of the RHI scheme
22 Dec 2015 Email from Rodney Corrigan
to Chris Osborne and Wesley
Aston attaching response from
Amber Rudd on issue of
support to small-scale wind
in NI
22 Dec 2015 Online Farmers Weekly article
by Isabel Davies – NI farmers
launch legal challenge over
wind subsidies
23 Dec 2015 Email from Andrew McCormick
with suggested amendments to
draft submission: future of RHI
23 Dec 2015 Email from John Mills with
clarifications on forecast
expenditure in response to
Andrew McCormick’s questions
23 Dec 2015 Emails between John Mills,
Chris Stewart and Andrew
McCormick re draft
submission to Minister
23 Dec 2015 Email from Chris Johnston to
Cathal Ellis re CAFRE event
23 Dec 2015 Email from Andrew McCormick
to John Mills confirming he is
content with submission to the
Minister
23 Dec 2015 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re future of RHI
23 Dec 2015 Emails between David Gibson
and David Mark re change in
RHI scheme post March 2016
29 Dec 2015 Email from Helen Vaughan
to John Mills re RHI closure
29 Dec 2015 Memo from Lee-Anne
Hutchinson to Trevor Cooper
and others re corporate risk
register
29 Dec 2015 Email from Helen Vaughan
to John Mills re RHI closure
30 Dec 2015 Email from Jeff Partridge to
Trevor Cooper with revised
submission to Jonathan Bell
re 2016-17 budget - 
implications of budget and
proposed distribution across
DETI
30 Dec 2015 Email from Trevor Cooper to
Bernie Brankin and others re
corporate risk register for
January 2016 Board
30 Dec 2015 Further emails from Jeff
Partridge to Trevor Cooper re
submission to Jonathan Bell -
2016-17 budget

DFE-287831 to DFE-287845
DFE-287847 to DFE-287861

30-31 Dec 2015 Email from John Mills to 
Andrew McCormick re
suspension or closure
30-31 Dec 2015 Emails between John Mills and
Andrew McCormick re revised
submission
31 Dec 2015 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re future of RHI
31 Dec 2015 Email from John Mills to 
Andrew McCormick re
recommendations to
Minister on RHI
2016 Extract from UFU annual report
2016-2017 UFU commodity watch – small
scale generation SCADA -
document by Chris Osborne
2016-2017 DfE Business Plan 2016/17
Jan 2016 AME forecast
Jan 2016 Draft consultation paper –
proposed closure of the NI RHI
Jan 2016 Draft letter from Jonathan Bell
to Patsy McGlone re
consultation on closure of the
RHI scheme
4 Jan 2016 Timothy Cairns’ annotation on
 31 December 2015 submission
4 Jan 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
James Dornan to his query re
consultation
5 Jan 2016 January technical monitoring
round – Energy response:
submission to DETI Minister;
email from Bernie Brankin to
DFP attaching DETI letter on
January monitoring uncleared
by Minister; email from Linda
Donaldson to Sarah Benton
(copying Michelle Scott and
others) attaching spreadsheet
with reductions identified in
DETI as part of the January
monitoring technical exercise
5 Jan 2016 Email from JCM Farms to
stakeholders re DETI meeting
reminder and points for
discussion
5 Jan 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick,
forwarded to Richard Bullick
and Timothy Johnston re emails
from anonymous source
6 Jan 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Peter Jackobsen on hearing of
Minister providing additional
funding in other areas
6 Jan 2016 Email from John Mills to 
Michael Woods re draft terms
of reference for Internal Audit
review of the non domestic RHI
6 Jan 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
David Mark in response to his
request for an update re RHI
6 Jan 2016 Email from Edmund Ward to
Alison Hardie re volume of
applications in October and
November and increased
budget from DETI
6 Jan 2016 Email from Helen Vaughan to
Seamus Hughes and Gail
Anderson re timing of RHI
closure
6-7 Jan 2016 Emails between John Mills and
Damien Hegarty (obo Timothy
Cairns) re submission on future
of RHI
6-7 Jan 2016 Emails between Trevor Cooper
and Michelle Scott re Casework
Committee queries
6-7 Jan 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick and Michael Woods
re draft terms of reference;
documents regarding internal
audit of the RHI scheme
8-11 Jan 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Emer Morelli and Mike Brennan
re DETI considering whether to
write at Ministerial level to HMT;
submission on future of
scheme not yet agreed; email
from Mike Brennan to David
Sterling, copying Michelle Scott:
relating discussion with DETI
on whether to contact HMT
8 Jan 2016 Email from John Mills to
Seamus Hughes re submission
to Minister on future of RHI
8 Jan 2016 Email from Chris Johnston to
Padraic O’Neill and Fred
Tottenham re DAFM climate
mitigation presentation
8 Jan 2016 Email from John Mills answering
Timothy Cairns' questions on
31 December 2015 submission
8 Jan 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Chris Johnston forwarding email
from Stacey Speakman re NI
RHI – permitted fuel types
8 Jan 2016 Email from Chris Johnston to
Michael Doran and JCM Farms
forwarding email chain from
Seamus Hughes re NI RHI –
permitted fuel types
11 Jan 2016 Email from John Mills to
Andrew McCormick re branch
receiving queries re closure
11 Jan 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to John Mills re calls from public
re closure of scheme
11 Jan 2016 Email from JCM Farms to
Michael Hegarty re summary
of key points from informal
discussion
12 Jan 2016 Emails between Chris Stewart
and John Mills re Minister's
acceptance of advice
12 Jan 2016 Letter from Helen Vaughan to
Paul McGinn re closure of RHI
schemes
12 Jan 2016 Letter from Helen Vaughan to
Paul McGinn re closure of RHI
scheme, cross-cutting' and
notice period
12 Jan 2016 Emails between Edmund Ward,
Teri Clifton, Gareth John and
Jane Pierce re NI RHI
forecasted costs
12 Jan 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to
Gareth John and Jane Pierce
re NI RHI costs
12 Jan 2016 Emails between Edmund Ward
and Peter Rice re assumed
costs and expected costs from
DETI
12 Jan 2016 Emails between Chris Stewart
and John Mills re update on
RHI & NIRO
13-15 Jan 2016 Letter from Chief Secretary to
the Treasury to Mervyn Storey
re spending review and autumn
statement 2015 – NI Executive;
forwarded from Mike Brennan
to Michelle Scott and Emer
Morelli; letter to Mervyn Storey;
(for communication to DETI see
26 January 2016)
13 Jan 2016 Email from Helen Vaughan to
John Mills re key issues
arising from meeting 
14 Jan 2016 Emails between Boyd George
and David Mark re biomass
payback
14 Jan 2016 Email from Cathal Ellis to Chris
Johnston re CAFRE event on
making the best use of Biomass
heat for your business –
Enniskillen College
15 Jan 2016 Email from Terence Coyne to
Trevor Cooper, Bernie Brankin
and Iain McFarlane re RHI
insertion to corporate risk
register in advance of
Departmental board meeting
15 Jan 2016 Letter from HOCS to Arlene
Foster re appointment of
Timothy Johnston, Richard
Bullick and Stephen Brimstone
as OFMDFM Special Advisers,
including signed acceptance
of Stephen Brimstone
15 Jan 2016 Email from Jeff Partridge to
Trevor Cooper attaching draft
Departmental board finance
paper 
18 Jan 2016 Email from Paul Dolaghan to
Jacqui Rose re DETI business
plan 2015/16 – performance
monitoring to quarter ending
31 December 2015
18 Jan 2016 Draft submission from John
Mills to Timothy Cairns and
Jonathan Bell re options on
the future of the RHI schemes
18 Jan 2016 Emails between John Mills,
Andrew McCormick and Chris
Stewart re invitation from
Action Renewables to attend
a round table discussion
18 Jan 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Stuart Wightman re draft
submission to Minister –
options on the future of the
RHI schemes and paper
consultation
18 Jan 2016 Email from Jeff Partridge
to Bernie Brankin attaching
email with RHI forecasts
18 Jan 2016 Emails between Moy Park staff
about unofficial briefing that
RHI will close
18 Jan 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Dovile Bagdonaite re projected
costs
18 Jan 2016 Email from Mike Mullan to
David Gibson and Declan
Cunningham re RHI subsidy
- closure
18 Jan 2016 Email from Mike Mullan re
RHI closure
19 Jan 2016 Email from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns re NIRO
submission and RHI submission
19 Jan 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re options on the future
of RHI schemes
19 Jan 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Timothy Cairns re urgency
of RHI submission
19 Jan 2016 Letter from Emer Morelli to
Kieran Donnelly re DFP's
decision not to grant approval
for the retrospective element
of the non-domestic RHI; email
from Fiona Dynes forwarding
letter to Kieran Donnelly
19 Jan 2016 UFU press notice on UFU and
small scale wind industry
present to ETI Committee on
closure of renewable support
scheme
19 Jan 2016 Ofgem E-Serve bi-monthly
summary report on suspected
fraud cases
19 Jan 2016 Emails between David Mark,
Mike Mullan, Mairi Patton,
Simon Oborn and Brian
Gibson re NI RHI update –
draft thoughts
20 Jan 2016 Email from Jeff Partridge to
Linda Donaldson attaching
AME commissioning letter
budget 2016
21 Jan 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re NIRO closure to
onshore wind
21 Jan 2016 Ofgem RHI Non-domestic
Board meeting - scheme
board overview
21 Jan 2016 Emails between Seamus
Hughes, Stuart Wightman,
Mark Compston and Ofgem  
re Mr McNaughton’s RHI
application
22 Jan 2016 Email from Timothy Cairns to
Timothy Johnston re NIRO
submission
22 Jan 2016 Email from Timothy Cairns to
Timothy Johnston re RHI
submission
22 Jan 2016 Email from Timothy Johnston to
Timothy Cairns re getting party
view on submissions
22 Jan 2016 Email from Timothy Cairns to
Sean Kerr forwarding re ‘hold’
the NIRO and RHI submissions
22 Jan 2016 Email from Timothy Cairns to
Jonathan Bell forwarding
Timothy Johnston’s email
and advising submissions
are on hold
22 Jan 2016 Email from Timothy Cairns to
Timothy Johnston re Andrew
Crawford’s view
22 Jan 2016 Email from Chris Johnston to
Seamus Hughes re renewable
heat target at end of 2015
22 Jan 2016 Emails between John Mills, 
Andrew McCormick and Chris
Stewart re NIRO and RHI
submissions clearance
25 Jan 2016 Submission from Joanne
McBurney to Andrew Crawford
and Mervyn Storey
COR/0024/2016: Chief
Secretary to the Treasury –
Spending Review
25 Jan 2016 Emails from Timothy Cairns to
Andrew McCormick forwarding
his response to Chris Stewart
re NIRO and RHI submissions
on hold
25 Jan 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to John Mills re RHI forecast
scenarios
25 Jan 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to
Gareth John re expected
scheme closure
25 Jan 2016 Handwritten notes by Seamus
Hughes of teleconference with
Ofgem
25 Jan 2016 Note of teleconference meeting
between DETI and Ofgem
25-26 Jan 2016 Text messages from Andrew
McCormick to Timothy Cairns
and Chris Stewart
26 Jan 2016 Email from Bernie Brankin to
Trevor Cooper re RHI forecast
scenarios
26 Jan 2016 Email from David Sterling to
Chris Stewart urging that the
scheme is closed as a matter
of urgengy (forwarded to
Michelle Scott and Emer Morelli
at DOF-42040); email from
Andrew McCormick to David
Sterling: ‘Issue is where it is,
and nothing more Chris or I
can do to shift it’
26 Jan 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Chris Stewart and
John Mills discussing the RHI
funding issue and closure of
scheme
26 Jan 2016 Emails between Mike Brennan,
David Sterling,  Andrew
McCormick, Emer Morelli,
Michelle Scott, Joanne
McBurney re communications
with HMT
26 Jan 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to John Mills and Chris Stewart
responding to John Mills' email
on RHI/NIRO closure
26 Jan 2016 Email from Nicola Harron to RHI
Accreditation re meter reading
26 Jan 2016 Email from Bernie Brankin to
Trevor Cooper with draft
submission from Trevor to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re briefing for supply
resolution debates
26 Jan 2016 Email to Moy Park re wood
pellets
26 Jan 2016 Email from Chris Farmer to
Joanne Warnock forwarding
DETI RHI approval documents
26 Jan 2016 HOCS email to David Sterling
reporting that significant
liabilities continuing to be
incurred through RHI scheme
had been raised with the 
First Minister
26-27 Jan 2016 Emails between Andrew
Crawford, Timothy Johnston,
Richard Bullick and Stephen
Brimstone with email chain
re consultation on closure
of the RHI
27 Jan 2016 Email from Timothy Johnston
to Richard Bullick re Arlene
Foster's discussions with HOCS
27 Jan 2016 Emails between John Mills and
Andrew McCormick re
timetable for closure
27 Jan 2016
Letter from HOCS to Andrew
McCormick re RHI and
escalating costs of scheme
(refers to Emer Morelli’s
concerns); emails between
Andrew McCormick, HOCS and
David Sterling, forwarded to
Emer Morelli and Michelle Scott
27 Jan 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Timothy Cairns forwarding
HOCS memo
27 Jan 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Jonathan Bell forwarding
HOCS memo
27 Jan 2016 Email from Richard Bullick to
Timothy Johnston re HOCS
memo
27 Jan 2016 Email from Timothy Johnston
to Arlene Foster re HOCS memo
27 Jan to
1 Feb 2016
Emails between Andrew 
McCormick, Executive Office,
HOCS and Timothy Johnston
re HOCS memo to Andrew
McCormick re RHI submission
27 Jan 2016 President’s Report UFU
Executive Committee meeting
27 Jan 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Chris Stewart re approval of
RHI closure submission
27 Jan 2016 Various emails between HOCS,
Mike Brennan, David Sterling,
Emer Morelli and Michelle
Scott re RHI timeline and
DETI key issues
27 Jan 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Trevor Cooper re points from
meeting the previous day
27 Jan 2016 Emails between HOCS, Andrew
McCormick, David Sterling and
John Mills discussing timetable
for closure of RHI scheme
27 Jan 2016 Eemails between Mike Brennan,
Richard Bullick and Andrew
Crawford re liaising with HMT
27 Jan 2016 Memo from Lee-Anne
Hutchinson to Trevor Cooper
and others re corporate risk
register
27 Jan 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, David Sterling,
Chris Stewart, John Mills, Mike
Brennan and others re RHI
timetable
28 Jan 2016 Email from Mike Brennan to
Emer Morelli and  Michelle
Scott re observations on
Andrew McCormick's letter
to HOCS
28 Jan 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Chris Stewart re draft
response to HOCS memo
28 Jan 2016 Email from Terence Coyne to
Francine Manikpure re DFP
approvals with additional
conditions
28 Jan 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Timothy Cairns and others re
debate on closure of RHI scheme
28 Jan 2016 Email from David Sterling
to Andrew McCormick re
timetable for closure of
scheme
28 Jan 2016 Emails between John Mills,
Andrew  McCormick, Eugene
Rooney and others re draft
response to HOCS memo
28 Jan 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to John Mills re draft response
to HOCS memo
28 Jan 2016 Emails between Chris Stewart
and Andrew McCormick re
legal advise on consultation
28 Jan 2016 Memo from Andrew McCormick
to HOCS in response to memo
28 Jan 2016 Janice Hill on behalf of Andrew
McCormick to HOCS re
response to HOCS minute of
27 January on RHI
28 Jan 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Jonathan Bell, Timothy Cairns
and Sean Kerr attaching his
memo to HOCS
28 Jan 2016 Email from Timothy Cairns to
Andrew McCormick taking
issue with his memo to HOCS
28 Jan 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
responding to Timothy Cairns
re accuracy closure of scheme
28 Jan 2016 Email from John Mills to Chris
Stewart re RHI closure
timetable
28 Jan 2016 Email from John Mills to Chris
Stewart with proposed
timetable for closure.
Forwarded to David Sterling,
then Mike Brennan, Emer
Morelli and Michelle Scott:
to note DETI’s expectation that
we will be able to turn around
formal request for comment
tomorrow
28 Jan 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to John Mills re RHI closure
timetable
28 Jan 2016 Letter from Paul McGinn to
Stuart Wightman re risk of
litigation with  suspension
of RHI
28 Jan 2016 HOCS memo to Andrew
McCormick re RHI; email from
Mike Brennan to Emer Morelli
re PS DETI 009/16 RHI;
forwarded to David Sterling and
then Mike Brennan, Emer
Morelli, Michelle Scott for
preparation of a DfP response
28 Jan 2016 Email from Lee-Anne
Hutchinson to Michelle Scott
seeking comments on
casework committee papers
28 Jan 2016 Memo from Andrew McCormick
to HOCS re RHI difficulties and
DETI's response
28 Jan 2016 Email from Mark Compston
to Teri Clifton re Mr
McNaughton’s RHI application
28 Jan 2016 Email from Mark Compston
to Teri Clifton re Mr
McNaughton's RHI application
29 Jan 2016 Letter from David Sterling to
Andrew McCormick re memo
to HOCS
29 Jan 2016 Letter from Paul McGinn to
Stuart Wightman with advice
re consultation
29 Jan 2016 Email from John Mills to Andrew
McCormick and Chris Stewart
re draft submission to Minister
29 Jan 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re NI RHI closure timelines
29 Jan 2016 Ministerial approval of
submission NI RHI closure –
timelines
 
29 Jan 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re NI RHI closure – views of
Finance Minister
29 Jan 2016 Email from Private Office to
Timothy Cairns forwarding
submission
29 Jan 2016 Emails between Chris Stewart
and Stuart  Wightman
discussing David Sterling’s
letter to Andrew McCormick
29 Jan to
1 Feb 2016
Emails between Chris Stewart 
and Grainne Walsh at
Stratagem re future of RHI
29 Jan 2016 Emails between Mike Brennan,
Emer Morelli, Michelle Scott 
re DfP response to Andrew 
McCormick’s letter
29 Jan 2016 Letter from David Sterling to
Andrew McCormick; email
from Chris Stewart to John Mills,
Stewart Wightman, Eugene
Rooney discussing reply
29 Jan 2016 Email from Michelle Scott
confirming she is content with
Casework Committee minutes 
29 Jan 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Lee-Anne Hutchinson
confirming DfP is content with
the casework minutes
29 Jan 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Teri Clifton re note on alleged
fraud
29 Jan 2016 Email from Cathal Ellis to Chris
Johnston re RHI announcement
29 Jan 2016 Email from Mark Corrigan to
David Mark re biomass – RHI
change
29 Jan 2016 Emails between Chris Osborne
and Gillian Cahoon re support
for small scale (non-cluster)
wind and proposed closure
of NIRO to new onshore wind;
letter from UFU to Jonathan Bell
29 Jan 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to DETI
following call from Fergal
Hegarty re speculative calls
about scheme closure
1 Feb 2016 Ministerial approval of 29
January 2015 submission:
NI RHI closure 
1 Feb 2016 Submission from Jonathan Bell
to First and deputy First
Minister re closure of RHI by
urgent procedure; Minister's
approval; letter from Jonathan
Bell to Mervyn Storey for his
views
1 Feb 2016
  • Email from Mike Brennan to
    Glynis Aiken: concerns about
    this draft and will get back
    to you with tracked changes
  • Email from Michelle Scott
    to Glynis Aiken attaching
    tracked changes;
  • Submission from Emer
    Morelli to Andrew Crawford
    and Minister Storey re Mike
    Brennan’s proposed
    changes to DFE memo to
    Executive;
  • Emails from Mike Brennan
    to Andrew Crawford and
    Glynis Aiken: proposed
    changes and then RHI
    urgent procedure paper
    revised as discussed
1 Feb 2016 Email from Mike Brennan to
Andrew Crawford forwarding
email chain re HOCS memo to
Andrew McCormick re RHI
1 Feb 2016 Letter from Jonathan Bell to
Mervyn Storey attaching DFE
memo to the Executive seeking
agreement for urgent procedure
1 Feb 2016 Emails between Glynis Aiken,
DoF Private Office, Mike
Brennan, Andrew Crawford,
David Sterling, Joanne
McBurney and others re RHI
– urgent procedure paper
attached re closure of RHI
1 Feb 2016 Email from Timothy Johnston
to Andrew McCormick re
HOCS Memo to Andrew
McCormick re RHI
1 Feb 2016 Email between Jane Pierce 
and Seamus Hughes re
NI RHI consultation
1 Feb 2016 Letter from Stuart Wightman
to Paul McGinn enclosing
draft regulations
1 Feb 2016 Emails Eugene Rooney, Trevor
Cooper and Michael Woods re
memo from Andrew McCormick
to HOCS re RHI
1 Feb 2016 Email from Iain McFarlane to
Rachel Linton attaching email
chain from 2015 re RHI paper
for Audit Committee
1 Feb 2016 Email from Lee-Anne
Hutchinson to Trevor Cooper re
Energy division Casework
Committee meeting minutes
1 Feb 2016 Emails between Teri Clifton and
Jane Pierce re RHI Ni scheme
closure
1 Feb 2016 Email from Edmund Ward to
Chris Poulton and Gareth John
re costs
1 Feb 2016 Emails between Chris Stewart
and Grainne Walsh of Stratagem
re RHI announcement
1 Feb 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Stuart Wightman
and John Mills re response to
media enquiry
2 Feb 2016 Mail to HOCS attaching draft
memo to OFMdFM
2 Feb 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Eugene Rooney,
Chris Stewart and others
on origin of 5% rule and
referencing DfP
2-3 Feb 2016 Emails between John Mills,
Andrew McCormick, Timothy
Cairns, Mike Brennan, HOCS re
draft submission from Chris
Stewart to Timothy Cairns and
Jonathan Bell re closure of RHI
- urgent procedure
2 Feb 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Chris Stewart,
John Mills and Stuart Wightman
re 5% rule and impact on DEL
2 Feb 2016 Memo from John Murray to
John Mills re query from
ETI Committee
2 Feb 2016 Emails between David Sterling,
Andrew McCormick and John
Mills re proposed changes to
DFE memo to Executive
2 Feb 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to John Mills re DFP’s changes
to DFE memo to Executive
2 Feb 2016 Email from Mike Brennan
attaching Andrew McCormick’s
tracked changes on draft letter
to OFMDFM; Mike Brennan
draws attention to three
specific points
2 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re closure of RHI - urgent
procedures,attaching amended
memo to Executive, letter to
ETI Committee and
consultation document; Email
from Andrew Crawford to
Timothy Johnston: can you let
me or Timothy Cairns know if
you are content for he letter to
OFMDFM to be issued.
2 Feb 2016 Email from Andrew Crawford
to Timothy Johnston attaching
draft DfE memo to Executive
2 Feb 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Timothy Cairns re
consultation and clearance of
urgent procedure paper
2 Feb 2016 Note of actions/updates from
Ofgem RHI Non Domestic
Leadership Team meeting
2 Feb 2016 Email from Francine Manikpure
to Trevor Cooper attaching
RHI budget timeline
2 Feb 2016 Email from Eugene Rooney to
Trevor Cooper and Bernie
Brankin re ETI Committee
queries with memos attached
2 Feb 2016 Email from John Mills to Chris
Stewart and others re
RHI AME 5%
2 Feb 2016 Email from Bernie Brankin to
Trevor Cooper re RHI timeline
2 Feb 2016 Email from Jeff Partridge to
Trevor Cooper re RHI timeline
2 Feb 2016 Email from Jeff Partridge to
Trevor Cooper attaching AME
forecast for Chancellors
budget 2016
2 Feb 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Chris Stewart re tracked
changes to draft memo to HOCS
2 Feb 2016 Email from Bernie Brankin to
Trevor Cooper attaching AME
forecast for Chancellors
budget 2016
2 Feb 2016 Chair’s brief from Jim McManus
to Patsy McGlone for ETI
Committee meeting
2 Feb 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Timothy Johnston and others
re HOCS memo to Andrew
McCormick re RHI
2 Feb 2016 ETI Committee minutes for
meeting held 2 February 2016
2 Feb 2016 Email from Helen Vaughan to
John Mills re RHI – heating an
empty room
2 Feb 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
Andrew McCormick re
AME and RDEL
3 Feb 2016 Emails between Eugene
Rooney, Andrew McCormick
and others re draft memo
to HOCS
3 Feb 2016 Emails from Mike Brennan to
David Sterling and Andrew
McCormick re consultation
attaching further amended
DFE memo to Executive: aim
to close scheme as soon as
possible
3 Feb 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman to
Chris Stewart regarding an
amendment to the submission
on closure of RHI - urgent
procedures; email reply from
Chris Stewart to Stuart
Wightman requesting further
amendment as ministerial
preference is to proceed
without consultation
3 Feb 2016 Submission from Chris Stewart
to Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re closure of RHI – urgent
procedures
3 Feb 2016 Email from Andrew Crawford
to Johnston and Aidan McAteer
attaching amended DFE memo
to Executive
3 Feb 2016 Emails between Timothy Cairns
and Chris  Stewart re timetable
3 Feb 2016 Emails between Stuart
Wightman, Chris Stewart, John
Mills and Timothy Cairns re
RHI closure timeline
3 Feb 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
Stuart Wightman re further
amendments to submission
3 Feb 2016 Email from John Mills to Stuart
Wightman re drafting
regulations
3 Feb 2016 Emails between Andrew
Crawford, Timothy Johnston
and Aidan McAteer reRHI
draft memo to FM and dFM
3 Feb 2016 Emails from Timothy Cairns
to Timothy Johnston, Richard
Bullick and Andrew Crawford
attaching draft paper on RHI
closure – Executive approval;
version with Timothy Cairns’
tracked changes
3 Feb 2016 Email exchange between
Timothy Cairns and Andrew 
Crawford re drafting of
submission and memo to
the Executive
3 Feb 2016 Emails between Chris Stewart,
John Mills and Stuart Wightman
re response to AQW from
Steven Agnew re closure of
RHI scheme
3 Feb 2016 Draft email by Bernie Brankin
to Michelle Scott seeking
timeline of engagement with
HMT and profiling AME
3 Feb 2016 Emails between Nicola Harron
and RHI accreditation re
update on applications
3 Feb 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
Stuart Wightman re RHI
closure without consultation
3 Feb 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to
Edmund Ward and Gareth
John re request from DETI
to increase audits
3 Feb 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Mike Brennan re revised
urgent procedure paper
3 Feb 2016 Emails between Mark
Compston and Teri Clifton re
Mr McNaughton’s RHI
application
3 Feb 2016 Email from Michael Woods
to Andrew McCormick re
inspection of RHI non
domestic installations
3 Feb 2016 Submission from Chris Stewart
to Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re closure of RHI – urgent
procedures
3-4 Feb 2016 Emails between Eugene
Rooney, Michael Woods, Stuart
Wightman and others re
inspection of RHI installations
and Action Renewables
4 Feb 2016 Emails between Chris Stewart
and Andrew McCormick and
others attaching further drafts
of the letter to go fromAndrew
McCormick to HOCS
4 Feb 2016 Emails between Teri Clifton,
Mark Compston and Seamus
Hughes re McNaughton
application
4 Feb 2016 Email from Timothy Cairns
to Chris Stewart forwarding
3 February 2016 submission
with his amendments
4 Feb 2016 Email from Linda McIlwrath
(obo Chris Stewart) to
Timothy Cairns and Private
Office attaching submission
re closure of RHI – urgent
procedures
4 Feb 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
Andrew McCormick and
Eugene Rooney re Timothy
Cairn’s amendments
4 Feb 2016 Email from Timothy Cairns
to Sean Kerr giving his
clearance on submission
on closure of RHI Scheme
4 Feb 2016 Email from Andrew Crawford
to Timothy Cairns showing
Andrew McCormick had
circulated 3 February 2016
submission to HOCS and DFP
4 Feb 2016 Emails between Timothy Cairns
and Andrew McCormick re
circulation of 3 February 2016
submission
4 Feb 2016 Email exchange between
Andrew McCormick, Chris
Stewart and Stuart Wightman
re GB scheme
4 Feb 2016 Email from Bernie Brankin
to Trevor Cooper attachng
AME forecast for Chancellors
budget 2016
4 Feb 2016 Email from Bernie Brankin
to Trevor Cooper attaching
RHI AME requirements
4 Feb 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Trevor Cooper replying to
queries on (1) risk to RDEL
in current financial year and
(2) when DfP first engaged
with HMT; email from Trevor
Cooper to Andrew McCormick
and others with Michelle
Scott’s answers
4 Feb 2016 Email from Bernie Brankin to
Trevor Cooper re RHI timeline
on engagement with DECC
4 Feb 2016 Email from Chris Stewart
to Andrew McCormick re
update on proposed
reform of the RHI scheme
4 Feb 2016
Email from Chris Stewart to
Timothy Cairns and Private
Office attaching submission
re closure of RHI; forwarded
to HOCS and others with a
mail stating “sent to Emer 
and Michelle” (DOF-36693)
4 Feb 2016
Letter from Amber Rudd 
to Jonathan Bell (followed
 by DECC consultation paper)
4 Feb 2016
Email from Mike Brennan to
Andrew Crawford and Glynis
Aiken re RHI closure  –
executive approval 
attaching submissions
4-5 Feb 2016
Emails between Eugene
Rooney and Linda McIlwrath re
Energywise asework follow-up
meeting
4 Feb 2016
Email from Timothy Cairns to
Timothy Johnston, Andrew
Crawford & Richard Bullick 
attaching submission from
Chris Stewart on closure of
RHI - urgent procedures,
asking if paper can be issued
to the Executive
4 Feb 2016
Email from Michelle Scott
to Trevor Cooper responding 
to his questions on RHI
4 Feb 2016
Emails between Seamus
Hughes, John Batch and Nigel
McCormick re biomass versus
natural gas heating attaching
report from Carella Laminate
Systems
4 Feb 2016 Email from John Batch to
sustainable development
tenders re biomass versus
natural gas heating and
lighting upgrade
assessment for Carella
Laminate Systems Ltd
4 Feb 2016 Email from John Batch to
Seamus Hughes re biomass
v natural gas heating and 
lighting upgrade
assessment for Carella
Laminate Systems Ltd
4 Feb 2016 Submission from Chris Stewart
to Timothy Cairnsand Jonathan
Bell re closure of RHI – urgent
procedures
4 Feb 2016 Email from John Batch to
Seamus Hughes re biomass
versus natural gas heating
and tiering
4 Feb 2016 Email from IES to Seamus
Hughes re McGuckian biomass
project – planning permission
4 Feb 2016 Emails between Deborah
Cummings, Chris Osborne,
Wesley Aston and Andrew
Crawford re UFU NIRO press
release with attachment
4 Feb 2016 Emails between Chris Osborne
and Paul Frew re UFU/Simple
Power/wind NI letter sent to
DETI Minister
5 Feb 2016 Emails between Timothy Cairns
and Andrew Crawford re
circulation of 3 February 2016
submission
5 Feb 2016 Email from Eugene Rooney to
Michael Woods with question
re submission to HOCS 
5 Feb 2016 Submission from Chris Stewart
to Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re EnergyWise scheme -
update on progress and
funding streams
5 Feb 2016 Emails between Chris Stewart,
Timothy Cairns and Andrew
McCormick re closure of scheme
5 Feb 2016 Email from Trevor Cooper to
Lee-Anne Hutchinson 
confirming he is content with
updated RHI Casework
minutes
5 Feb 2016 Request from Jonathan Bell
to Executive for a decision
by urgent procedure –
closure of the RHI scheme
5 Feb 2016 Submission from Neill Jackson
to PS/First Minister and PS/
deputy First Minister re DETI
urgent decision request:
closure of the RHI scheme
5 Feb 2016 Email from Michael Woods
to Dovile Bagdonaite re
inspection of RHI non
domestic installations
5 Feb 2016 Handwritten notes by Seamus
Hughes of meeting with Ofgem
5 Feb 2016 Email from Michael Woods to
David Saunders and Dovile
Bagdonaite forwarding email
from Eugene Rooney re
inspection of RHI non-domestic
installations
5 Feb 2016 Letter from DSO to Helen
Vaughan re draft regulations
5 Feb 2016 Email from Lynn McBride to
Gail Anderson and Helen
Vaughan re validated copy
of draft Regulations
5 Feb 2016 Email from Helen Vaughan to
John Mills, Stuart Wightman,
Seamus Hughes and others
attaching draft regulations
cleared by DSO
5 Feb 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes
to Jane Pierce re timetable
for new regulations
5 Feb 2016 Submission from Chris Stewart
to Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re approval to lay the RHI
schemes (Amendment)
regulations (NI) 2016
5 Feb 2016 Email from Ann Niblock to PS
Ministers, HOCS, Timothy
Johnston and others re
submission from Neill Jackson:
DETI urgent decision request:
closure of the Renewable Heat
Incentive scheme
5 Feb 2016 Email from OFMDFM to
execomm secretariat
attaching note from Jonathan
Bell re DETI request for a
decision by urgent procedure –
closure of the RHI scheme
5 Feb 2016 Email from OFMDFM EIS News
Service to EIS News Service
members re DETI News Release
– proposals to close NI RHI
announced
5 Feb 2016 Email from Damien Hegarty
to all Departmental Private
Offices attaching memo from
Jonathan Bell to OFMdFM re
request for a decision by
urgent procedure – closure
of the RHI scheme
5 Feb 2016 Email from Chris Stewart
to Private Office re urgent
procedure approved
5 Feb 2016 Text message from Andrew
McCormick to David Sterling
5 Feb 2016 OFMDFM Press Release re
closure of RHI scheme
5 Feb 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Cathal Ellis re non-domestic
RHI applications – breakdown
for period 1 August 17 to
November 2015
5 Feb 2016 UFU news release
8 Feb 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
Timothy Cairns re RHI closure
8 Feb 2016 Email from Private Office to
John Mills confirming
Ministerial approval of
2 February 2016 submission
re closure of RHI – urgent
procedure
8 Feb 2016 Letter from Stuart Wightman
to Assembly Business Office
laying the draft regulations
8 Feb 2016 Emails between Seamus 
Hughes and Jane Pierce re
press release on closure
of NI RHI
8 Feb 2016 Email from Private Office to
Chris Stewart confirming
Ministerial approval of
5 February 2016 submission
re approval to lay the RHI
schemes (amendment)
regulations (NI) 2016
8-9 Feb 2016 Submission from Jonathan Bell
to First Minister and deputy
First Minister re request for a
decision by urgent procedure -
closure of the RHI scheme;
memo from OFMDFM to
confirm content with
submission
8 Feb 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Chris Stewart
and Eugene Rooney re
draft speaking note for
ETI Committee
8 Feb 2016 Email from John Mills to
Eugene Rooney, Andrew
McCormick and Chris
Stewart re speaking note
for ETI Committee
8 Feb 2016 Email discussion between
Clive McFarland and Timothy
Cairns re complaint
8 Feb 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Seamus Hughes attaching
email from Damien Hegarty
to Jim McManus re: closure
of RHI scheme and draft
regulations
8 Feb 2016 Email from Brian Moreland of
Moy Park to DAERA private
office requesting meeting
with Michelle O'Neill
8 Feb 2016 Email from Mark Anderson
to Chris Johnston forwarding
press release
8 Feb 2016 Email from John Martin of
Gordonall Farms to various
members forwarding the
DETI press release
8 Feb 2016 Internal DETI emails re calls
from suppliers/installers
stating boilers already ordered
won’t be delivered in time
8 Feb 2016 Emails between John Mills 
and Andrew McCormick re
email from John McCallister
MLA to DETI private office
regarding closure date
8 Feb 2016 Email from John Mills to Andrew
McCormick and Chris Stewart
re enquiries re closure of the
scheme
8 Feb 2016 Emails between Fergal Hegarty
and Seamus Hughes re RHI
closure
8 Feb 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Alan Hegan re closure of RHI
scheme
8 Feb 2016 Emails between David
Hamilton and Seamus Hughes
re preliminary accreditation
8 Feb 2016 Email to Jonathan Bell from
FG Plumbing requesting
clarification on the date for
closure of the RHI scheme
8 Feb 2016 Email chain regarding APG
meeting on bioenergy in NI
8 Feb 2016 Email from Mike Mullan to
David Mark re NI RHI changes
8 Feb 2016 Emails between David Mark,
Mike Mullan, David Gibson
and Alan Gibson re RHI press
release
8 Feb 2016 Emails between John
McCallister, DETI Private Office,
Damien Hegarty and John Mills
re RHI closure
8 Feb 2016 Invitation advice template
for meeting request from
Moy Park to meet Michelle
O'Neill to discuss RHI
8 Feb 2016 Emails between Jim Clarke, 
Seamus Hughes and 
sustainable development
team re RHI closure
8 Feb 2016 Email from Sean Kerr to Gillian
Cahoon, James Ingram and
private office DETI re request
from Connel McMullan of
Alternative Heat to meet with
Jonathan Bell re RHI closure
9 Feb 2016 Public Spending Directorate
(PSD) topical questions
briefing and agreed lines to
take in relation to the RHI
9 Feb 2016 Agenda for fortnightly meeting
between OFMdFM, SpAds and
HOCS
9 Feb 2016 Email from OFMDFM to DETI
Private Office responding
to submssion to close RHI
scheme 
9 Feb 2016 Email from OFMDFM to
Execomm secretariat 
attaching note from Jonathan
Bell re DETI request for a
decision by urgent procedure –
closure of the RHI scheme
9 Feb 2016 Email from Michelle Scott
to Emer Morelli re lines 
to take on RHI
9 Feb 2016 Query from ETI Committee
to John Mills
9 Feb 2016 Emails between Timothy
Johnston and Timothy Cairns
re Arlene Foster's need to
speak to Jonathan Bell before
his question time re RHI
9 Feb 2016 Email from Leona Edgar to
Timothy Johnson, Richard
Bullick, Stephen Brimstone
and John Robinson forwarding
PA Release – OFMDFM -
Economy Minister urges probe
after early closure of renewable
energy scheme
9 Feb 2016 Extracts from Hansard Report,
NI Assembly, 9 February 2016
9 Feb 2016 Minutes of HOCS meeting
with OFMDFM and SpAds
9 Feb 2016 Text messages between
Andrew McCormick and
Timothy Cairns
9 Feb 2016 Extract from First Minister’s
Diary
9 Feb 2016 Extract from deputy First
Minister’s diary
9 Feb 2016 Chair’s brief from Jim McManus
to Patsy McGlone for ETI
Committee meeting
9 Feb 2016 ETI Committee – outstanding
department issues from
meetings, action list and
outstanding actions from
previous meetings
9 Feb 2016 Assembly oral questions due
for answer: request from
T Clarke, DUP for an update
on RHI; emails between John
Mills, Stuart Wightman and
others responding to question
9 Feb 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Terence Patton re RHI closure
9-12 Feb 2016 Emails between Brendan
McVeigh and Seamus
Hughes re closure of RHI
9 Feb 2016 Emails between Jacinta
Parkhill and Mike Mullan 
re UFU statement
9 Feb 2016 Email from Alan Gibson
to Mike Mullan, David
Gibson and David Mark
re Ian Marshall - update
9 Feb 2016 Emails between Ian Marshall
and David Gibson, Mike Mullan
and David Mark re RHI lobbying
10 Feb 2016 Agenda for Executive meeting
10 Feb 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Stuart Wightman
and Timothy Cairns re closure
date
10 Feb 2016 Chairs’ Brief for Executive
meeting on 10 February
2016: agenda Item 8: note
for urgent decisions
10 Feb 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to FG Plumbing & Heating re
closure date
10 Feb 2016 Email from John Mills to
Andrew McCormick and Chris
Stewart re closure date options
10 Feb 2016 Email from Timothy Cairns to
Karen Fullerton closure date
10 Feb 2016 Emails between Karen
Fullerton and Stuart Wightman
re draft press release on
closure date
10 Feb 2016 Email from Timothy Cairns
to Karen Fullerton re draft
press release
10 Feb 2016 Text message from Timothy
Cairns to Jonathan Bell
10 Feb 2016 Extract from minutes of
Executive meeting on
10 February 2016
10 Feb 2016 Briefing paper from Michael
Woods to Andrew McCormick
10 Feb 2016 Email from HOCS to Timothy
Johnston re Special Adviser
pay award 2015
10 Feb 2016 Letter from NI Assembly
Agriculture Committee
to Rod Robson re RHI
10 Feb 2016 Letter from Nigel Smith CBI
to Jonathan Bell re proposed
closure of RHI
10 Feb 2016 Email from Roy Beggs to DETI
Private Office attaching email
from constituent re closure of
RHI scheme
10 Feb 2016 Email from Stephen Andrews
(DUP member) to Jonathan
Bell re closure of RHI
10 Feb 2016 Email from Alan Keys to
Jonathan Bell re domestic RHI
10-12 Feb 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
requesting meeting with
Andrew McCormick and
Terence McCracken Innasol
(in response to Terence
McCracken's email)
10 Feb 2016 Emails between Iain Hoy and 
David Mark re heads up info
following meeting with DUP 
and Sinn Fein

10 Feb 2016

Memo from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re NI RHI closure – press
release re closure date
10 Feb 2016 Email from Mairead Higgins to
Assembly Business and others
re minutes of Executive
meeting on 10 February 2016
10 Feb 2016 Emails between Andrew
Crawford, Wesley Aston and
Deborah Cummings re UFU
press release: UFU slams
closure of RHI scheme
10 Feb 2016 Email from James Ingram to
Chris Osborne re letter from
Jonathan Bell
10-16 Feb 2016 Email from First Trust Bank to
‘NI RHI’ email account seeking
confirmation of RHI closure
date
10-19 Feb 2016 Representations to political
parties seeking to keep the
RHI scheme open / extend
the closure date
11 Feb 2016 Letter from Jonathan Bell to
Mervyn Storey, copied to
OFMDFM re closure of RHI;
on 29 February; forwarded  
to Mike Brennan, Emer
Morelli, Michelle Scott etc.
at DOF-42212-4; email from
Mike Brennan to Eugene
Rooney: Andrew Crawford
will speak to Timothy
Cairns; your Minister needs
to send a note to OFMDFM
saying we are keeping the
scheme open for 2 weeks;
Eugene Rooney’s reply
11 Feb 2016 Email from Leona Edgar to
Timothy Johnston, Richard
Bullick, Stephen Brimstone
and John Robinson forwarding
PA Release – OFMDFM –
renewable energy incentive
scheme extended for two weeks
11 Feb 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes
to John Mills re draft SR: RHI
schemes (amendment)
regulations (NI) 2016
11 Feb 2016 Email from Gail Anderson to
Stuart Wightman re draft SR:
RHI schemes (amendment)
regulations (NI) 2016
11 Feb 2016 Email from Gail Anderson to
Stuart Wightman re draft SR:
RHI schemes (amendment)
regulations (NI) 2016
11 Feb 2016 Email from HOCS to Richard
Bullick, Timothy Johnston,
Stephen Brimstone and
others re Minutes of HOCS
meeting with OFMDFM,
SPADs on 9 February 2016
11 Feb 2016 Letter from Jonathan Bell to
Mervyn Storey re closure of
RHI scheme
11 Feb 2016 Email from Timothy Cairns to
Andrew Crawford and Timothy
Johnston forwarding email
from Karen Fullerton to
Timothy Cairns and Sean Kerr
attaching draft press release
re closure date
11 Feb 2016 Emails between Timothy
Cairns, Andrew McCormick
and others re RHI press
release – closure date
11 Feb 2016 Emails between Eugene
Rooney, Chris Stewart and
Timothy Cairns re closure date
11 Feb 2016 Email from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns attaching press
release and draft letter from
Jonathan Bell to Mervyn Storey
re closure on 29 February 2016
11 Feb 2016 Email from Timothy Cairns to
John Mills re proposed removal
of reference to agreement from
OFMdFM on closure date in
letter to Mervyn Storey
11 Feb 2016 Email from DETI Private Office
to DFP Private Office attaching
letter from Jonathan Bell to
Mervyn Storey
11 Feb 2016 Emails between Teri Clifton,
Jane Pierce, Gareth John and
Edmund Ward re NI issues
and NI forecast costs 16-17
to 20-21
11 Feb 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Teri Clifton re risk assessment -
requesting details of number
of audits carried out each year
and the results
11 Feb 2016 Email from Mark Gould to
Jonathan Bell (sent via NI
Assembly communications
office) re closure of RHI
11 Feb 2016 AQW from Chris Hazzard MLA
to Jonathan Bell re date of
closure of RHI
11 Feb 2016 Email from Timothy Johnston
to Stephen Brimstone
forwarding email from Timohty
Cairns with press release re
extension to RHI closure date
11 Feb 2016 Email from Paul McCambridge
of Somerton Nursing to
Jonathan Bell re closure of
RHI scheme
11 Feb 2016 Email to Pam Cameron MLA
from Cool-sky re closure of
RHI scheme
11 Feb 2016 Email from Martin King to
Jonathan Bell re closure
of RHI scheme
11 Feb 2016 Email from Marc McIlveen to
Jonathan Bell re  closure of
RHI scheme
11 Feb 2016 Letter to Jonathan Bell from
Jim Wells: can exceptions be
made for those who have
signed legally binding
contracts to install
11 Feb 2016 Emails between Michael
Hegarty, John Martin, Linda
Walsh, Michael Doran and
Chris Johnston re draft press
release from Irish BioEnergy
Association
11 Feb 2016 Final version of DETI Casework
Committee meeting 21 October
2015 minutes sent to Eugene
Rooney for his signature
to be added
11 Feb 2016 Email from John Mills to
Andrew McCormick and
Chris Stewart re RHI spend
11 Feb 2016 Email from NI RHI account
attaching press release
announcing extension to RHI
11 Feb 2016 Emails between Danny Kinahan
and Chris Osborne re closure
of RHI scheme
11-12 Feb 2016 Email from TVI Community
Development Manager to
Arlene Foster with comment
by Andrew Crawford
12 Feb 2016 Email from Paul Ferris to
Andrew McCormick and
others with Departmental
Board February 2016 –
finance paper
12 Feb 2016 Email from Helen Vaughan
to Paul McGinn attaching 
draft notice for suspension
12 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills
to Timothy Cairns and
Jonathan Bell re motion –
draft RHI schemes
(amendment) regulations
(NI) 2016
12 Feb 2016 Ofgem change request form
re additional funding
for 2015/16
12 Feb 2016 Email from Chris Johnston to
Mark Anderson attaching
draft press release from BENI
12 Feb 2016 Letter to Jonathan Bell from
the National Trust re closure
of RHI
12-24 Feb 2016 Emails between Gavin Mackie
of Larch Field Estate and
Seamus Hughes re boiler
order/closure of RHI
12 Feb 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Iain Bruce re draft
response to media enquiry
12 Feb 2016 AQW 53974/11-16 from Ian
Milne MLA answered by
Jonathan Bell advising approved
applications  will be eligible for
RHI payments
12 Feb 2016 AQW from Daniel McCrossan
MLA for Jonathan Bell about
jobs in West Tyrone impacted
by closure of RHI
12 Feb 2016 AQW from Daniel McCrossan
MLA to Jonathan Bell about
an impact assessment on
closure of RHI
12 Feb 2016 Emails between Nicola Harron,
Alan Hegan, David Mark and
Brian Gibson re RHI scheme
closure
12 Feb 2016 Email from David Mark to
George Ferguson, Derek
Burrows, Stephen Bamford
and David Bailey re Carn
and Donaghmore hatcheries
12 Feb 2016 Email from Stephen McConnell
to Neill Jackson re HOCS notes
of meeting with First Minister
and SPADs – 9 February 2016
12 Feb 2016 Ulster Farmers’ Union Update
14 Feb 2016 Email from Gavin McGuire
to DETI private office re
closure of RHI/block DETI's
decision to close RHI
14-15 Feb 2016 Email from Geraldine
Cowan-Smyth to DETI and
Seamus Hughes’ response re
closure of RHI 
15 Feb 2016 DETI emails: additional budget
required for consultancy spend
(RHI audit); initial synopsis of
issues identified by audit
review with comments
15 Feb 2016 Email from Paul Ferris to
Andrew McCormick and
others re amended synopsis
of Departmental Board
February 2016 finance paper
15 Feb 2016 Email from Janice Hill to HOCS
and others attaching memo
from Andrew McCormick
15 Feb 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman to
Teri Clifton confirming telecon
between DETI and Ofgem on
review of RHI
15 Feb 2016 Extracts from Hansard Report,
NI Assembly, 15 February 2016
15 Feb 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Janice Hill re arranging
meeting with Moy Park
15 Feb 2016 Email from Philip Hughes
Plumbing and Heating to DETI
re date of closure of RHI
15 Feb 2016 Letter from Stuart Wightman
to Kathy McVeigh re closure
of RHI schemes
15 Feb 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to John Mills re RHI closing
date/biomass requirement
for Moypark
16 Feb 2016 Handwritten notes of
teleconference with DECC
16 Feb 2016 Email from Gareth John from
Teri Clifton re wording for joint
DETI/Ofgem audit review
16 Feb 2016 Letter from Chris Poulton to
John Mills re administrative
arrangements for
non-domestic RHI
16 Feb 2016 Email from Bernie Brankin
to Trevor Cooper re funding
for RHI audit and PCI
16 Feb 2016 Note of teleconference
meeting between DETI
and Ofgem re RHI
16 Feb 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Michael Woods re joint
DETI/Ofgem audit review
16 Feb 2016 Emails between Timothy Cairns
and Andrew McCormick re
memo to HOCS
16 Feb 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman 
to Timothy Cairns attaching
documents referred to in
Andrew McCormick’s memo
to HOCS
16 Feb 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Chris Poulton confirming
joint DETI/Ofgem audit review
16 Feb 2016 Email from Kelley to Jonathan
Bell
16 Feb 2016 Email from Aaron Connolly to
Sean Kerr re eligibility for RHI
after closure, with response
from Stuart Wightman
17 Feb 2016 Emails between Richard Gregg,
David Mark and Nicola Harron
re proforma/PO number
17 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re NI RHI closure – notice
of closure
17 Feb 2016 Draft letter from Ofgem to
John Mills re administrative
arrangements agreement
17 Feb 2016 Briefing note by John Mills for
Andrew McCormick’s meeting
with Moy Park
17 Feb 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman to
John Mills re Innasol request
for meeting with Minister
17 Feb 2016 Invitation to all members of
the UFU Rural Enterprise
Committee to their next
meeting on 3 March 2016
18 Feb 2016 Email from RHI email address
attaching notice of suspension
18 Feb 2016 Email from Private Office to
John Mills confirming
Ministerial approval of
17 February 2016 submission
18 Feb 2016 Email from Timothy Cairns
to Andrew McCormick re
delay in 2015 regulations
18 Feb 2016 Ofgem RHI Non-domestic
Board meeting - scheme
board overview
18 Feb 2016 Email from NI RHI to
unidentified recipients
re notice of suspension
18 Feb 2016 Email from Steven Agnew
MLA to Andrew McCormick
forwarding emails from
Esther Smith and Deborah
Cummings and Louise Dun
woody;  Andrew McCormick
sends them to Stuart Wight
man for advice; Seamus
Hughes replies to Andrew
McCormick
18 Feb 2016 Letter from Peter Mc Crossan
to Jonathan Bell re closure of
RHI scheme
18 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re correspondence from
Margaret Ritchie MP
18-23 Feb 2016 Emails between David Mark,
Andrew McCormick and John
Mills re follow up to meeting
18 Feb 2016 Email from Terence McCracken
(Innasol) to Andrew McCormick
re follow up to meeting
18 Feb 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Teri Clifton re non-domestic
RHI – management of
applications towards the
closing date
18 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re COR 0055 2016 RHI
– with annotations and
Minister's approval
18 Feb 2016 Emails between Mhairi
McQuillan and Teri Clifton
re forecasting of
application numbers
18 Feb 2016 Emails between Jane Pierce,
Karen Roe, Callum Green,
Alex Noonoo, Sarah Diver,
Mhairi McQuillan and Teri
Clifton re draft email to
applicants re missing
bank information
18 Feb 2016 Emails between Gareth John,
Teri Clifton and Brian
Dunford re contingency
plans for 27-29 February
18 Feb 2016 Emails between Mhairi
McQuillan, Teri Clifton and
Jane Pierce and others re
draft email to applicants
re missing bank information
18 Feb 2016 Email from Chris Johnston
to himself re DECC report
18 Feb 2016 Internal Ofgem emails re
publication of DETI notice
on the website, increase in
queries and heat loads
19 Feb 2016 Draft minutes of the
Executive meeting held
on 10 February 2016
19 Feb 2016 Permanent Secretary Group
meeting – draft minutes
19 Feb 2016 Email from Mark George to
Angelique Welsh confirming
that Ricardo can conduct 
eight audits
19 Feb 2016 Text message from Andrew
McCormick to Chris Stewart
19 Feb 2016 AQW from Stephen Agnew MLA
to Jonathan Bell re the
rationale for the change to RHI
19 Feb 2016 AQW from Chris Lyttle MLA to
Jonathan Bell re the rational
for closure of RHI
19 Feb 2016 AQW from Barry McElduff MLA
to Jonathan Bell re R&S Biomass
19 Feb 2016 AQW from Fearghal McKinney
MLA to Jonathan Bell re jobs at
risk with closure of RHI
19 Feb 2016 Email from Fergal Hegarty of
Alternative Heat to Seamus
Hughes re additional heat
loads
19 Feb 2016 AQW from Adrian Cochrane
-Watson MLA to Jonathan Bell
re the impact of closure of RHI
19-20 Feb 2016 Emails between Stuart
Wightman and Seamus Hughes
re freedom of information
request from Sam McBride
19 Feb 2016 AQW from Joanne Dobson MLA
to Jonathan Bell re when
concerns over RHI were
brought to his attention
21 Feb 2016 Email from Chris Johnston to
Michael Doran re all party
working group presentation
22 Feb 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes
to Alan Hegan with link to
legislation
22 Feb 2016 Letter from Stuart Wightman
to Iain Hoy of CBI in response
to his email re budgetary
pressures on DETI
22 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re correspondence from
FG Plumbing
22 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re correspondence from
Jim Wells MLA and Roy Beggs; 
with annotations
22 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re correspondence from
CBI; with annotations
22 Feb 2016 Letter from Paul Givan MLA to
Jonathan Bell re suspension of
RHI Scheme
22 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re correspondence from
John McCallister MLA; with
annotations
22 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re correspondence from
the National Trust; with
annotations
22 Feb 2016 AFBI presentation – the
potential for bioenergy in NI
22 Feb 2016 Email from John Mills to Andrew
McCormick and Chris Stewart
re Meeting with representation
from Moy Park on 19 February
22 Feb 2016 Emails between Seamus
Hughes and John Mills re
request from Connel McMullan
for meeting with the Minister
22 Feb 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to
Seamus Hughes re non-
domestic RHI – management
of applications towards the
closing date
22 Feb 2016 Emails between Tommy
Moody, Mark George and
Sarah Russell re NI stats
report 15 February 2016
23 Feb 2016 Email from John Mills to David
Mark re follow-up from meeting
between DETI and Moy Park
23 Feb 2016 Ofgem Management
Committee meeting notes
23 Feb 2016 Email from Bernie Brankin to
Trevor Cooper attaching last
forecasts from Energy at 28th
January 2016 based on scheme
closing at 31st March 2016
23 Feb 2016 Minutes of the ETI Committee
meeting held on 16 February
2016
23 Feb 2016 Chair’s brief from Jim McManus
to Patsy McGlone for ETI
Committee meeting  held on
23 February 2016
23 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re correspondence from
F G Plumbing; with annotations
23 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re correspondence from
Mr Dawson
23 Feb 2016 Email from Graeme Cather
of Irwin Feeds Ltd to Seamus
Hughes re accreditation
23 Feb 2016 Email from Jeffrey Donaldson
MP to Jonathan Bell re
Larchfield Estate
23 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re correspondence from
Assembly Agriculture
Committee
23 Feb 2016 Email from DETI press office to
Timothy Cairns re media query
from Banbridge Chronicle
24 Feb 2016 Email from Paul Montgomery
to Lucy Marten re fuel versus
oil costs over time
24 Feb 2016 AQW from Joanne Dobson
MLA re closure of RHI
24 Feb 2016 AQW from Fearghal McKinney
MLA re impact on closure of
RHI on rural communities
24-25 Feb 2016 Emails between Nicola
Harron of Hegan Biomass 
and Seamus Hughes re
preliminary accreditation
24 Feb 2016 UFU Executive Committee
President’s Report
25 Feb 2016 AQW from Chris Lyttle MLA
to Jonathan Bell re financial
loss due to closure of RHI
25 Feb 2016 Email from Laura McCoy to
Iain McFarlane and others
attaching Departmental
Audit Committee papers
for meeting on 2 March 2016
26 Feb 2016 Submission from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re udate on proposed
changes to GB Renewable Heat
Incentive (RHI)
26 Feb 2016 Submission from Stuart
Wightman to Timothy Cairns
and Jonathan Bell re query
from the ETI Committee in
relation to closure of the RHI
26 Feb 2016 DETI emails: RHI report for
review outlining interim
conclusions on objectives
1 & 2 of the audit
26 Feb 2016 Memo from Michael Woods
to Stuart Wightman and John
Mills re internal audit review
of non domestic RHI scheme
within energy division
29 Feb 2016 Email from Nicola Harron to
RHI accreditation re
commissioning certificate
29 Feb 2016 Email from Stephen Moore to
Stuart Wightman re state aid
decision
29 Feb 2016 Email from Ian Milne MLA
to Jonathan Bell attaching
correspondence from a
constituent re closure of RHI
29 Feb 2016 Email from Stephen Moore
to Stuart Wightman re RHI
state aid decision
1 Mar 2016 ETI Committee minutes of
meeting held 23 February 2016 
1 Mar 2016 Chair’s brief from Jim McManus
to Patsy Mc Glone for ETI
Committee meeting held on
1 March 2016 
1 Mar 2016 Email from OFMdFM to PSFM
PSdFM cc Timothy Johnston
and others re COR-0126-2016
- closure of RHI scheme
1 Mar 2016 Email from BS Holdings to
‘NI RHI’ email account re
extending an existing RHI
installation
2 Mar 2016 Agenda and papers for DETI
Departmental Audit Committee
meeting; draft minutes of
meeting
2 Mar 2016 Departmental Audit Committee
paper: Bytel memorandum of
reply implementation plan
2 Mar 2016 DETI email on RHI state
aid decision
2 Mar 2016 Email from Stephen Moore
to Michael Woods attaching
email chain re NI RHI scheme
state aid notification – phase
2 review non domestic RHI
3 Mar 2016 Email from Arlene Foster
to Timothy Johnston re
draft email to Jonathan Bell
for factual accuracy check
3 Mar 2016 Memo from Lee-Anne
Hutchinson to Trevor Cooper
and others re corporate risk
register
3 Mar 2016 Letter from Stuart Wightman
to BSH Innovative Heating
and Cooling Solutions re
closure of RHI
3 Mar 2016 Letter to Connel McMullan
from Jonathan Bell in response
to his request for a meeting
3 Mar 2016 Letter to John Martin (BENI)
from Jonathan Bell in response
to his letter of 17 February 2016
re closure of RHI
3 Mar 2016 UFU Rural Enterprise
Committee minutes
4 Mar 2016 Letter from Sean Kerr to Mrs
Smith in response to her email
re closure of RHI
4 Mar 2016 Email chain between Chris
Osborne and John Mills re
request for meeting with DETI
4-5 Mar 2016 Emails between Arlene Foster
and Jonathan Bell re issues
including complaint re SpAds
4-11Mar 2016 Emails between Bernie Brankin,
Stewart Wightman and Sandra
Thompson re RHI applications
and estimated payments
7 Mar 2016 Note of the meeting between
Trevor Cooper, Michael Woods
and Dovile Bagdonaite
7 Mar 2016 Letter from John Mills to Chris
Poulton re joint DETI/Ofgem
review of NI non-domestic RHI
scheme
7 Mar 2016 Email from Bernie Brankin 
to Trevor Cooper attaching
bullet points on budgeting
in relation to RHI
7 Mar 2016 Updated lines to take on
need to close RHI
7 Mar 2016 Letter to Brian Moreland from
Michelle O’Neill re a meeting
to discuss the RHI with
Mike Mullan
8 Mar 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman to
John Mills attaching state aid
approval for upcoming meeting
8-23 Mar 2016 Email from Janice Hill to Chris
Stewart and John Mills re
meeting arranged and brief
required.  Email from John
Mills to Andrew McCormick
and Chris Stewart re briefing
on current position of RHI
8 Mar 2016 Chair’s brief from Jim
McManus to Patsy McGlone
for ETI Committee meeting
held on 8March 2016 
8-10 Mar 2016 Email exchange between
Jonathan Bell and Timothy
Johnston re issues including
complaint re SpAds
9 Mar 2016 Email from Doville Bagdonaite
to Michael Woods re actions
from Casework Committee
meeting on 9 March 2016
9 Mar 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Mike Brennan re RHI funding
9 Mar 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Trevor Cooper and Bernie
Brankin with queries about
assumptions for estimated
RHI RDEL pressure for 2016
-17 of £30.6m
9 Mar 2016 Note from Mike Brennan to
HOCS re known financial
pressures the Executive will
have to address in June
monitoring
9 Mar 2016 Email from Bernie Brankin
to Trevor Cooper re shortfall
estimated at £30.6m if two
large biomass plants proceed
9 Mar 2016 Letter from Minister Bell to
Amber Rudd MP re update
on proposed reform of the
RHI schemes
9 Mar 2016 Letter from Chris Poulton
to John Mills re review of
NI non-domestic RHI scheme
9 Mar 2016 Emails between Ben Cupples 
at NIE Networks and  Seamus
Hughes re closure of RHI
9 Mar 2016 Emails between David Mark,
Tom McKeown, John Harrison,
Brian Gibson, and Stephen
Beagan re ventilation controls
9 Mar 2016 Email from Helen Vaughan
to John Mills re relationship
between DETI and Ofgem
in relation to RHI
9 Mar 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Michael Woods re audit
review of RHI - basis of
governance questions;
update on progress
10 Mar 2016 UFU News Release – UFU
welcomes new consultation
on small scale turbines
10 Mar 2016 Note of meeting between
Energy Division and NIAO
on RHI irregular spend
10 Mar 2016 Emails between Seamus
Hughes and Cathal Ellis
re maintenance costs of
biomass versus oil
10 Mar 2016 Letter from Chris Osborne
to Jonathan Bell re new
consultation on the closure
of NIRO to small scale (non
-cluster) onshore wind
10 Mar 2016
onwards
Email from Lee-Anne
Hutchinson to Energy Division
attaching final signed copy of
casework committee meeting
minutes dated 10 March 2016;
email from Lee-Anne
Hutchinson to Michelle Scott
attaching final signed copy of
minutes dated 10 March 2016
10-14 Mar 2016 Emails between Bernie
Brankin and Trevor Cooper
with briefing on February
actual and forecast outturn
11 Mar 2016 Emails between Stuart
Wightman and Dovile
Bagdonaite re ability
to close the scheme
11 Mar 2016 Letter from Chris Poulton to
John Mills re review of the
NI non-domestic RHI scheme
11 Mar 2016 Emails between Michael
Woods and Stuart Wightman
re letter from Chris Poulton to
John Mills re joint DETI/Ofgem
RHI review 
14 Mar 2016 Memo from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re briefing for oral session
with the ETI Committee on RHI
14 Mar 2016 Email from John Smyth to
David Mark re re-siting a boiler
15 Mar 2016 Handwritten note of telecon
between Ofgem and DETI
15 Mar 2016 Email from Michael Woods to
John Mills re research and
analytical requirements
for 2016/17
15 Mar 2016 Letter from Stuart Wightman
to Edmund Ward re 
preliminary accreditation
issues – CHP projects
15 Mar 2016 Minutes of the ETI Committee
meeting held on 8 March 2016 
15 Mar 2016 Chair’s brief from Jim 
McManus to Patsy McGlone
for ETI Committee meeting
held on 15 March 2016
15 Mar 2016 ETI Committee minutes of
meeting held 15 March 2016
15 Mar 2016 Emails between Brian
Moreland, Private Office DARD
and Mairi Patton re meeting
request from Moy Park to
meet with Michelle O’Neill
16 Mar 2016 Email from Michael Woods
to Stuart Wightman re
concerns in reltation to non
domestic NI RHI draft scope
for review of the scheme
16 Mar 2016 Memo from John Simms to
DETI HODs re performance
monitoring to year end 31
March 2016 – DETI corporate
/ business plan 2015/16
16 Mar 2016 Emails between Seamus
Hughes, Stephen Moore,
Stuart Wightman and Adele
Willis re meeting to discuss
RHI and state aid implications
21 Mar 2016 Email from John Mills to
Andrew McCormick and
others attaching draft RHI
work plan for 2016/17
21 Mar 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes
to Green Investment Bank
re closure of RHI
22 Mar 2016 Follow-up email from Michelle
Scott to Trevor Cooper and
Bernie Brankin re profile of
RHI spend
23 Mar 2016 Email from John Mills to
Michael Woods attaching
RHI report for review; Memo
from John Mills to Michael
Woods with version 4 RHI
report for review
23 Mar 2016 Emails between David Mark,
Andrew McCormick, Chris
Stewart, John Mills re NI RHI
- Sean and Anne McNaughton
23 Mar 2016 Email from Mark Compton to
David Mark re Mr McNaughton
application details
24 Mar 2016 Email from Edmund Ward to
Seamus Hughes re non-
domestic NI RHI – draft scope
24 Mar 2016 Email from Michael Woods
to John Mills re RHI report
for review; forwarded to
Joanne McCutcheon
24-31 Mar 2016 Internal Ofgem emails
re data collection
24 Mar 2016 Email from John Mills to
David Mark re NI RHI –
Sean & Anne McNaughton
24 Mar 2016 Email chain between David
Mark, Chris Osborne and John
Mills re Sean McNaughton
24 Mar 2016 Emails between Michael
Woods, Brian O’Neill and
John Mills re RHI report for
review
24 Mar 2016 Letter from Jonathan Bell to
Chris Osborne re consultation
on the closure of the NIRO to
new small scale onshore wind
24-25 Mar 2016 Email from Nigel Dodd’s to
Richard Bullick, forwarding
email exchange between 
Nigel Dodd’s and Jonathan
Bell re issues including
complaint re SpAds
25 Mar 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
John Mills re review of RHI
report
25 Mar 2016 Email from Trevor Cooper to
Michael Woods  forwarding
email from Michelle Scott re
RHI funding and audit checks
25 Mar 2016 Minutes of DETI/DEL/DFP
stocktake meeting
25 Mar 2016 Emails between David Mark
and Chris Osborne re
Sean McNaughton
25 Mar 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Edmund Ward re NI non-
domestic RHI – draft scope
25 Mar 2016 Email from Terence Coyne to
Rachael Linton and others
forwarding email chain re RHI
funding and audit checks
25 Mar 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Trevor Cooper, Mike Brennan,
Emer Morelli and Bernie
Brankin re Supply - DETI – RHI
retrospective, attaching letter
to Trevor Cooper from Emer
Morelli
25-30 Mar 2016 Email from Arlene Foster to
Timothy Johnston forwarding
email exchange between
herself and Jonathan Bell re
key issues
25-26 Mar 2016 Email from Nigel Dodd’s
to Timothy Johnston
forwarding email exchange
between Jonathan Bell and
Arlene Foster re issues
including complaint re SpAds
25-30 Mar 2016 Email from Michelle Scott
to Trevor Cooper re audit
checks have not commenced,
forwarded by Mike Brennan
to Andrew Crawford
29 Mar 2016 Letter from Amber Rudd
DECC to Jonathan Bell
confirming GB scheme
will  not be extended to NI
30 Mar 2016 Email from Timothy Johnston
to Richard Bullick re response
to Jonathan Bell
30 Mar 2016 President’s Report UFU
Executive Committee meeting
31 Mar 2016 Emails between Chris Osborne,
Ian Paisley and David Mark re
Sean and Anne McNaughton
1 Apr 2016 Email from Nicola Harron
to RHI accreditation re
re Ewing Farms application
1 Apr 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes
to Stephen Moore attaching
draft memo from John Mills
to Chris Stewart on state aid
4 Apr 2016 Emails between Seamus
Hughes and Stephen Moore
discussing draft memo from
John Mills to Chris Stewart
4 Apr 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
and Stephen Moore
discussing draft memo from
John Mills to Chris Stewart
4 Apr 2016 Emails between Stephen
Moore and Seamus Hughes
re draft memo from John
Mills to Chris Stewart
4 Apr 2016 Email from David Saunders to
Michael Woods re comments
on various RHI papers
5 Apr 2016 Emails from Chris Stewart to
Michael Woods re discussion
of issues arising from review
of RHI 
5 Apr 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
David Saunders attaching RHI
report for information
5 Apr 2016 Email from Michael Woods
to Fiona Hepper re initial
set of issues arising from
review of RHI
5 Apr 2016 Email chain between Cathal
Ellis and Geoffrey Wilson
(Danske Bank) re RHI
application
5 Apr 2016 Emails between DARD Private
Office, Peter Scott and
Terence Patton re request
from Moy Park for a meeting
to discuss the RHI
8 Apr 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Michael Woods attaching
communications on RHI
budgets
8 Apr 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Stuart Wightman re Ministerial
priority for domestic RHI
8 Apr 2016 Minute of meeting to discuss
Internal Audit Service interim
issues and findings paper on
RHI between IAS and Energy
Division
11 Apr 2016 Email from Michael Woods
to Dovile Bagdonaite
forwarding Fiona Hepper’s
comments on initial set of
issues from Internal Audit
Review
13 Apr 2016 Email from Danny Kinahan to
Chris Osborne re NI Affairs
Committee and reqeust from
UFU to discuss small scale
renewable sector
14 Apr 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
and Michael Woods re query
on RHI application
14 Apr 2016 Email from Michael Woods to
Edmund Ward re non-
domestic RHI – draft scope
14 Apr 2016 Email from Gareth John to
Edmund Ward re non-
domestic NI RHI – draft scope
15 Apr 2016 Memo from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re DETI response to DoE's
'call for evidence’ of strategic
planning policy on renewable
energy
18 Apr 2016 Email from Joanne
McCutcheon to Michael Woods
re initial synopsis of review
carried out by Internal Audit
19 Apr 2016 Handwritten notes of DETI
/Ofgem teleconference
19 Apr 2016 Email from Paul Dolaghan to
John Mills and Jacqui Rose re
DETI business plan 2015/16 –
performance monitoring to
year end 31 March 2016
20 Apr 2016 Email from John Mills to Chris
Stewart re update on fraud
detection measures and audits
20-21 Apr 2016 Memo from John Mills to
Timothy Cairns and Jonathan
Bell re COR 0126/2016 Sean
McNaughton; Timothy Cairns'
approval;  Jonathan Bell’s
letter of response 
22 Apr 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to
Mark Compston re update 
on Mr & Mrs McNaughton
28 Apr 2016 Email from Teri Clifton
to Jane Pierce 
29 Apr 2016 Email from Michael Woods to
Stuart Wightman and Edmund
Ward commenting on the
draft Deloitte independent
assurance on NI RHI report
29 Apr 2016 Emails between Teri Clifton,
Stuart Wightman and Seamus
Hughes re costs incurred for
closure of the NI scheme
29 Apr 2016 Email from Michael Woods 
to Stuart Wightman and
Edmund Ward commenting
on the Ofgem independent
assurance draft report
May 2016 Energy, Telecoms, Minerals &
Petroleum Division Composite
Divisional Plan 2016 - 2017
May 2016 Extract from DfE Ministerial
first day brief
3 May 2016 Email from John Mills to Brian
O’Neill re RHI scheme – letters
from DECC Minister to DETI
Minister from November 2013
4 May 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Brian O’Neill attaching
CEPA addendum report
4 May 2016 Report to the Departmental
Audit Committee prepared
by Michael Woods Re
Department for the Economy
– Internal Audit Plan 2016/17
5 May 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Trevor Cooper re RHI cost
projections
5 May 2016 Email from Laura McCoy to
Trevor Cooper re RHI
forecasting
6 May 2016 Six monthly assurance
statement from John
Mills to Chris Stewart
6 May 2016 Ofgem independent 
assurance report – non-
domestic NI RHI Phase 1;
draft letter to Chris Poulton
6 May 2016 Letter from Philip Rainey,
Chris Osborne and Rob
McMillan to the Renewable
Energy Branch re 24 March
2016 consultation on the
closure of the NIRO to new
small scale onshore wind
9 May 2016 Letter from Andrew
McCormick to Chris Poulton
re Deloitte review of NI RHI
9 May 2016 Email from Edmund Ward to
Seamus Hughes re inspections
carried out
10 May 2016 Email from Alison Clydesdale
to Trevor Cooper re RHI
estimates attaching forecasts
and monthly drawdowns
10 May 2016 Email from Michelle Scott
to Bernie Brankin pressing
for RHI cost projections
10 May 2016 Internal Ofgem emails re NI
fraud allegation; relating to
Stephen Brimstone
10 May 2016 Email from NIRO 2016 DETI
mail box to Chris Osborne
acknowledging receipt of
email re consultation on
closure of the NIRO to new
small scale onshore wind
11 May 2016 Email from Cathal Ellis re
difference in RHI income due
to restructuring tariffs,
November 2015
12 May 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman 
to Alison Clydesdale re budget
for audits
12 May 2016 Emails between Jeff 
McGuiness, Stephen Barrett,
Kirsty McMillan and Karen
Weir re forecast June
monitoring position 25/4/16
13 May 2016 Internal Ofgem email
discussion re NI fraud
allegation
13 May 2016 Further internal Ofgem emails
re NI fraud allegation
16 May 2016 Email from Tomas Wilkinson
to Stuart Wightman re draft
C&AG report 
17 May 2016 Handwritten notes of 
DETI/Ofgem teleconference
18 May 2016 Note of teleconference
meeting between DFE/Ofgem
18 May 2016 Emails between David Mark,
RHI Accreditations, Nicola
Harron and Fiona Walton re
further information in respect
of Moy Parks application for
accreditation to the non-
domestic RHI
18 May 2016 Email from TEO HR
department re Stephen
Brimstone signed Special
Advisor Contract of
12 May 2016
18 May 2016 Email from Michael Woods
to Alison Clydesdale:
attaching draft Internal
Audit report on RHI;
Internal Audit explanation of
rate of return assessment
19 May 2016 Email from Nicola Harron
to RHI accreditation re
Cardwell Brothers
Engineering complaint and
status of application
19-23 May 2016 Emails between Chris Stewart,
Alison Clydesdale, Stuart
Wightman Seamus Hughes,
and Andrew McCormick
discussing comments on
the draft NIAO report
19-20 May 2016 Emails between Edmund
Ward and Stuart Wightman
discussing Ofgem issues
identified through site audits
20 May 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to
Stuart  Wightman re urgent
– explanation needed around
Ofgem to issues identified
through site audits
20 May 2016 Email between Stuart
Wightman and Michael Woods
discussing Ofgem issues
identified through site audits
20 May 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
replying to Stuart Wightman
re urgent explanation
needed around Ofgem to
issues identified through
site audits
20 May 2016 Ofgem and Ricardo meeting
agenda to discuss ND RHI
audits
20 May 2016 Notes of meeting between
Deloitte, Ricardo and Ofgem
re NI NDRHI joint review
23 May 2016 Letter from Stuart Wightman
to Paul McGinn seeking legal
advice on site audits 
24 May 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Alison Clydesdale
attaching early email
exchanges with Finance
24 May 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Alison Clydesdale re urgent
cost control and administrative
changes to NI RHI schemes
24 May 2016 Email from Michael Woods to
Alison Clydesdale re
requirements of phase 2 of
investigation into RHI
25 May 2016 Agenda and papers for DETI
Departmental Audit
Committee meeting; draft
minutes of meeting
25 May 2016 Email from Alison Caldwell to
Julie Sewell re draft CAG
NIAO report
25 May 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Alison Clydesdale re 
analysis on 4,000 hours cap
25 May 2016 Paper by Alison Clydesdale re
update on non domestic RHI
25 May 2016 Emails between Seamus
Hughes, Cathal Ellis and
Stuart Wightman requesting
paper comparing costs of
biomass versus oil
26 May 2016 Letter from Ricardo Energy
to Ofgem re proposal
document for site audits
26 May 2016 Email from Cathal Ellis to
Seamus Hughes re costs
relating to conversion of
biomass versus oil
27 May 2016 Letter from Stuart Wightman
to Paul McGinn requesting
legal advice on potential
annual cap on payments
31 May 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes
to Stephen Moore re RHI
sate aid implications
31 May 2016 Emails between Michael 
Woods and Alison Clydesdale
re initial findings on
domestic RHI
31 May 2016 RHI Steering Group – draft
note of meeting in relation
to RHI held on 31 May 2016;
with draft Terms of
Reference
31 May 2016 Minutes of RHI Steering
Group meeting
31 May 2016 Letter from Chris Osborne
to Simon Hamilton re urgent
need for decision on 24
March 2016 consultation on
closure of the NIRO to new
small scale onshore wind
Jun 2016 Various drafts of the Report
by the Comptroller and
Auditor General for NI –
DETI Resource Accounts
2015 – 2016 with comments
1 Jun 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Stephen McMurray re RHI
note to DFE attaching NIAO
resource accounts 2015-16
1 Jun 2016 Email from Peter Briggs to
Seamus Hughes and Stepeh
Moore attaching chain re
notifying reduced tariffs
1 Jun 2016 Email chain between Stephen
Moore, Seamus Hughes and
Peter Briggs re agreed action
points and EC’s decision that
NIRO revisions did not need 
to be notified
3 Jun 2016 Email from Rachael Linton
to Heather Cousins and
others attaching papers for
RHI steering group meeting
3 Jun 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes
to Cathal Ellis re RHI sealing
of meters
3 Jun 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes
to Stephen Moore attaching
draft Internal Audit RHI report
4 Jun 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Alison Clydesdale re
response to the DoF
comments
6 Jun 2016 Agenda and papers for the
Departmental Audit
Committee meeting
6 Jun 2016 Email from Sean Cudmore,
Policy Forum for NI, to
Timothy Johnston re 
conference on the future of
energy policy in Northern
Ireland – with keynote from
Jenny Pyper –
6 December 2016
6 Jun 2016 RHI Steering Group agenda
7 Jun 2016 Suspected cases summary
table
8 Jun 2016 Submission from Stuart
Wightman to John Robinson
and Simon Hamilton re
correspondence from Sandra
Overend MLA
8 Jun 2016 Emails between Stuart
Wightman and Paul McGinn
re legal advice on: potential
annual cap on payments
including email
correspondence with Alison
Clydesdale and Chris Stewart
8 Jun 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Alison Clydesdale re RHI
information
8 Jun 2016 Email from Chris Johnston to
himself attaching SUBB
presentation
8 Jun 2016 Email chain between John
Fullerton and Chris Osborne
re email to Economy
Committee members
8 Jun 2016 Email from Peter Hall to Chris
Osborne in response to UFU
email to Chairman and
members Economy
Committee
9 Jun 2016 Emails between Stuart
Wightman, Alison Clydesdale,
Michael Woods and Tomas
Wilkinson re RHI information
10 Jun 2016 Email from Edmund Ward to
Alison Clydesdale and others 
re NI RHI review with
attached updated Ricardo
Scope and meeting notes
10 Jun 2016 Email from Chris Osborne
to Chris Stewart re NIRO
and grace periods (non wind)
10 Jun 2016 to
13 Feb 2017
Chris Stewart's
handwritten notes
13 Jun 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
to Teri Clifton updating
him on conversation with
Stuart Wightman
13 Jun 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
to Deloitte re non-domestic
NI RHI phase 2 – draft scope
13 Jun 2016 Email from Michael Woods
to Stuart Wightman and
Alison Clydesdale re key
issues for Ofgem review;
sent by Stuart Wightman
to Edmund Ward
13 Jun 2016 Letter from Simon Hamilton
to Andrew McCormick re
appointing John Robinson
as his SpAd
13 Jun 2016 Letter from Simon Hamilton
to Chris Osborne re closure
of the NIRO to new small
scale onshore wind
14 Jun 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Alison Clydesdale re Non-
domestic RHI review –
Deloitte scope
14 Jun 2016 Email from Gemma Armstrong
to Chris Stewart and others
attaching RHI meeting agenda
14 Jun 2016 Email from Sean McNaughton
to private office, DAERA re
McNaughton family farming
crisis and draft response
15 Jun 2016 Emails between Rachel Linton,
Heather Cousins, and others
re minutes of RHI Steering
Group – 6 June 2016 with
versions containing tracked
changes
15 Jun 2016 Email chain between Chris
Osborne and Chris Stewart 
re NIRO and crace periods
16 Jun 2016 Emails between Gareth John,
Jane Pierce and Teri Clifton
re NI fraud allegation
16 Jun 2016 Emails between Seamus
Hughes and Chris Osborne
re RHI application processing
17 Jun 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Alison Clydesdale
attaching NI RHI draft
Internal Audit report
17 Jun 2016 Email from Alison Clydesdale
to Michael Woods with initial
findings on draft domestic
RHI report
17 Jun 2016 Emails between Chris Osborne
and Greg Irwin re NIRO and
grace periods (non wind)
17 Jun 2016 Emails between Michael Woods
and Dovile Bagdonaite re
media reports update
17 Jun 2016 Extract from memo from
Gareth John to Chris Poulton
and Dermot Nolan, ‘NI RHI –
allegations update’
17 Jun 2016 Letter from Chris Poulton to
Alison Clydesdale re 2016/17
budget, NI RHI joint review,
and administrative
arrangements 
17-20 Jun 2016 Emails between Michael
Woods and Alison Clydesdale
re draft report on
non-domestic RHI
20 Jun 2016 Email from Michael Woods
to Chris Stuart re draft
Internal Audit service report
20 Jun 2016 Email from Luke Hargreaves
to Chris Osborne re NIRO
and grace periods
21 Jun 2016 Emails between Brendan
McCann and Andrew 
McCormick: draft internal
audit report on RHI
21 Jun 2016 Email from Brendan McCann
to Alison Clydesdale re draft
RHI project plan 
21 Jun 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Brendan McCann,
Michael Woods and others re
DETI resource accounts,
attaching accounts from NIAO
21 Jun 2016 Letter from Tomas Wilkinson
to Andrew McCormick re
DETI Resource Accounts
2015-16 draft report on the
RHI scheme with final copy
attached
21 Jun 2016 Various draft copies of the
NIAO report on DETI, audit
of 2015-2016 financial
statements – draft report
to those charged with
governance; with comments
21 Jun 2016 UFU news release
22 Jun 2016 Email from Brendan McCann
to Alison Clydesdale and
others re RHI risk register
22 Jun 2016 Email from John Mills to
Michael McCallion to issue
response to Sean
McNaughton regarding
meeting to discuss RHI
scheme
22 Jun 2016 Email from Brendan McCann
to Alison Clydesdale and
others re draft RHI project
issues log
22 Jun 2016 Email from Brendan McCann
to Alison Clydesdale re DETI
resource accounts
22 Jun 2016 Email from Adele Willis to
Gareth John requesting
DETI auditors have access
to NI RHI data
22 Jun 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to
Jane Pierce forwarding
emails with DETI in March
2015 re DETI costings
23 Jun 2016 Emails between Lucy Marten,
Stephen Moore, Brendan
McCann, Alison Clydesdale
and Michael Woods re RHI
risk register
23 Jun 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
Alison Clydesdale forwarding
RHI risk register
23 Jun 2016 Email from Lucy Marten
to Alison Clydesdale re
RHI risk register template
24 Jun 2016 Email from Brendan McCann
to Alison Clydesdale and
others re draft RHI Steering
Group action points register
24 Jun 2016 Email from Gareth John to
Adele Willis seeking further
information on request for
access to data
24 Jun 2016 Emails between Terence
Coyne, Brendan McCann and
Rachel Linton re minutes of
RHI Steering Group meeting
on 6 June with attachment
27 Jun 2016 Code Governing the
Appointment of Special
Advisers, laid before the
NI Assembly under s8 (4)
of Civil Service Advisers)
Act (NI) 2013 by DfP on
20 August 2013, updated
27 June 2016.  Comprises:
  • Code on the appointment
    of Special Advisers dated
    June 2013
  • Model Contract for Special
    Advisers with: Special
    Advisers – Main Terms and
    Conditions (Schedule 1);
    Code of Conduct for
    Special Advisers
    (Schedule 2); and System
    for Remuneration of
    Special Advisers dated
    February 2012 (Schedule 3)
28 Jun 2016 Report by the Comptroller
and Auditor General for NI
– DETI Resource Accounts
2015-2016 along with the
certificate to the NI Assembly
28 Jun 2016 Emails between Brian O’Neill,
Pauric Higgins, Stephen
McMurray, Tomas Wilkinson,
Stuart Wightman, Tanya
McNally and Brendan McCann
re draft C&AG report
2015-2016
28 Jun 2016 Agenda and minutes for
non-domestic RHI Steering
Group meeting 
28 Jun 2016 UFU news release
29 Jun 2016 NIEA/Moy Park minutes of
meeting re broiler
expansion plans
29 Jun 2016 President’s Report UFU
Executive Committee meeting
30 Jun 2016 Email from Alison Clydesdale
to Andrew McCormick and
others re revised line to take
on NIAO RHI report for
comment
30 Jun 2016 Emails between Julie Sewell,
David Sterling and Mike
Brennan re PAC hearing 
1 Jul 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes
to Stephen Moore advising
Chris Stewart has indicated
an informal approach to the
EU Commission
1 Jul 2016 NIAO Report by Comptroller
and Auditor General for DETI
Resource Accounts 2015-16
(with cover email and media
release from NIAO)
4 Jul 2016 Email from Cathal Ellis to
Seamus Hughes re biomass
versus oil costs
4 Jul 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Chris Stewart re absence of
final Phase 2 consultation
response
4 Jul 2016 Emails from Andrew
McCormick replying to DUP
queries
4 Jul 2016 Email from Timothy Johnston
to John Robinson re
anonymous allegations
about Stephen Brimstone
4 Jul 2016 Emails between John Robinson,
Timothy Johnston, Simon
Hamilton and Andrew Crawford
re obtaining submissions
4 Jul 2016 Notes of conference call
between Alison Clydesdale,
Trevor McBriar, Joanne Adair,
Paul Rose and Frank Groome
re RHI support schemes
4 Jul 2016 Press statement from Simon
Hamilton in response to
NIAO report
5 Jul 2016 Press release by
Sammy Wilson MP
5 Jul 2016 Emails between David
Lawrence, John Harrison
and David Mark re RHI
lack of cost controls
6 Jul 2016 Email from Leona Edgar to
Timothy Johnston, Richard
Bullick, Stephen Brimstone,
John Robinson and others
forwarding transcript of BBC
Newsline interview with Simon
Hamilton and Steve Aiken on
5 July 2016
6 Jul 2016 Email from Leona Edgar to
Timothy Johnston, Richard
Bullick, Stephen Brimstone,
John Robinson and others
forwarding transcript of
Evening Extra programme on
5 July 2016
6 Jul 2016 Email from Leona Edgar to
Timothy Johnston, Richard
Bullick, Stephen Brimstone,
John Robinson and others
forwarding transcript of UTV
Live programme on
5 July 2016
6 Jul 2016 Emails between Chris
Johnston and Michael Doran
re tariff changes
7 Jul 2016 Email from Robert Cope to
Chris Osborne responding
to his email re inquiry into
the electricity sector in NI
7 Jul 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
Alison Clydesdale and Lucy
Marten re timescale for
approaching EU Commission
given the date of PAC
7 Jul 2016 Email from Danny Kinahan to
Chris Osborne advising his
email re inquiry into the
electricity sector in NI has
been forwarded to NIAC staff
8 Jul 2016 Email from Alison Clydesdale
to Marcus Brooks and Mark
Holden re NI RHI – approach
to EU commission
8 Jul 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Alison Clydesdale
and Lucy Marten re RHI advice
- primary checks by Ofgem 
8 Jul 2016 Ofgem letter to Andrew
McCormick re NIAO report on
DETI resource accounts
2015-16
8-20 Jul 2016 Internal DETI email discussion
re drafting letter from Andrew
McCormick to Chris Poulton
11 Jul 2016 Letter from Andrew
McCormick to Chris Poulton
re independent investigation
into NI RHI
13 Jul 2016 ND RHI NI audit strategy
15 Jul 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes
to attaching email chain with
position paper re NI RHI and
informal  approach to the
Commission
15 Jul 2016
Email from James Crichton
 to Teri Clifton, Edmund 
Ward and Jane Pierce re 
an allegation of fraud
15 Jul 2016
Emails between RHI Audits,
David Mark and Ryan 
Turkington re NI RHI site
audit notification - Moy
Park Carn Hatchery 
biomass plant
15 Jul 2016
Email from David Mark to Tom
McKeown, John  Burch and
George Ferguson re biomass
boiler 99kWh uncapped –
John McAuley Rock
16 Jul 2016
Ofgem RHI Non-domestic
Board  meeting - scheme 
board overview
18 Jul 2016 Email from Joanne McBurney
to Malcolm McKibbin re
2016-17 in year monitoring
forecast pressures
18 July 2016
19 Jul 2016 Handwritten notes of DETI
/Ofgem teleconference
19 Jul 2016 Email from Jane Pierce to
Edmund Ward forwarding
email chain re NI Audits
20 Jul 2016 Emails between Gareth John
and Chris Poulton re DETI
staff changes
21 Jul 2016 Letter from Andrew
McCormick to Chris Poulton
re NIAO report
21-22 Jul 2016 Email from Brendan McCann
to Stephen McMurray 
attaching draft audit service
report on RHI for comments
21-28 Jul 2016 Internal DETI email discussion
re mechanisms to prevent
fraud in RHI scheme
22 Jul 2016 Email from Peter Briggs to
Seamus Hughes attaching
NI RHI data for February
spike
22 Jul 2016 Emails between Brendan
McCann, Michael Woods,
Andrew McCormick and
others re management
response to Internal Audit
report on NI RHI
25 Jul 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Sarah Redwood re NI RHI
– approach to EU Commission
25 Jul 2016 Emails between Chris Stewart,
Seamus Hughes  and Stuart
Wightman re re approach to
EU Commission
25 Jul 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Seamus Hughes re RHI
budget 2016-17
25 Jul 2016 Ofgem change request
form re increase in costs
25 Jul 2016 Agenda issued by the UFU
for the Rural Enterprise
Policy Committee meeting
on 4 August 2016
26 Jul 2016 Email from Michael Knight to
Shaneigh Turner re advice on
sharing audit reports with DETI
27 Jul 2016
Emails between Chris Osborne,
DfE Private Office and Susan
Boyd re meeting between
UFU and Simon Hamilton
28 Jul 2016
Letter from Chris Osborne to
Robert Cope re NI Affairs
Committee Inquiry into the
electricity sector in NI – UFU
evidence
28 Jul 2016
Emails between Joanne Mc
Burney, Executive Office, 
Head of Civil Service, Stephen 
McConnell, Joanne McBurney,
Emer Morelli and others re 
request for briefing – HOCS
attendance at departmental
board meetings – budget 
2016 document attached
28 Jul 2016
Non-domestic RHI audit 
report: Stephen Brimstone
29 Jul 2016
Emails between Jane Pierce
and Teri Clifton re NI ND RHI 
audit report for review 
29 Jul 2016
Letter from Chris Osborne 
to the SEM Committee re 
De Minimis Generation 
in I-SEM
29 Jul 2016
NIAO report on DETI,
audit of 2015-2016
financial atatements – 
report to those charged 
with governance
1 Aug 2016
Emails between Chris
Osborne and Robert Cope
re submission to NIAC re
inquiry into the electricity
sector in NI
2-4 Aug 2016
Internal Ofgem email 
discussion re data sharing
3 Aug 2016
Email from Jane Pierce to
Michael Knight, James 
Robinson, Gareth John, 
Teri Clifton and Edmund 
Ward re draft DETI/Ofgem
data sharing protocol
3 Aug 2016
Email from Teri Clifton to
Gareth John re summary of
actions to be taken for NI
3 Aug 2016 Email between Jeff
McGuinness, Joanne
McBurney, Mike Brennan
and David Sterling re 2016-17 
in year monitoring – forecast
pressures
4 Aug 2016 DfE – final Internal Audit
report; brainstorm document
4 Aug 2016 Letter from Chris Poulton
to Andrew McCormick re
non-domestic RHI audits
4 Aug 2016 Emails between Jane Pierce
and Marc Tischler  re data
sharing
5 Aug 2016 Letter to Stephen Brimstone
from Ofgem re site audit
8 Aug 2016 Non-domestic RHI audit report
for Stephen Brimstone
[Issue 2]
8 Aug 2016 RHI site audit programme
report: Stephen Brimstone
9 Aug 2016 Email from Gareth John to
Teri Clifton re NI draft wording
10 Aug 2016 Ofgem emails forwarding an
email from Stephen Brimstone
dated 8 August 2016 re site
audit complete
10 Aug 2016 Emails between Teri Clifton
and Jane Pierce re state aid
transparency advice
3 August 2016
11 Aug 2016 Internal Ofgem emails re
Stephen Brimstone re
closure of Brimstone case
12 Aug 2016 Submission from Stuart
Wightman to John Robinson
and Simon Hamilton re
correspondence from
Patsy McGlone MLA
15 Aug 2016 Emails between Teri Clifton
and Wayne Reid re NI month
end summary – costs
15-17 Aug 2016 DETI emails discussing
October monitoring round
16 Aug 2016 Handwritten notes of
DETI/Ofgem teleconference
16 Aug 2016 Draft Deloitte Report on audit
with tracked comments by DfE
17 Aug 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Davina McCay and Trevor
McBriar re budget 2016
enclosing memo from Mike
Brennan to Finance Directors
17 Aug 2016 Email from Joanne Adair to
Stuart Wightman re state aid
18 Aug 2016 Email discussion between
Stephen Moore and the UK
Foreign Office re state aid
18 Aug 2016 Email discussion between
Teri Clifton and Mark George
re site audits where multiple
boilers have been installed
19 Aug 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Bernie Brankin – RHI
deficit in funding
19 Aug 2016 Emails between Sarah Driver
and Jane Pierce re feasibility
study and costs
19 Aug 2016 Ofgem change request
form re increase in costs
19 Aug 2016 Email from Mark George to
Edmund Ward re NI update
with example NI audit report
22 Aug 2016
Emails between Chris Poulton
and Teri Clifton re 99kw on
risk log
22 Aug 2016 Emails between Seamus
Hughes and Cathal Ellis re
biomass v oil costs
23 Aug 2016 Ofgem email discussion re
costs and audits
23 Aug 2016 DETI Bbusiness case for
additional funding for
Ofgem administrative costs
23-25 Aug 2016 Email from Adele Willis to
Stuart Wightman with
updated October monitoring
round form for approval
24 Aug 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Mike Brennan re follow up
from supply stocktake
meeting
26 Aug 2016 Email from Mike Brennan
to Michelle Scott and Brian
McClure re rates relief
28 Aug 2016 Handwritten notes of
site meeting Moy Park
30 Aug 2016 Email from Alison Clydesdale
to Chris Stewart and others re
draft consultation document
2016 RHI cost control
31 Aug 2016 Email from Patrick Millen to
Stuart Wightman re RHI
consultation document
Sep 2016 Internal Audit Service review
of the RHI financial model
(including drafts)
Sep 2016 DfE – Consultation Paper –
Review of the Non – Domestic
RHI Scheme 2016
2 Sep 2016 Email from Ofgem to Seamus
Hughes re data collection
2 Sep 2016 Email Shaneigh Turner to
Seamus Hughes re audit
reports and further
documents requested
2 Sep 2016 Note of teleconference
between DfE and Ofgem
re RHI
6 Sep 2016 Email chain between David
Gibson, Alan Johnston, David
Mark, Tom McKeown, Alan
Huston and John Harrison
re sustainable use of fuel
7 Sep 2016 Ofgem email discussion re
feedback from PWC audit
of Ofgem processes
7-8 Sep 2016 Email from Adele Willis to
Stuart Wightman and Lucy
Marten re Ofgem
administration costs forecasts
9 Sep 2016 Email from Michael Woods
to Lucy Marten and others
attaching appendix 5 risk
register
9 Sep 2016 Submission from Stuart
Wightman to John Robinson
and Simon Hamilton re
– COR 11970 RHI and NIRO
9 Sep 2016 Draft notes of teleconference
between DfE and OFGEM
9 Sep 2016
Email from Alison Clydesdale
to Jane Pierce re PAC briefing
9 Sep 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
to Natasha Fitzsimons re
further evidence – approach
to targeted and statistical
sampling in 2016/2017  
9 Sep 2016 Email from John McGettrick
to TEO PS Ministers re
INV-1381-2016: request to
meet First Minister
and deputy First Minister
regarding an investment of up
to £26 million in a renewable
energy project by McGuckian
Farms Biomass Power
9 Sep 2016 Emails between Cathal Ellis
and David Mark re CAFRE/
AFBI biomass event at
Hillsborough
13 Sep 2016 Email from Nicola Coulter
to Lorraine Crozier re RHI
financial database
13 Sep 2016 Email from Colette McEvoy
to Louise Oxley re PAC
Briefing
13-27 Sep 2016 Emails between Victor
Dukelow, Andrew 
McCormick and others re
inherent economic
weaknesses in the
RHI scheme
14 Sep 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes
to Lucy Marten and others
attaching note of Ofgem/DfE
teleconference Friday 9
September 2016
14 Sep 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
to Teri Clifton re DfE costs
breakdown 2016/17
14 Sep 2016 Email discussion between
Chris Poulton and Gareth
John re standard of Deloitte
report
14 Sep 2016
Email from Edmund Ward to
Jane Pierce and Luke  Bailey
attaching presentation on RHI
lessons from GB experience,
by Gaynor Hartnell of Renewable
Energy Association
16 Sep 2016
Email from Teri Clifton to
 Jane Pierce and others re
 PAC preparation
16 Sep 2016
Email from Sean Cudmore,
Policy Forum for NI, to 
Timothy Johnston re 
conference on the future
of energy policy in Northern
Ireland – 6 December 2016
16 Sep 2016
Email from Stephen Beagan
to Maurice Macauley re 
biomass payback
16 Sep 2016
Emails between Gareth John
and Chris Poulton re PWC report
18 Sep 2016
Email from Alison Clydesdale
to Stuart Wightman and 
others re updated lines on
irregular expenditure with
tracked changes
19 Sep 2016
Email from Teri Clifton to
Jane Pierce and Edmund 
Ward re PAC briefing
19 Sep 2016
Email from Edmund Ward
to Colette Archer and 
others re independent 
input into RHI review 
process
19 Sep 2016
Emails between Jane Pierce,
Teri Clifton and Alison
Clydesdale re PAC briefing  
and lines to take
19 Sep 2016
Email from Shane Murphy
 to Victor Dukelow re 
Ofgem RHI weekly data
19-20 Sep 2016 Emails between Edmund Ward,
Jane Pierce and Teri Clifton re
audit strategy and data sharing
attaching draft administrative
arrangements agreement
and draft data sharing
protocol
20 Sep 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Michael Woods re alleged
fraud
20 Sep 2016 Email from Alison Clydesdale
to Jane Pierce re PAC briefing
20 Sep 2016 Email from Alastair Timothy
to Michael Woods re RHI
applications breakdown
21 Sep 2016 Email from Alison Clydesdale
to Andrew McCormick and
Michael Woods re updated
lines from Ofgem on
category 4 cases
22 Sep 2016 Email from Trevor Cooper
to Andrew McCormick re RHI
22 Sep 2016 NDRHI non-compliance
investigation sheet/DA
template [Brimstone]
22 Sep 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Brian O’Neill re RHI
breakdowns/PwC charts
22-23 Sep 2016 Emails between Stuart
Wightman, Brian O’Neill
and Tomas Wilkinson re
further RHI breakdowns
23 Sep 2016 Letter from Mark George
to Stephen Brimstone 
confirming installation is
compliant
23 Sep 2016 Email from Alison Clydesdale
to Andrew McCormick re
PWC review and PAC, 
comments ahead of call
with Chris Poulton
23 Sep 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Alan Smith re RHI business
case addendum (version 3) and
tariffs
23 Sep 2016 Email from Alan Smith to
Andrew McCormick re RHI
business case addendum
(Version 3)
23 Sep 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Lawrence Gaw re business
case approvals for ongoing
expenditure
23 Sep 2016 Email from DoF AFMD Returns
to Stephen Brimstone, Timothy
Johnston, Richard Bullick,
Malcolm McKibben, Andrew
McCormick, Chris Stewart and
others re PAAB: alert notice for
PAC hearing – non-domestic
RHI scheme (DfE)
26 Sep 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Colette McEvoy re RHI
breakdowns
26 Sep 2016 Email from Mark George
to Edmund Ward re standard
of site inspection reports
26 Sep 2016 Email from Alison Clydesdale
to Andrew McCormick and
Heather Cousins re simplified
lines to take on biomass
tariffs
26 Sep 2016 Email from Alison Caldwell
to Emer Morelli, Michelle
Scott and Julie Sewell re
HOCS memo to Andrew
McCormick re RHI
26 Sep to
10 Oct 2016
Emails from Edmund Ward to
Seamus Hughes and others
attaching NI RHI Board papers,
terms of reference for NI RHI
board and agenda; actions
from 6 October 2016 meeting
27 Sep 2016 Email from Shane Murphy
to Andrew McCormick and
others re tariffs, tiering and
rate of return query
27 Sep 2016 Email from Nicola Sweeney to
Chris Osborne re meeting with
UFU to discuss Utility
Regulator consultation
on Power NI price control
27 Sep 2016 Email from Heather Cousins
to Andrew McCormick re
tariffs and tiering query,
sensitivity analysis
27 Sep 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Emer Morelli re
sensitivity analysis
27 Sep 2016 Emails between Emer Morelli,
Andrew McCormick and
others re immediate priority
- RHI - tariffs and tiering -
query from DoF
27 Sep 2016 Email from Trevor Cooper to
Heather Cousins re timeline
of Finance Division’s
involvement in RHI
28 Sep 2016 Emails between Peter
Hutchinson, Alison Clydesdale,
Andrew McCormick and Alison
Caldwell re Renewable Heat
Branch handover note from
April/May 2014 (Peter
Hutchinson)
28 Sep 2016 Email from Alison Clydesdale
to Andrew McCormick and
Stuart Wightman re 2011
emails RHI 
28 Sep 2016 Email from Andrew 
McCormick to John Robinson
re Renewable Heat Branch
– handover note - April 2014
28 Sep 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to John Robinson
forwarding Janette O’Hagan’s
email to Peter Hutchinson
dated 12 May 2014
28 Sep 2016 Emails from Andrew 
McCormick to Michael Woods
forwarding Janette O’Hagan’s
email to Peter Hutchinson
dated 12 May 2014
28 Sep 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Michael Woods
forwarding Renewable Heat
Branch handover note
28 Sep 2016
Email from Andrew 
McCormick to Alison Caldwell
forwarding emails between
Janette O'Hagan and Peter
Hutchinson
28 Sep 2016 Email from Michelle Anderson
to Michael Woods re
anonymous letter with
allegations of fraud
29 Sep 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to himself  re RHI investigation
30 Sep 2016 Email from Wendy Johnston
to Andrew McCormick and
Heather Cousins attaching
emails between Janette
O’Hagan and Energy Branch
30 Sep 2016 Email from Wendy Johnston
to Andrew McCormick and
Heather Cousins re
documents for PAC 
30 Sep 2016 Email from Brendan McCann
to Heather Cousins, Wendy
Johnston and Michael Woods
attachmenting further
correspondence from
Janette O’Hagan
30 Sep 2016 Email from Samantha
Young to Chris Osborne
confirming meeting with
office of Utility Regulator
Oct 2016 Assembly written question
AQW 5734/16-21 from Robin
Swann to Máirtín Ó Muilleoir
re detail the amount of
money held in the RHI
contingency fund and its
budgetary source
Oct 2016 Ofgem document: RHI
administration – costs risks
and opportunities for
remainder of 2016/17 
5 Oct 2016 Submission from Stuart
Wightman to John Robinson
and Simon Hamilton re
correspondence from
Jim Allister
5 Oct 2016 Email from Edmund Ward to
Brendan McCann, Stuart
Wightman and others re
re PWC report/next steps
5 Oct 2016 Emails between Teri Clifton
and Russell Ogilvie re closure
of Stephen Brimstone case
6 Oct 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
to Clare Kennedy PWC re
meeting on the 13 May 2014
6 Oct 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Chris Poulton re PAC
request for Ofgem officials
to provide evidence
6-7 Oct 2016 Emails from Stuart Wightman
to Jane Pierce and Edmund
Ward re DFE/ Ofgem follow
up actions from meeting on
6 October 2016
7 Oct 2016 Letter from Chris Stewart to
PAC attaching documents
ahead of Andrew McCormick's
attendance at evidence session
7 Oct 2016 Emails between Alison
Caldwell, Mike Brennan,
Emer Morelli and Michelle
Scott re DOE – nformation
requested in PAC letter of
3 October 2016, attaching
correspondence between
DETI and HMT
9 Oct 2016 Email Chris Stewart to
Andrew McCormick re lines
to take for PAC session on
12 October 2016
10 Oct 2016 Email from Brendan McCann
to Stuart Wightman re possible
questions and responses for
PAC hearing
10 Oct 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Brendan McCann re lines
for PAC/cost of installations
10 Oct 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to
Gareth John re calculation
of costs
10 Oct 2016 Email from DoF AFMD Returns
to Stephen Brimstone, Timothy
Johnston, Richard Bullick,
Malcolm McKibben, Andrew
McCormick, Chris Stewart and
others re PAAB: alert notice
for 2nd PAC hearing - non-
domestic RHI scheme (DfE)(2)
10 Oct 2016 Emails between Wendy
Johnston, Brendan McCann,
Eugene O’Loan and others
re correspondence from
Chair of the PAC/request 
for Janette O'Hagan to
give evidence
11 Oct 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Edmund Ward re urgent
RHI application investigation
11 Oct 2016 Transcript of Peter
Hutchinson’s first
PwC interview
11 Oct 2016 Ofgem internal emails
discussing lines to take
for PAC
11 Oct 2016 Internal Ofgem emails
re letter from Northern
Ireland Assembly with
anonymous allegation
against Stephen Brimstone
and letter from Jim Allister 
11 Oct 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
to Adele Willis re Stephen
Brimstone investigation
11 Oct 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Edmund Ward re Stephen
Brimstone investigation
12 Oct 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
to Chris  Poulton and others
re questions from DfE in
relation to Brimstone case
Circa
mid Oct 2016
Potential questions for Ofgem
prior to PAC appearance 
12 Oct 2016 Transcript of Joanne
McCutcheon’s PwC interview
12 Oct 2016 Transcript of John Mills' PwC
interview 
12 Oct 2016 Notes of informal meeting
between Robin Swann, PAC
and Andrew  McCormick
12 Oct 2016 PAC – Official Report –
Inquiry into Non–domestic
RHI Scheme: Department
for the Economy
13 Oct 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Edmund Ward re
outstanding information
from Ofgem
13 Oct 2016 Email from Gareth John to
Teri Clifton re outstanding
information on NI RHI 
13 Oct 2016 Trancript of Alison
Clydesdale's PwC interview
12-13 Oct 2016 Texts from John Robinson
to Timothy Johnston re
urgent discussion
14 Oct 2016 Transcript of Fiona
Hepper's PwC interview
14 Oct 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to
Gareth John re NI costs
forecast
14 Oct 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Edmund Ward seeking
information re specific
investigation [Brimstone], the
email is forwarded to Gareth
John by Teri Clifton
14 Oct 2016 Emails between Stuart
Wightman, Edmund Ward
and Chris Poulton re Stephen
Brimstone investigation
14 Oct 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Mike Brennan and Emer
Morelli re DfE/DoF meeting
on RHI attaching suggested
questions for meeting
15 Oct 2016 Email from Gareth John to
Edmund Ward re Stephen
Brimstone investigation
15 Oct 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Lucy Marten and Michael
Woods forwarding email
between Edmund Ward and
Stuart Wightman re Ofgem
outstanding information
17 Oct 2016 Text messages between
Timothy Johnston and
Andrew McCormick
17 Oct 2016 Email chain between Stuart
Wightman, Victor Dukelow,
Andrew McCormick and
Chris Stewart reengagement
with CEPA
17 Oct 2016 Note of meeting held to
discuss RHI and seek update
on actions from 27 May 2016
meeting; questions for RHI
meeting with Emer Morelli
notes
17 Oct 2016 Transcript of Davina McCay's
PwC interview
17 Oct 2016 Assembly query number
AQO 487/16-21 from Jim
Allister to Máirtín Ó Muilleoir
re what are the budgetary
consequences of RHI
17 Oct 2016 Internal Ofgem emails re
Stephen Brimstone case –
police contact
17 Oct 2016 Internal Ofgem emails re NI
police enquiry 
17-21 Oct 2016 Emails between Stuart
Wightman, Stephen Moore
and UK Foreign Office re
state aid
18 Oct 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Andrew McCormick re
outstanding information 
from Ofgem
18 Oct 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Andrew McCormick re
pre-consultation on RHI
cost controls
18 Oct 2016 Email from Alan Smith to
Shane Murphy and Victor
Dukelow re RHI CEPA letter
18 Oct 2016 Emails between Iain Morrow
and Mark Cockburn re
NAO report
18 Oct 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick and Tomas
Wilkinson re corrections
to the C&AG’s report
18 Oct 2016 Transcript of Seamus Hughes'
PwC interview
19 Oct 2016 Letter from Stuart Wightman
to Patrick Millen re additional
queries - request for legal
advice on Ofgem's response
to site inspections
19 Oct 2016 Transcript of Stuart
Wightman’s PwC interview
19 Oct 2016 Email from Mike Brennan to
David Sterling re RHI – DOF
lines attaching briefing
documentation
19 Oct 2016 Emails between Lucy Marten,
Chris Stewart, Brendan
McCann and Andrew
McCormick re submission to
Minister – pre-consultation
bilaterals
 20 Oct 2016 Transcript of Chris Stewart’s
interview by PWC 
 20 Oct 2016 Email from Wayne Reid to
Edmund Ward re NI RHI
costs charged per year
20 Oct 2016 Letter from Andrew
McCormick to Robin Swann,
Chair PAC re additional
correspondence in relation
to RHI, attaching emails
between Janette  O’Hagan
and DETI
20 Oct 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Terence Coyne re NI RHI
consultation – fuel costs
20 Oct 2016 Letter from Chris Osborne
to Nicola Sweeney re Power
NI supply price control 2017
20 Oct 2016 Email from Michael Campbell
to Chris Osborne
acknowledging response from
UFU re de-regulation of
Power NI
21 Oct 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to DFE Procurement attaching
commissioning of
procurement plan return
24 Oct 2016 Email from DoF AFMD Returns
to Stephen Brimstone, Timothy
Johnston, Richard Bullick,
Malcolm McKibben, Andrew
McCormick, Chris Stewart and
others re PAAB: alert notice for
3rd PAC hearing – non-domestic
RHI scheme (DfE)(3)
24 Oct 2016 Letter from Máirtín Ó Muilleoir
to OFMDFM re executive
request for agreement by
urgent procedure: 2016-17
October monitoring round
24 Oct 2016 Internal Ofgem emails re
Stephen Brimstone case
24 Oct 2016 Emails between Richard
Bullick and Timothy Johnston
re Stephen Brimstone’s RHI
application
25 Oct 2016 Statement to Assembly by
Máirtín Ó Muilleoir: 2016-17
October monitoring round
26 Oct 2016 Northern Ireland Assembly
Public Accounts Committee
Official Report Hansard
Inquiry into Non-domestic
RHI Scheme: Ofgem E-Serve
26 Oct 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Brendan McCann
forwarding email from Stuart
Wightman re increase in 
installations before deadline
26 Oct 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Brendan McCann
forwarding documents re cost
control and administrative
changes to NI RHI schemes
26 Oct 2016 Letter from Conor Spackman,
BBC NI to Fiona Hepper re
Spotlight programme
26 Oct 2016 Letter from Andrew 
McCormick to Mark Cockburn
26 Oct 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Brendan McCann
forwarding email chain re RHI
and approvals letter from
Michelle Scott
26 Oct 2016 President’s Report UFU
Executive Committee meeting
26 Oct 2016 Emails between Elaine
Chapman, DAERA Private
Office, Ruth Galwey and
DAERA SpAd re invitation
to visit Moy Park with
Moy Park presentation
attached
26-27 Oct
2016
Emails between Janette
O’Hagan and Lucia Wilson
PAC re meeting
27 Oct 2016 Minutes of PAC informal
meeting with Janette O’Hagan
Circa
late Oct 2016
Non-domestic RHI related
communications
[correspondence timeline
document compiled by
Janette O’Hagan]
27 Oct 2016 Email from Stephen Moore to
UK Foreign Office re state aid
27 Oct 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Marc Tischler seeking RHI data
27 Oct 2016 Email from Michael Woods to
Brendan McCann attaching
timeline and minutes of RHI
meeting held 7 March 2016
28 Oct 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman to
Edmund Ward re draft agenda
for following week's meeting
28 Oct 2016 Email from Iain Morrow to
Mark Cockburn re
non-domestic RHI query
28 Oct 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to
Gareth John, Edmund Ward
and Jane Pierce forwarding
minutes of meeting with
DETI on 29 May 2013
28 Oct 2016 Emails between Stephen
Moore and Stephen Clark-
Foulquier re Commission's
decision on standstill
29 Oct 2016 Emails from Kirby Owen to
Willy Rickett including emails
from David Newbery and 
Mark Cockburn re
correspondence from PAC
31 Oct 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
Trevor McBriar and Stuart
Wightman re preparation
for PAC
DFE-175985 to DFE-175986
31 Oct 2016 Emails between Samantha
Turnbull and John Jackson
[Ofgem Legal] re Northern
Ireland police data protection
request
Nov 2016 Draft letter from Stuart
Wightman to Hugh Widdis
re Attorney General advice
on Possible Cost Control
and enforcement options
for RHI
Nov 2016 Draft letter from Stuart
Wightman to Andrew Madden
re Environmental Information
Regulations 2004
Nov 2016 Assembly query number
AQW 6395/16-21 from Daniel
McCrossan to Mártín Ó
Muilleoir re how the RHI
impacted on allocations for
October monitoring round
1 Nov 2016 Email from Marie Collin to
Stephen Barrett, Joanne 
McBurney and Emer Morelli 
re October monitoring round
– DoF – Hansard report dated
26 October 2016 attached
1 Nov 2016 Edmund Ward forwarding
an email chain to himself
between himself, Stephen
Moore, Kate Porter and
Joanne McCutcheon re
Carbon Trust de minimis
loans and the RHI
1 Nov 2016 Email from Marcus Porter
to Edmund Ward forwarding
an email from Paul Heigl
on 5 December 2012
1 Nov 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
to Marcus Porter attaching
administrative arrangements
and update to the 2012/13
parts of the NI RHI feasibility
study
1 Nov 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
to Marcus Porter forwarding
emails from October 2012
re NI RHI performance
indicators
1 Nov 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Brendan McCann re Project
Heat Phase 2 draft report
1-3 Nov 2016 Email discussions between
DFE and CEPA re evidence
for PAC
1 Nov 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to
Jane Pierce and Edmund Ward
forwarding an email from
14 January 2015 re another
example of multiple boilers
1 Nov 2016 Emails between PSNI and
Ofgem re Ofgem Form 81
requesting information on
Stephen Brimstone's
application
1 Nov 2016 Emails between PSNI and
Ofgem re confirming receipt
of reqeusted RHI information
1-2 Nov 2016 Emails between Kirby Owen,
Willy Rickett and Mark
Cockburn re arranging 
meeting to discuss PAC
evidence
2 Nov 2016 Email from Jill Downie to DoF
and Jonathan McNaught re
PSD co-ordinated topical
questions and headline issues;
briefing document attached
3 Nov 2016 Ofgem emails re issues being
raised at the PAC hearing
3 Nov 2016 Email from Julie Sewell to
Brendan McCann attaching
guidance for PAC witnesses
3 Nov 2016 Note of meeting between
Ofgem, DfE and DSO
3 Nov 2016 Emails between Samantha
Turnbull and John Jackson re
closure of police investigation
4 Nov 2016 RHI internal note
4 Nov 2016 Draft version of Ofgem
response to PAC’s request
for documentation
4 Nov 2016 Letter from Andrew McCormick
to Fiona Hepper re non-
domestic RHI
4 Nov 2016 Emails between Shane
Murphy, Victor Dukelow,
Alan Smith, Andrew
McCormick and Mark Cockburn
re clarification from Ricardo on
load factor and tariff band
4 Nov 2016 Contact log for RHI Steering
Group meeting
4 Nov 2016 Email from Sean Cudmore,
Policy Forum for NI, to
Timothy Johnston re
conference on the future of
energy policy in Northern
Ireland – 6 December 2016
4 Nov 2016 Email from Mavreen
Kabagambe to Edmund Ward
forwarding ‘procedure for
compiling weekly reports to
DECC/DETI’ original
sent in September 2013
7 Nov 2016 Email from Adele Willis to
Aideen Martinos attaching
signed assurance statement
7 Nov 2016 Email from Mark Cockburn
to Andrew McCormick
attaching email dated
April 2011
7 Nov 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to Laura McCoy attaching
response from Mark Coburn
re RHI incentives

DFE-301407.xlsm

7 Nov 2016 Email from Adele Willis to
Teri Clifton re Ofgem
administrative costs
7 Nov 2016 Letter from Chris Poulton
to PAC Chairman re evidence
7 Nov 2016 Email from DoF AFMD Returns
to Stephen Brimstone, Timothy
Johnston, Richard Bullick,
Malcolm McKibben, Andrew
McCormick, Christ Stewart and
others re PAAB: alert Notice for
4th PAC hearing – non-domestic
RHI scheme (DfE)(4)
8 Nov 2016 Emails between Stuart
Wightman, Andrew
McCormick, Chris Stewart
and Brendan McCann
re analysis work for cost
control options for RHI
consultation document
8 Nov 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Edmund Ward re action
points from meeting
8 Nov 2016 Email from Chris Stewart
declaring a conflict of interest
re opening statement to PAC
8 Nov 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to
Stuart Wightman re Ofgem’s
evidence to PAC about
their administrative costs
8 Nov 2016 Assembly query number
AQO 610/16-21 from Steve
Aiken to Mártín Ó Muilleoir
re outline the projected
impact of the overspend
on RHI on the 2016-17
Executive budget
8 Nov 2016 Suspected fraud case
closure report
9 Nov 2016 Hansard Report of PAC
evidence session: inquiry
into the non-domestic RHI
scheme: DFE, NIAO, DOF
9 Nov 2016 Memo from Joanne McBurney
to Máirtín Ó Muilleoir re
COR/1259/2016 – RHI –
part input
9 Nov 2016 Emails between Teri Clifton,
Gareth John, Jane Pierce,
and Edmund Ward re
draft email for Gareth to
send round to staff following
cascade
10 Nov 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
Stuart Wightman and Andrew
McCormick re seeking legal
advice from Attorney General
on cost control options for 
consultation document
10 Nov 2016 Email from Terence Coyne
to Andrew McCormick &
others attaching letter to
Mark Cockburn in relation
to PAC evidence session
10 Nov 2016 Emails between Angela Millar
and Claire Kennedy re RHI –
AME allocations
10 Nov 2016 Emails between Timothy
Johnston, John Robinson and
Clive McFarland re draft
press release
10 Nov 2016 Emails between John
Robinson, Andrew McCormick,
Ross Carson, Clive McFarland,
David Gordon, Arlene Foster
and Timothy Johnston re
query from Nolan Show
10 Nov 2016 Email from Timothy Johnston
to John Robinson, Clive Mc
Farland and Arlene Foster
re RHI update attached
10 Nov 2016 Letter from Chris Osborne
to the Single Electricity Market
Committee re SEM Committee
consultation, SEM–16-060,
energy trading arrangements
basis for supplier charging
11 Nov 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
Stuart Wightman and Andrew
McCormick re state aid
11 Nov 2016 Email from Terence Coyne
to Julie Sewell re Policy Group
– six monthly assurance
statement to 30 September
2011
11 Nov 2016 Email from Terence Coyne
to Julie Sewell re Policy Group
– six monthly assurance
statement to 31 March 2012
11 Nov 2016 Email from Darren Weir to
Andrew McCormick re PAC
letter requesting further
information on RHI issues
11 Nov 2016 Emails between Janette
O’Hagan and Lucia Wilson
PAC re appearing before
the Committee
12 Nov 2016 Handwritten notes of
teleconference with Ofgem
14 Nov 2016 Email from Terence Coyne
to Julie Sewell re Policy Group
– six monthly assurance
statement to 31 March 2013
14 Nov 2016 Email from Terence Coyne
to Julie Sewell re Policy Group
 - six monthly assurance
statement to 30 September
2013
14 Nov 2016 Email from Terence Coyne to
Julie Sewell re Policy Group
- six monthly assurance
statement to 30 September
2014
14 Nov 2016 Email from Terence Coyne
to Julie Sewell re Policy
Group - six monthly
assurance statement
to 31 March 2014
14 Nov 2016 Email chain between Jacinta
Parkhill, Mike Mullan, David
Mark and David Gibson re
RHI scheme briefing notes
15 Nov 2016 Email from Karen Boyle to
Teri Clifton re outstanding
ND RHI case closure
recommendations for 
review and decision
15-16 Nov 2016 Emails between William
Rickett, Kirby Owen, Mark
Cockburn, Paul Grimal
and Paget Fulcherand Iain
Alexander re tiering
15 Nov 2016 Submission from Stuart
Wightman to John Robinson
and Simon Hamilton re
update on the Government
response to the consultation
on reform of the RHI
schemes
16 Nov 2016 Email from Terence Coyne
to Julie Sewell re information
on degression point
16 Nov 2016 Emails between Kirby
Owen and Paget Fulcher
re information for PAC
hearing
16 Nov 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
replying to Stuart Wightman’s
queries re audits and heat
usage
17 Nov 2016 Email from Laura McCoy
to Terence Coyne attaching
email from Mark Cockburn
17 Nov 2016 Emails from Kirby Owen
to Willy Rickett including
emails from Terence Coyne
and Mark Cockburn re
PAC hearing
17-21 Nov 2016 Emails between William
Rickett, Kirby Owen, Mark
Cockburn, Paul Grimal
and Paget Fulcher re RHI
deployment figures
18 Nov 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
to Stuart Wightman re NI
RHI urgent clarification
on current arrangements
and other materials
18 Nov 2016 Email from Emer Morelli
to Joanne McBurney and
Jeff McGuiness re RHI profile
18 Nov 2016 Letter of resignation as
Special Adviser from Stephen
Brimstone to Arlene Foster
18 Nov 2016 NI RHI Internal Service
Audit Report
21 Nov 2016 Email from DoF AFMD Returns
to Stephen Brimstone, Timothy
Johnston, Richard Bullick,
Malcolm McKibben, Andrew
McCormick, Chris Stewart and
others re PAAB: alert notice for
5th PAC hearing – non-
domestic RHI scheme (DfE) 5
21 Nov 2016 Further emails between
Emund Ward and Stuart
Wightman re clarification on
current arrangements
23 Nov 2016 PAC Official Report: inquiry
into the non-domestic RHI:
CEPA
23 Nov 2016 Letter from Andrew
McCormick to the PAC
Chairman in response to
PAC's letter of 11 November
2016 requesting further 
information
23 Nov 2016 Agenda for DfE/Ofgem
teleconference
23 Nov 2016 Email from Seamus Hughes to
Edmund Ward re identifying
test cases for enforcement
action
23 Nov 2016 Emails between Andrew 
McCormick, Terence Coyne
and others re draft letter to
PAC following letter to
Andrew McCormick following
meeting on 7 November 2011;
attaching associated
documents
24 Nov 2016 DETI emails re drafting of
letter to PAC
24 Nov 2016 Email between John Mills,
Chris Stewart and Andrew
McCormick re letter from
BBC Spotlight programme
24 Nov 2016 Emails between Stuart
Wightman and Edmund Ward
re NIRHI – audit approach
current risk and suggested
immediate actions
24 Nov 2016 Email sending termination
letter and Handbook extract
to Stephen Brimstone
24-25 Nov 2016 Emails between Andrew
Crawford and Mark Anderson
discussing RHI in emails
25 Nov 2016 Assembly query number
AQW 6749/16-21 from
Harold McKee to Mártín
Ó Muilleoir re what impact
RHI has had on the 2016-17
budget and the projected
17-18 budget 
25 Nov 2016 Letter from Robin Swann
to Mark Cockburn re PAC
evidence session, requesting
further information
28 Nov  to
1 Dec 2016
Emails between Peter Rice, 
Teri Clifton and Gareth John
re costs structure
28 Nov 2016 Email from DoF AFMD Returns
to Stephen Brimstone, Timothy
Johnston, Richard Bullick,
Malcolm McKibben, Andrew
McCormick, Chris Stewart and
others re PAAB: alert notice for
6th PAC hearing – non-
domestic RHI scheme (DfE)(6)
29 Nov 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman to
John Robinson in response to
his query re Manufacturing NI
29 Nov 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Edmund Ward re draft
DfE/MOU
29 Nov 2016 Draft MOU between DfE
and  Ofgem
30 Nov 2016 ‘Lines to take’ drafted by John
Robinson after speaking to
Andrew  McCormick and
David Sterling
30 Nov 2016 Hansard report of PAC
evidence session: inquiry
into the non-domestic RHI
scheme: DoF
24 Nov to
23 Dec 2016
Text messages between 
David Sterling and Andrew
McCormick
Dec 2016 Assembly Query number
AQW 9094/16-21 from
Danny Kennedy to Mártín
Ó Muilleoir – whether any
SpAds, past or present,
have breached the SpAd
code of conduct/practice
in relation to what has
been discovered re RHI
scheme
Dec 2016 Draft Fraud Prevention
Strategy for NI 
1 Dec 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to DFE Private Office with
revised letter to Baroness
Neville Rolfe
1 Dec 2016 Email from Teri Clifton to
Peter Rice and Gareth John
re DFE costs
2 Dec 2016 Email from Chris Stewart
to Stuart Wightman attaching
RHI non paper re state aid
2 Dec 2016 Email from Michael Woods
to Andrew McCormick re PAC
evidence session – letter
from CEPA to PAC
2 Dec 2016 Letter from CEPA to Robin
Swann PAC enclosing emails
and reports.
2 Dec 2016 Letter from Conor Spackman
BBC Spotlight to Fiona Hepper
2 Dec 2016 Further letter from Conor
Spackman BBC Spotlight
to Fiona Hepper
2 Dec 2016 Ofgem emails re sending
letter to PAC
2 Dec 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman to
Stephen Moore re draft RHI
non paper November 2016
5 Dec 2016 Ofgem emails re NI Non-
domestic RHI cases for 
closure – action from NI board
5 Dec 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Michael Woods,
Kieran Donnelly and others
re DfE suspected fraud
notifications
6 Dec 2016 Ofgem emails re NI Non-
domestic RHI cases for
closure – action from NI board
6 Dec 2016 Text message from Timothy
Johnson to Simon Hamilton
6 Dec 2016 Email from Brian Doherty
to Chris Osborne re basic
payment scheme
6 Dec 2016 Email from Michael Knight
to Jane Pierce, Teri Clifton,
Gareth John, James Robinson
and Edmund Ward re
proposed changes to
administrative arrangements
agreement and data sharing
7 Dec 2016 Simon Hamilton’s statement
on planned measures to
stem RHI losses
7 Dec 2016 Email from Stephen Moore to
UK Foreign Office re state aid
7 Dec 2016 Press release from Arlene
Foster
7 Dec 2016 Email from David Gordon to
John Robinson re counter plan
7 Dec 2016 Email from Janette O’Hagan to
Lucia Wilson PAC re Nolan
Show comments
8 Dec 2016
Email from Andrew  McCormick
to David Sterling with transcript
of Nolan Show 
including
interview with 
Janette O’Hagan
8 Dec 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Edmund Ward and Teri
Clifton re update on
suspected fraud case 
9 Dec 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
to Gareth John, Jane Pierce
and Teri Clifton re verbal
update to Stuart
Wightman 9 Dec 2016
9 Dec 2016 Email from Gareth John to
Samantha Turnbull, Teri
Clifton re verbal update to
Stuart Wightman 9 Dec 2016
9 Dec 2016 Emails between Edmund Ward
and Samantha Turnbull re
suspected fraud case 
9 Dec 2016 Email to Edmund Ward and
Samantha Turnbull re NI
case closure report 
9 Dec 2016 Email from Samantha
Turnbull to Edmund Ward
re suspected fraud case 
9 Dec 2016 Email from Edmund Ward 
to Samantha Turnbull re
proposed summary for
suspected fraud case 
9 Dec 2016 Email from Edmund Ward to
Stuart Wightman, Teri Clifton
and others re summary
update on suspected fraud
case
9 Dec 2016 Email from Samantha Turnbull
to Edmund Ward re summary
on suspected fraud case
9 Dec 2016 Email from Counter Fraud to
Teri Clifton re case closure
report
9 Dec 2016 Email from Edmund Ward
to numerous Ofgem staff
re internal briefing/summary
for suspected fraud case
9 Dec 2016 Email from Edmund Ward to
himself re NI RHI infomation
request letter; Edmund Ward
forwards to himself
correspondence between
Ofgem and Stephen Brimstone
from August 2016
9 Dec 2016 Draft NI RHI audit strategy
2016/17 by Shaneigh Turner
9 Dec 2016 Email from Clive McFarland
to Timothy Johnston and
Clive McFarland re press
query
9 Dec 2016 Email from Timothy Johnston
to Andrew Crawford and John
Robinson with draftreponse
to query from Sunday Life
9 Dec 2016 Emails between Teri Clifton
and Mark George re biomass
audit report - Moy Park Carn
hatchery 
9 Dec 2016 Emails between Alison
Hardie, Gareth John, Jane
Pierce, Chris Poulton and
Stuart Forsyth re Nolan Show
9 Dec 2016 Email from Chris Johnston
to Margaret Patterson and
Jim McAdam re query –
renewable energy and
biomass research
9 Dec 2016 Emails between Chris Osborne,
Chris Stewart and Linda
McIlwrath re meeting between
DfE and UFU
10 Dec 2016 Texts between John Robinson
and Simon Hamilton
10 Dec 2016 Email from Stephen Brimstone
to Timothy Johnston re draft
RHI personal line in relation
to allegations
10-15 Dec 2016 Text and emails from BBC
Nolan Show to Stephen
Brimstone and Timothy
Johnston re Nolan broadcast
and texts between Timothy
Johnston and Stephen
Brimstone re response
10-17 Dec 2016 Emails of support from
Stephen Harron to Arlene
Foster
11 Dec 2016 Emails between Richard Bullick
and Timothy Johnston re
reference to DUP party officers
11 Dec 2016 DUP emails re lines to take
on RHI
11 Dec 2016 Transcript of audio tape
provided by Jonathan Bell
to RHI Inquiry of conversation
with Andrew McCormick
11-12 Dec 2016 Emails between Richard
Bullick and John Robinson
re lines to take including
in relation to whistle-blower
12 Dec 2016 Email from Chris Stewart
to Andrew McCormick
re timeline
12 Dec 2016 Email from Linda Walsh to
Chris Johnston re Nolan show
12 Dec 2016 Texts between John Robinson
and Richard Bullick
12 Dec 2016 Talkback transcript Arlene
Foster, discussing RHI
including Janette O’Hagan
12 Dec 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Chris Stewart
and Stuart Wightman re
delay in 2015 regulations
12 Dec 2016 Letter to Mark Cockburn
from Robin Swan re PAC
evidence session
12 Dec 2016 Internal DUP email discussions
and drafting of ‘platform piece’
for Belfast Telegraph
12 Dec 2016 Email from Clive McFarland
to Gregory Campbell re RHI
quotes 
12 Dec 2016 Email from David Gordon
to Clive McFarland re
issues with Nolan
12 Dec 2016 Email from Clive McFarland to
Gregory Campbell re RHI lines
12-13 Dec 2016 John Robinson forwarding
internal DFE emails to
Timothy Johnston, Simon
Hamilton, Richard Bullick
and Clive McFarland re
query from Irish News
and draft response
12 Dec 2016 Email from Timothy Johnston
to Clive Mc Farland confiming
he is content with revised
RHI statement
12 Dec 2016 Email from Chris Johnston
to Rodrigo Olave re case
study with action renewables
12 Dec 2016 Media extract – RHI – Arlene
Foster announces inspections
of claimants
12 Dec 2016 Email from Samantha Turnbull
to Teri Clifton and Edmund
Ward re case closure report
12 Dec 2016 Email from Edmund Ward to
Lucy Marten with draft case
closure report
13 Dec 2016 Irish News report ‘Former
DUP adviser was claimant’
13 Dec 2016 News Letter report ‘First
Minister’s former spad
scheme claimant’
13 Dec 2016 News Letter report ‘Foster
reveals her former spad
benefitted from scheme'
13 Dec 2016 Email from John Robinson to
Timothy Johnston, Richard
Bullick,  Clive McFarland and
others re PAC neutrality
13 Dec 2016 Email exchange between John
Robinson and Richard Bullick
re response to Mike Nesbitt's
smoking gun comment
13-16 Dec 2016 Text messages between
John Robinson, Timothy
Johnston, Richard Bullick
and Simon Hamilton
13 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew McCormick
to John Robinson re cause for
delay in 2015 regulations
13 Dec 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Chris Stewart and
John Robinson re possible
lines to take
13 Dec 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
Andrew McCormick re lessons
earned and comparison with
Project Kelvin
13 Dec 2016 DUP emails re ‘Nesbitt and
his smoking gun’
13 Dec 2016 DUP emails re RHI fact check
13 Dec 2016 Draft letter to accounting
officer re approval and review
of incentive schemes
13 Dec 2016 Email from Robyn Cairns to
Stephen McMurray copying
Mike Brennan and others,
enclosing letter from Emer
Morelli re non-domestic RHI
with minutes of meeting
between DfE/DoF held on
17 October 2016 appended;
forwarded by Mike Brennan
to Alison Caldwell and Julie
Sewell
13 Dec 2016 Emails from Jonathan Bell
to Andrew McCormick
attaching email chain re
request for document:
PS DETI 009/16 – RHI
13 Dec 2016 Emails between Stuart Forsyth
and Michael Knight re media
query response
13 Dec 2016 Emails between Richard
Bullick, Arlene Foster, John
Robinson, Simon Hamilton
and Timothy Johnston re
RHI closure timeline
14 Dec 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, John Robinson,
Richard Bullick and others re
DUP response to Irish News
story on Arlene Foster and
Jonathan Bell resignations
14 Dec 2016 Email from Bernard
McCaughan to Andrew
McCormick forwarding
Janette O’Hagan’s email
correspondence dated
26 August 2013 to DETI 
Mail for Arlene Foster
14 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew 
McCormick to Jeremy 
Gardner commenting on
Janette O'Hagan's email
(attached) and radio
interview; email then
forwarded to Richard
Bullick by Andrew 
McCormick
14 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Jeremy
Gardner attaching letter
to Janette O’Hagan from
Arlene Foster dated
5 September 2013
14-19 Dec 2016 Emails relating to the Janette
O’Hagan correspondence
14 Dec 2016 Email from Emer Morelli to
Sean Kerr and DoF Private
Office attaching copies of
correspondence between
Supply and DfE from June
monitoring 2016 to date as
requested by the Minister
14 Dec 2016 Email from OFMdFM to TEO
secretariat - EXEC-1094-2016:
DFE draft executive paper –
future of the NI RHI
14 Dec 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Emer Morelli attaching
Executive Paper on future
of RHI
14 Dec 2016 DUP Press Office statement
re costs controls/SpAd
interference
14 Dec 2016 Email from Richard Bullick
to David Gordon; email
exchange between Richard
Bullick, Clive McFarland re
response to BBC; and email
from David Thompson to
Leona Edgar (TEO) re Nolan
Show questions
14 Dec 2016 Text message from Andrew
McCormick to John Robinson
re fact check on document
14 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Richard Bullick
and John Robinson re his
memo to HOCS on
28 January 2016
14 Dec 2016 Email from DUP Press Office
enclosing copy of email sent
from Janette O’Hagan to
Minister Foster
14 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick responding to
Timothy Johnston's request
to fact check Nigel Dodd’s’
statement on the
whistle-blower
14 Dec 2016 Internal DUP emails re
press releases
14 Dec 2016 Emails between Timothy
Johnston, Aidan McAteer
and David Gordon re joint
OFMDFM statement
14 Dec 2016 TEO News Release, statement
by OFMdFM
14 Dec 2016 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Andrew McCormick re ETI
Committee consideration
RHI scheme design
14 Dec 2016 Emails between Andrew
Crawford and Timothy
Johnston re UFU press release
14 Dec 2016 Email from Clive McFarland
to Timothy Johnston, Richard
Bullick and Arlene Foster re
Aaron Brimstone
14 Dec 2016 Email from abu@economy
NI to DAERA, education,
finance, DOJ and others
re version 1 draft executive
paper on the future of NI RHI
14 Dec 2016 Daily Mirror report ‘Arlene
faces grilling over heating
fiasco’
15 Dec 2016 Email from John Robinson
to Timothy Johnston, Richard
Bullick and Simon Hamilton
forwarding emails from
Andrew McCormick re
email from Janette O'Hagan
15 Dec 2016 Irish News report ‘Brother
of special adviser benefitted
from scheme as well’
15 Dec 2016 News Letter report ‘Foster
to make ‘full statement’ on
heating scandal to Assembly’
15-16 Dec 2016 Mails from Andrew Crawford
to John Robinson and
Timothy Johnston forwarding
the July 2015 mails from R&S
Biomass Ltd and Balcas Ltd
about forthcoming changes
to the RHI scheme
15-16 Dec 2016 Transcripts of Interviews by
Arlene Foster and Jonathan
Bell on Nolan show
15 Dec 2016 Emails between Mike Brennan
and David Sterling following
Executive Paper on future
of RHI 
15 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Brendan
McCann re Janette O'Hagan's
Nolan show interview
15 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to David Gordon
discussing the details of
Janette O’Hagan’s email to
Peter Hutchinson on
12 May 2014; Andrew
McCormick then forwards
the email to Richard Bullick
and John Robinson
15 Dec 2016 Lucy Marten forwards
Edmund Ward the transcript 
of Talkback which is
discussing Janette O’Hagan/
DUP/Stephen Brimstone
15 Dec 2016 Email from Janette O’Hagan
to Lucia Wilson PAC re
additional info for PAC,
Janette O’Hagan sends Lucia
Wilson her email to Arlene
Foster dated 3 Sept 2013
15 Dec 2016 Email from Lucia Wilson PAC
to Karen Barry and Darren
Weir, forwarding Janette
O’Hagan’s email of the
same date with additional
info for PAC
15 Dec 2016 Email from Lucia Wilson to
Karen Barry, Elaine Farrell,
Darren Weir forwarding
Janette O’Hagan’s email
of same date, which is
forwarding Janette O’Hagan’s
email to Arlene Foster
information@detini.gov.uk
dated 26 August 2013
FW: FAO of Arlene Foster –
helping businesses get
greener
15 Dec 2016 Emails between Clive
McFarland and Richard
Bullick re whether Janette
O’Hagan consented to
release of emails to Arlene
Foster
15 Dec 2016 Email from Nigel Dodds to
John Robinson, Timothy
Johnston, Simon Hamilton,
Richard Bullick and Clive
McFarland re Janette
O’Hagan
15 Dec 2016 Internal DUP exchanges
about whether they had
permission to release
Janette O’Hagan’s email
15 Dec 2016 Text message from Timothy
Cairns to Timothy Johnston
15-19 Dec 2016 Text messages between
Timothy Cairns and
Richard Bullick
15 Dec 2016 Email query from BBC
to DUP re Chris Stewart
15 Dec 2016 Email from John Robinson
to Timothy Johnston, Simon
Hamilton and Richard Bullick
forwarding 'The Detail' article:
further DUP links to
beneficiaries of Stormont’s
flawed RHI
15 Dec 2016 Letter from Jim Allister to
DfE Private Office re
non– domestic RHI scheme 
- queries arising from the
EU Commissions approval
of this scheme
15-21 Dec 2016 Email exchange between
DoF and DfE re rate of
return and value for money
16 Dec 2016 Email between John Robinson
and Clive McFarland re main
lines for press queries
16 Dec 2016 Email of support to
Arlene Foster
16 Dec 2016 Press queries including:
who witnessed confrontation
between Jonathan Bell and
Arlene Foster?
16 Dec 2016 Text messages between
Chris Stewart and Timothy
Cairns
16 Dec 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick and Richard
Bullick re final version
of February submission
16 Dec 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
Andrew McCormick re draft
note for the record in
relation to the BBC Spotlight
programme of 15 December
2016
16 Dec 2016 Email from Eugene Rooney
to Aidan McAteer re RHI
paper
16 Dec 2016 Emails between Máirtín
Ó Muilleoir and Eoin
Rooney re action plan
16 Dec 2016 Media report ‘RHI scandal:
Advisers ‘pressurised
Jonathan Bell’
16 Dec 2016 Belfast Telegraph report
‘Arlene Foster and her
former Enterprise Minister
at loggerheads over series
of explosive claims in
Stephen Nolan TV interview’
16 Dec 2016 Daily Mirror report ‘RHI
scandal: Bell lifts lid on
flawed scheme’
17 Dec 2016 Daily Mirror report ‘RHI
scandal: pressure increasing
on Foster’
17 Dec 2016 Irish News report 
‘Spads named by Bell’
17 Dec 2016 News Letter report ‘Nesbitt:
spat between Bell and
Foster a ‘distraction’’
17 Dec 2016 Letter from Simon Hamilton
to Baroness Neville-Rolfe in
response to her letter of
4 November 2016
17 Dec 2016 Email from David Gordon
to Richard Bullick, Andrew
McCormick, Timothy Johnston
and John Robinson re RHI
statement
17 Dec 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick and Richard
Bullick discussing Janette
O’Hagan emails
17 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Richard Bullick,
David Gordon, Timothy
Johnston and John Robinson
re: record cleansing
17 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Richard
Bullick re RHI statement
17 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew 
McCormick to Richard
Bullick re Janette O’Hagan
and contact with Arlene
Foster
17 Dec 2016 Email Andrew McCormick
to Richard Bullick attaching
letter to Janette O’Hagan
17 Dec 2016 Email from Richard Bullick to
Timothy Johnston re DUP
PAC members and Janette
O’Hagan emails
17 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Richard Bullick
re Janette O’Hagan emails
17 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to David Gordon,
Richard Bullick, Timothy
Johnston and John Robinson
regarding “PAC got the emails
(three in all)”
17 Dec 2016 Email from Máirtín Ó
Muilleoir to Aidan McAteer
measures to reduce costs
17 Dec 2016 Text message from Timothy
Cairns to another (unknown)
enclosing text conversation
screenshots between Timothy
Cairns and Timothy Johnston
re reconciliation with
Jonathan Bell and Timothy
Cairns’ return to DETI
17 Dec 2016 Emails between Andrew 
McCormick, Richard Bullick,
Timothy Johnston, David
Gordon and John Robinson
re record cleansing
17 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Chris Stewart
with proposed amendments
to Chris Stewart’s note for
the record on interview with
Jonathan Bell on
15 December 2016
17 Dec 2016 Email from Chris Stewart to
Andrew McCormick re closure
date of 29 January 2016
17 Dec 2016 Emails between Chris Stewart
and Andrew McCormick re
record cleansing
17 Dec 2016 Email from David Gordon
to Arlene Foster re Jonathan
Bell allegations
17 Dec 2016 Email from Richard Bullick
to Timothy Johnston and
John Robinson re statements
about Jonathan Bell
17 Dec 2016 Emails between Michelle
Scott, Emer Morelli, David
Sterling and others re
DFE initial response to
options paper
17 Dec 2016 Email from Clive McFarland
to Simon Hamilton re 
Jonathan Bell's allegations
18 Dec 2016
Email from Executive News 
Service to Simon Hamilton,
John Robinson, Andrew 
McCormick and Chris
Stewart enclosing press
release from DfE
18 Dec 2016 Email from Clive McFarland
to Richard Bullick re BBC
request for interviewee re
Janette O’Hagan
18 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to John Robinson
re search for Janette O’Hagan
email/response; timeline of
Department response
provided
18 Dec 2016 Email from Arlene Foster to
Clive McFarland re emails
from Janette O’Hagan
18 Dec 2016 Email from Michelle Scott to
Emer Morelli and Mike
Brennan re RHI cost controls
and need for robust business
case, with comments from
Andrew McCormick
18 Dec 2016 Email from BBC Nolan Show
to Clive McFarland requesting
response/ nominee for
interview to discuss
whistle-blower
18 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to John Robinson
re search for Janette O’Hagan
email/Departmental response
18 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Aidan McAteer
enclosing press release/
submissions/ transcript of
Bell’s BBC interview; press
release re Jonathan Bell’s
allegations
18 Dec 2016 Emails between John
Robinson and Richard Bullick
re proposal for Arlene Foster
to stand aside to facilitate an
independent investigation
into the RHI scheme
18 Dec 2016 Email from David Gordon to
Andrew McCormick, with
draft statement for Simon
Hamilton re allegations made
by Jonathan Bell that SpAd 
altered the record
18 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick's private email
account to his DFE account
re response to Sam
McBride's tweet
18 Dec 2016 Further proposed
amendments by Andrew
McCormick to Chris Stewart’s
note for the record
18 Dec 2016 Submission from Chris
Stewart to Simon Hamilton
re Jonathan Bell’s allegations 
18 Dec 2016
Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Chris Stewart
and others re draft 
statement from Minister 
and disclosure of documents
18 Dec 2016
Emails between Emer Morelli,
Mike Brennan, David Sterling,
Michelle Scott and Alison
Caldwell re RHI regularity
18 Dec 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Simon Hamilton,
Emer Morelli, Michelle Scott
and Mike Brennan re
immediate RHI cost control
options
18 Dec 2016 Emails between Emer Morelli,
David Sterling, Mike Brennan,
Michelle Scott and Alison
Caldwell re RHI regularity
18 Dec 2016 DUP emails - media query
re Arlene Foster signing
Regulatory Impact
Assessment in 2012
18 Dec 2016 Memo from Chris Stewart to
Simon Hamilton re interview
with former Minister Bell
15 December 2016
18 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew 
McCormick to Executive
Office and Head of Civil
Service re RHI – interview
with former Minister Bell
18 Dec 2016 Submission from Chris
Stewart to Simon Hamilton
re RHI - interview with
former Minister Bell
15 December 2016
18 Dec 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick and Richard
Bullick re date of cost
control decision
18 Dec 2016 Emails between David
Gordon and Richard Bullick
re Jonathan Bell's allegations
18 Dec 2016 Texts from Timothy Cairns
to Andrew McCormick
18 Dec 2016 Emails and draft responses
to media query re discovery
of Janette O’Hagan’s
3 September 2013 email
to Arlene Foster
18-20 Dec 2016 Text messages between
Timothy Johnston, Richard
Bullick, John Robinson
18-19 Dec 2016 Text messages between
from Andrew McCormick
and Richard Bullick
18 Dec 2016 Email from Lucy Marten to
Terence Coyne and Andrew
McCormick attaching email
chain concerning Janette
O'Hagan
18 Dec 2016 Sunday Life report ‘RHI firms
may soon be named’
18-19 Dec 2016 Email from Janette O’Hagan
to Lucia Wilson forwarded
by Lucia Wilson to Robin
Swann re calls from
journalists
19 Dec 2016 Hansard Report of First
Minister’s statement to
NI Assembly
19 Dec 2016 to
16 Jan 2017
Text messages between
David Sterling and
Máirtín Ó Muilleoir
19 Dec 2016 Email from Jacinta Parkhill
to David Mark regarding
Belfast Telegraph query
19 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew 
McCormick to Ciarrai Conlan
re response to question
from Nolan show
19 Dec 2016 Drafts of First Minister’s
statement in relation to
the RHI
19 Dec 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick and Richard
Bullick re drafting of First
Minister’s statement on RHI
19 Dec 2016 Draft letter from Andrew
McCormick to Robin Swann
re inquiry into the non
domestic RHI scheme
19 Dec 2016 Letter from Andrew
McCormick to Chris Poulton 
re proof of eligibility
19 Dec 2016 Emails between Shane
Murphy, Victor Dukelow,
Alan Smith and Stephen
Moore re RHI CBA and
options report
19 Dec 2016 Text messages between
Andrew McCormick and
Richard Bullick
19 Dec 2016 Email from Executive News
Service to EIS News Service
Executive Office re DFE News
Release – further document
laid in Assembly library
19 Dec 2016 Email from Chris Stewart
to Siobhan Tweedie and
others attaching papers
for Minister ahead of
Assembly business
19 Dec 2016 Emails between Emer Morelli,
Mike Brennan and Michelle
Scott re options for RHI
19 Dec 2016 Email from Tom Forgrave to
Wesley Aston forwarding  
email chain with DETI in
November 2015 re Annex A –
final policy paper on RHI
proposals
19-20 Dec 2016 Email from Timothy Johnston
to Richard Bullick enclosing
email from Alex Easton to
Timothy Johnston re leaked
email packs (PAC)
19-21 Dec 2016 Ofgem emails re drafting
response to letter from
Andrew McCormick
20 Dec 2016 Transcript of Trevor
Cooper's PwC interview
20 Dec 2016 Email from Timothy Johnston
to John Robinson, Richard
Bullick re Jonathan Bell's
allegations, with responses
from Simon Hamilton and
John Robinson
20 Dec 2016 Simon Hamilton email to
Clive McFarland forwarding
internal DFE discussion re
Invest NI shareholding in
Balcas
20 Dec 2016 Email from Timothy Johnston
to William Irwin re media
query about his AQW
20 Dec 2016 Emails between Timothy
Johnston, Clive McFarland
and William Irwin re media
query
20 Dec 2016 Emails between William
Irwin and Timothy Johnston
re Irish News query
20 Dec 2016 Email from Simon Hamilton
to Timothy Johnston, Richard
Bullick and  John Robinson re
call from Andrew McCormick
20 Dec 2016 Email from Simon Hamilton
to Timothy Johnston and
Richard Bullick forwarding
emails between Andrew
McCormick and Jonathan
Bell 
20 Dec 2016 Derry Journal Inishowen
Edition ‘Spads apply heat
to Cash for Ash’
20 Dec 2016 Emails between Emer Morelli,
Mike Brennan and Michelle
Scott re supply – DFE – RHI
scheme parameters
20 Dec 2016 Text messages between Clive
McFarland, John Robinson,
Timothy Johnston and Simon
Hamilton re Nolan Show
20-29 Dec 2016 Emails from Andrew 
McCormick to Jonathan
Bell re their conversation
being recorded 
21-22 Dec 2016 Emails between Aidan
McAteer, Richard Bullick,
John Robinson, Arlene
Foster and Simon 
Hamilton re meeting of
Sinn Fein and DUP
21 Dec 2016 Email from Michelle Scott
to Noel McNally – Version
1 Executive Paper RHI
21 Dec 2016 Letter from Naomi Long
to Malcolm McKibbin re
allegations made by Jonathan
Bell in an interview with
Stephen Nolan
21 Dec 2016 Note of meeting between
Máirtín Ó Muilleoir and
Simon Hamilton to discuss
options for closing RHI
21 Dec 2016 Gareth John’s actions list
from RHI Board
21 Dec 2016 NI RHI Fraud Prevention
Strategy by Sharon Fyfe
21 Dec 2016 Text messages between
John Robinson and Simon
Hamilton re biomass expert
and the Nolan Show
22 Dec -
6 Jan 2016
Emails between Paul 
Montgomery, Stephen
McMurray, Michelle
Scott and Brian McClure 
re state aid
22 Dec 2016 Assembly query number
AQW 8780/16-21 from
Philip Smith to Mártín
Ó Muilleoir re detail the
projected impact on the
NI budget of the RHI for
the next 30 years
22 Dec 2016 Email from Brian McClure
to Mike Brennan and others
re rates – RHI boilers
22 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Chris Stewart
and others re follow up
correspondence from PAC

DFE-182749.xlsm

23 Dec 2016 Email from Mark Cockburn
to Terence Coyne re PWC
report critique of chapter 3
23 Dec 2016 Submission from Andrew
McCormick to Simon
Hamilton re RHI – interview
with former Minister Bell on
15 December 2016
23 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew 
McCormick to David Sterling
re RHI cost reduction
23 Dec 2016 Email from Eugene Rooney
to Aidan McAteer re RHI
cost reduction
23 Dec 2016 Emails between David Gordon
and Richard Bullick re BBC
and the Jonathan Bell tapes
23 Dec 2016 Emails between David Gordon
and Richard Bullick re request
from BBC to interview Andrew
McCormick
23 Dec 2016 UFU update
28 Dec 2016 Emails between David Gordon
and Richard Bullick re
statement from Andrew
McCormick
28-29 Dec 2016 Text messages between
John Robinson, Simon
Hamilton and Andrew
Crawford re Andrew 
McCormick’s draft statement
28-30 Dec 2016 Internal DUP email discussion
re media query as to whether
Arlene Foster or her SpAd
read the 2013 CEPA report
29 Dec 2016 Email from Terence Coyne
to Andrew McCormick with
Minister's clearance for
SUB 464 2014 – NI RHI –
domestic aspect of
Phase 2 business case
29 Dec 2016 Email from Chris Stewart
to Andrew McCormick
commenting on Andrew
McCormick’s draft note
for the record
29 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to himself with
draft comments to BBC
re Jonathan Bell’s
recording of the Jonathan
Bell/Andrew McCormick
meeting
29 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew 
McCormick to Jonathan
Bell re request to put
information into the
public record
29 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Seamus
Hughes, Stuart Wightman,
Terence Coyne, Chris
Stewart and Lucy Marten
re Irish News comment
29 Dec 2016 Email from Aine Gaughran
to Andrew McCormick, 
Lucy Marten and others
re email from Sam McBride
29 Dec 2016 Email from John Robinson
to Clive McFarland with draft
response to media query re
Arlene Foster’s letter to the
banks
29 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to John Robinson
attaching Phase 2 business
case
29 Dec 2016 Email from Clive McFarland 
to media outlets forwarding
copy of Arlene Foster’s
letter to the banks
29 Dec 2016 Text messages between
Richard Bullick, John
Robinson and Simon
Hamilton
30 Dec 2016 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Simon
Hamilton attaching email 
from Stuart Wightman
dated 17 July 2015
30 Dec 2016 Email from Claire Archbold
DSO to Andrew McCormick
commenting on his draft
note for the record
30 Dec 2016 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Richard Bullick,
John Robinson and Simon
Hamilton re press release
regarding Arlene Foster’s
letter to banks
30 Dec 2016 Email from Richard Bullick
to Simon Hamilton re
releasing material through
DETI rather than party
30 Dec 2016 Email from John Robinson
to Clive McFarland re need
for secrecy
Dec 2016/
Jan 2017
Exchange of texts between
Andrew McCormick and
Chris Stewart regarding
declaration of conflict
interest and John Robinson
declaring interest
Jan 2017 Draft submission from Stuart
Wightman to John Robinson
and Simon Hamilton re non
domestic RHI scheme
(COR 1358-2016)
1 Jan 2017 DUP emails discussing press
query on donors and call
for boycott
3 Jan 2017 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Leander
Harding and others re
response to UFU RHI query
3 Jan 2017 Email from Helen Frazer to
Mike Brennan re meeting
between David Sterling
and HMT
3 Jan 2017 Email from Wesley Aston
to Andrew Crawford
attaching RHI emails
dated July 2015 between
Chris Osborne, Seamus
Hughes and Tom Forgrave
re changes to NI RHI
3-4 Jan 2017 Emails forwarded by
Wesley Aston to Andrew
Crawford who then 
forwards to other SpAds
re DETI officials briefing
UFU and Moy Park
4 Jan 2017 Email from Lucy Marten
to Adele Willis and Joanne
Adair re state aid
4 Jan 2017 Email from David Gordon to
Aidan McAteer
4 Jan 2017 Email from Máirtín Ó
Muilleoir to Ted Howell
re DUP proposed solution 
to the problem
4 Jan 2017 Internal Sinn Fein emails
re Tweet from Máirtín Ó
Muilleoir re DUP ‘solution’
4 Jan 2017 NI non domestic RHI
update for E-Serve
Board meeting
4 Jan 2017 Email from Stuart Forsyth
to Jane Pierce containing
draft response to media
query re multiple boilers
4 Jan 2017 Email from Andrew 
McCormick's personal
email to his DfE account
with draft email to Simon
Hamilton re emails from
anonymous source
4 Jan 2017 Emails from Andrew Crawford
to John Robinson and Richard
Bullick re briefings during
summer 2015 about changes
to the scheme
4 Jan 2017 Email from Mike Brennan
to Máirtín Ó Muilleoir re
economy proposal on
RHI attaching proposal
document
4 Jan 2017 Emails between Michelle
Scott, Mike Brennan and
Emer Morelli re Máirtín
Ó Muilleoir’s query
about irregular spend
4 Jan 2017 FOI request from John Moore
seeking copies of all written
correspondence to Simon
Hamilton as Finance Minister
re RHI; forwarded on to 
David Sterling
4 Jan 2017 Transcript of Bernie
Brankin's PwC interview
4 Jan 2017 Email from Taryn McHenry
to Chris Osborne re UFU
press release: RHI review
must focus on scheme
failings says UFU
5 Jan 2017 Text messages between
Simon Hamilton and
Timothy Johnston
5 Jan 2017 Email from Andrew 
McCormick to Simon
Hamilton re emails from
anonymous source
5 Jan 2017 Email from Máirtín
Ó Muilleoir to Ted Howell 
re thoughts after the meeting
5 Jan 2017 Email from Eoin Rooney
to Mike Brennan, Emer
Morelli and Michelle Scott
detailing Finance Minister 
and Economy Minister
meeting notes
5 Jan 2017 Email from DECC to Edmund
Ward re risk appetite and
audit strategy 
5 Jan 2017 Email chain between Fiona
Dickson, Seamus Hughes,
Cathal Ellis and Lucy Marten
re historic biomass
5 Jan 2017 Minutes of NI Broiler Growers
Committee meeting at
Cohannon Inn 
5 Jan 2017 Email from Paul Montgomery
to Stephen Moore requesting
advice on response to DoF re
RHI options
6 Jan 2017 Email from Timothy Johnston
to Richard Bullick re draft
letter to BBC with tracked
changes
6 Jan 2017 Emails between Simon
Hamilton, John Robinson
and Richard Bullick re memo
from Máirtín Ó Muilleoir to
Simon Hamilton
6 Jan 2017 Draft letter from Máirtín
Ó Muilleoir to Simon
Hamilton re delay with
provision of plan to address
the issues with the scheme
6-11 Jan 2017 Emails between Michelle
Scott and Stephen 
McMurray re rate of return
6 Jan 2017 Emails between Paul
Montgomery and David
Sterling re biomass cost
6 Jan 2017 Emails between David
Sterling, Shane Murphy
and Paul Montgomery
re biomass cost
6 Jan 2017 Email from Chris Johnston
to Mark Anderson re
Belfast Telegraph article
6 Jan 2017 Email from Martin Moore to
Eoin Rooney, Anne Armstrong,
Mike Brennan, Emer Morelli
re additional RHI transcripts
6 Jan 2017 Irish News report ‘Former
DUP politician urges ex-
colleagues to speak out’
6 Jan 2017 News Letter report ‘Open
letter: Speak out on scandal,
Palmer urges DUP members’
6 Jan 2017 Email from Michelle Scott
to Mike Brennan and Emer
Morelli forwarding email
from Paul Montgomery
re RHI options discussion
6 Jan 2017 Ulster Farmers’ Union update
6 Jan 2017 Email from Stephen Moore
to Claire Archbold re RHI –
clarification of the benefit
to be conferred
7 Jan 2017 Email to DUP press office
re Action Renewables RHI
conference 2013 brochure
7 Jan 2017 Email from Alan Taylor to 
DUP Press Office attaching
brochure for Action
Renewables RHI conference
and exhibition on
20 June 2013
7 Jan 2017 Email from Alan Taylor to
DUP Press Office re RHI
conference and exhibition
7-8 Jan 2017 Email from Andrew
McCormick's private email
to his DfE email with draft
letter from Simon Hamilton
to Minister of Finance re
DoF business case on
cost controls 
8 Jan 2017 Email from Clive McFarland
to Richard Bullick attaching
draft letter of complaint to
the BBC
8 Jan 2017 Emails between Michelle
Scott and Noel McNally re
RHI addendum – rates of
return
9 Jan 2017 Email from John Robinson
to Andrew McCormick re
tip-off from a concerned
citizen
9 Jan 2017 Email from Conor McStravick
to Stuart Wightman
attaching Energy whistle
blowing guidance
9 Jan 2017 Email from Michelle Scott
to Eoin Rooney re RHI- 
engagement between DoF
and DfE officials on rate
of return query
9 Jan 2017 Moy Park presentation to
DfE and DoF
9 Jan 2017 Moy Park presentation to
DfE and DoF with
additional notes
9 Jan 2017 Further copy of Moy Park
presentation to DfE and
DoF with further notes
9 Jan 2017 Email from Shane Murphy
to Stephen McMurray,
Andrew McCormick, Paul
Montgomery and Lucy
Marten attaching RHI
business case addressing
the deficiencies in the
non domestic RHI scheme
9 Jan 2017 Emails between Stephen
Moore and Peter Briggs
discussing email from
Gary Clarke re state aid
rules on disclosure of
details of beneficiaries
9 Jan 2017 Emails between Terence
Coyne and Mark Cockburn
re amendments to PWC
report
10 Jan 2017 Email from Máirtín Ó
Muilleoir re alleging that
Arlene Foster had a conflict
of interest
10 Jan 2017 Drafts of submission from
Stephen McMurray to
Simon Hamilton and John
Robinson re production of
details of non-domestic RHI
participants
10 Jan 2017 Email from Emer Morelli
to Mike Mullan re
presentation to DfE and DoF
10 Jan 2017 Internal Ofgem email
discussion re responding
to media queries
10 Jan 2017 Emails between Victor
Dukelow and Stephen
Moore re CEPA letter
to Andrew McCormick
– Degression
10 Jan 2017 Emails between Stuart
Wightman, Alan Smith and
Stephen Moore re spike
chart to be included within
the state aid notification
10 Jan 2017 Emails between Stephen
Moore, Stephen McGregor
and Lynsey Moore re
reason for cancellation of
meeting with Andrew 
McCormick
10 Jan 2017 Emails between Stephen
Moore and Lynsey Moore 
re meeting with Celine
10 Jan 2017 Emails between Lynsey
Moore, Teresa Agata
Majdzinska, Shane Murphy
and Amanda Murray re
meeting on 11 January
with Andrew McCormick 
10-18 Jan 2017 Correspondence between
DoF and DfE re DoF
meeting with Moy Park
10-22 Jan 2017 Emails between DfE and
Ofgem re the proposed
2017 regulations
11 Jan 2017 Email from Stephen Moore
to Nerys Levin requesting
advice re state aid
11 Jan 2017 Email from Stephen Moore
to Lucy Marten re state aid
11 Jan 2017 Emails between Neil Marr,
Colin Fletcher and Stephen
Moore re RHI State Aid
notification
11 Jan 2017 Emails between Stephen
Moore and Nerys Levin
re State Aid
11-13 Jan 2017 Emails from Stephen Mc
Murray to Michelle Scott
and Mike Brennan and
others attaching the
Business Case on future
operation of the RHI;
forwarded to Patrick Neeson
and Tony Simpson; emails
arranging to discuss the
Business Case
11 Jan 2017 Email from Andrew 
McCormick to Lucy Marten
re state aid and sunset
clause in draft regulations
11 Jan 2017 Transcript of Nolan Show
interview with Máirtín
Ó Muilleoir re financial
impact of collapse of RHI
11 Jan 2017 Email from Stephen McMurray
to Lucy Marten and others 
attaching business case re
addressing the deficiencies
in the non domestic RHI
11 Jan 2017 Emails between Máirtín
Ó Muilleoir, Noreen Douglas,
Eoin Rooney, Emer Morelli
and Michelle Scott re Moy
Park Irish News query for
clearance
11 Jan 2017 Email chain between Emer
Morelli, Stephen McMurray,
and Paul Montgomery re
letter to DfE
11 Jan 2017 Email from Jill Downie to
DoF, Jonathan McNaughton
re PSD – co-ordinated topical
questions and headline issues
– briefing document attached
11 Jan 2017 Email from Gareth John to
numerous Ofgem staff re
NI lessons learned session
5 Jan attachments: notes
from NI lessons learned
meeting; annex B initial
outputs from lessons
learned exercise
11 Jan 2017 Emails between Nerys
Levin, Esther Isaacs, Stephen
Moore, Lucy Marten and
Andrew McCormick re
standstill clauses
11 Jan 2017 Email from Joanne Adair to
Amanda Murray and Stephen
Moore re pre and post
November 2015 biomass
tariffs & definitions
12 Jan 2017 Email from Stephen Moore
to Lucy Marten re state aid
standstill clause
12 Jan 2017 Email from Andrew 
McCormick to Stephen
Moore and Lucy Marten
re state aid
12 Jan 2017 Email from Paul McGinn
to Adele Willis re draft
regulations
12 Jan 2017 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Terence Coyne,
Adele Willis and others re
sunset clause in draft
regulations
12 Jan 2017 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Brendan McCann re letter
to DfE 10 January 2017
12 Jan 2017 Submission from Stuart
Wightman to John Robinson
and Simon Hamilton re
COR 1358-2016 non-domestic
RHI scheme, correspondence
from Jim Allister re state aid
12 Jan 2017 Emails between Stephen
Moore and Andrew
McCormick re state aid
12 Jan 2017 Email from Leander Harding
to Lucy Marten, Stephen
McMurray and others with
draft response to Newsletter
press query
12 Jan 2017 Letter from Robin Swann,
PAC to Nick Perry, DOJ
re Desertcreat
12 Jan 2017
Email chain between 
Shane Murphy, Michelle
Scott and Stephen
McMurray re non-domestic
RHI business case
12 Jan 2017
Email from Mike Brennan
to Hugh Widdis re non-
domestic RHI business case
12 Jan 2017
Emails between Paul McGinn,
Stephen Moore, Nerys Levin
and Esther Isaacs re
standstill clauses
12 Jan 2017
Emails between Susan
Robinson (OBO Paul McGinn)
and Stephen Moore re RHI
regulations DSO draft and
advice from UK Rep
12 Jan 2017 UFU Poultry Committee
minutes of meeting held
on 12 January 2017
12-16 Jan 2017 Emails between DoF and
DfE officials attaching VfM
spreadsheets relating to
the business case on future
operation of the RHI
13 Jan 2017 Letters from Paul McGinn
to Lucy Marten re draft RHI
amendment regulations
13 Jan 2017 Emails between Edmund
Ward and Lucy Marten re
draft regulations
13 Jan 2017 Letter from DfE to NI
Assembly Business Office
enclosing draft regulations
for laying
13 Jan 2017 Letter from Simon Hamilton
to Conor Murphy re DfE’s
failure to consult ETI
Committee
13 Jan 2017 Email from Mike Brennan
to Hugh Widdis re RHI draft
instructions to counsel v1
13 Jan 2017 Email from Máirtín ÓMuilleoir
to Sean Kerr re critical issues
meeting and noting that
meeting should include
discussion on RHI
13 Jan 2017 Ulster Farmers’ Union update
13-23 Jan 2017 Text messages between
Andrew Crawford and 
John Robinson
14 Jan 2017 Email from Eoin Rooney
to Paul Kavanagh re RHI
regulations
14 Jan 2017 Emails between Máirtín
Ó Muilleoir, Eoin Rooney,
Paul Kavanagh and Ted
Howell re RHI solution
14 Jan 2017 Email from Victor Dukelow
to Brendan McCann
attaching draft briefing for
Assembly debate
14 Jan 2017 Email from Shane Murphy
to Alan Smith re those
earning 12% already
14 Jan 2017 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Simon Hamilton
and Shane Murphy re RHI
Moy Park
14 Jan 2017 Email from Victor Dukelow
to Alan Smith attaching
email chain re RHI Moy Park
14-15 Jan 2017 Drafts of Simon Hamilton’s
speech to Assembly re 2017
regulations, Q&As and
lines to take and emails
relating thereto
14-31 Jan 2017 Text messages between
David Sterling and
Andrew McCormick
15 Jan 2017 Email from Claire Archbold
to Andrew McCormick re
proposed responses for
Assembly debate
15-16 Jan 2017 Email from Emer Morelli
to DoF Private office and
Máirtín Ó Muilleoir attaching
Supply’s initial draft response
to DfE’s request for DoF
approval of a business case
to address the deficiencies in
the RHI scheme
15 Jan 2017 Emails between Andrew
McCormick, Stephen Moore,
Terence Coyne and others
re briefing material
15 Jan 2017 Email from Simon Hamilton
forwarding to Andrew
McCormick a letter sent to
MLAs by the Renewable
Heat Association Northern
Ireland
15 Jan 2017 Emails between Emer Morelli,
Mike Brennan, Michelle
Scott and David Sterling re
working draft RHI business
case January 2017, queries
to DfE, attaching draft letter
to Stephen McMurray
15 Jan 2017 Email from Emer Morelli
to Mike Brennan, Michelle
Scott and David Sterling re
working draft RHI business
case January 2017 queries
to DfE
15 Jan 2017 Email from David Sterling
to Emer Morelli and Mike
Brennan re working draft
RHI business case January
2017 queries to DFE
16 Jan 2017 Ministerial Submission from
Emer Morelli to Máirtín Ó
Muilleoir re approval of
business case to address
the deficiencies in the non-
domestic RHI scheme
16 Jan 2017 Email from Mike Brennan
to Emer Morelli and David
Sterling re working draft
RHI business case January
2017 queries to DFE
16 Jan 2017 Extract from Hansard
Report of the NI Assembly
16 Jan 2017 Emails between Máirtín
Ó Muilleoir, Ted Howell,
Aidan McAteer and
Eoin Rooney re proposed
party approach to RHI
16 Jan 2017 DUP press release re
Timothy Johnston and
John Robinson on further
Q&A/denial of any benefit;
IND-00490 to IND-00493;
16 Jan 2017 John Robinson’s response
to media query re his
father-in-law
16 Jan 2017 Transcript of Peter
Hutchinson’s second
PwC interview
16 Jan 2017 Text message between
David Sterling and Mike
Brennan
16 Jan 2017 Emails between Victor
Dukelow, Alan Smith, Shane
Murphy and others re Q&A
for Assembly Debate Master
16 Jan 2017 Email chain between Alan
Smith, Shane Murphy and
Victor Dukelow re sensitivity
analysis
16 Jan 2017 Emails from Alan Smith
to Stephen McMurray
re numbers affected by
moving to a new tariff
16 Jan 2017 Emails between Paul
Montgomery and Shane
Murphy re operating
cost differential
16 Jan 2017 Illustration of the proposed
RHI tariffs – a worked
example
16 Jan 2017 Email chain between Claire
Archbold, Andrew
McCormick, Stephen
McMurray and others
re letter from the
Renewable Heat
Association NI
16 Jan 2017 Email from Terence Coyne
to Emer Morelli re RHI
business case
16 Jan 2017 Email from Shane Murphy
to Siobhan Tweedie re RHI
– a worked example
16 Jan 2017 Email from Shane Murphy
to Patrick Neeson re RHI –
Annex C (CEPA 2012-Capex
& Opex Environment (Dec
2010 Prices)
16 Jan 2017 Email from  Joanne Adair to
Stephen Moore and Lucy
Marten re RHI – reply to
State Aid Unit request for
info re the tariff change
announcement by DETI
in late summer/early
autumn 2015
16 Jan 2017 Email from Shane Murphy
to Siobhan Tweedie re RHI
– a worked example –
details potential amount
of overpayment
16 Jan 2017 Email re meeting between
Máirtín Ó Muilleoir, Michelle
Scott, Mike Brennan, Emer
Morelli and Hugh Widdis
to discuss the DfE business
case in more detail 
17 Jan 2017 Emails between Máirtín
Ó Muilleoir, Ted Howell and 
Eoin Rooney re interim
solution
17 Jan 2017 Press statement by Simon
Hamilton and John Robinson
following media query
17 Jan 2017 Email from Phil Gregg to
himself attaching Dept of
Justice documents relevant to
Sunday World article dated
18 December 2016; attaches
documents dating back to
2012/13 related to
Desertcreat project
17 Jan 2017 Ofgem E-serve Board Paper,
NI non domestic RHI: an
update
17 Jan 2017 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Mike Brennan
re RHI - PAC line of 
questioning 
17 Jan 2017 Emails between DoF officials
discussing draft response to
AQW 9235-16 from Jim
Allister to Máirtín Ó Muilleoir
17 Jan 2017 Email (partial) from Charlotte
Baker to various Ofgem staff
re outstanding NI
information requests
17-18 Jan 2017 Email from BBC Nolan Show
to DUP with follow-up
questions
17-18 Jan 2017 DUP emails concerning
Andrew Crawford’s response
to Bell’s allegations and
questions from Nolan Show
18 Jan 2017 Email from Máirtín
Ó Muilleoir to Aidan
McAteer and others re
current thinking re RHI
18 Jan 2017 Northern Ireland Assembly
Public Accounts Committee
Official Report (Hansard)
Inquiry into the Non-domestic
RHI Scheme: DfE
18 Jan 2017 Andrew McCormick emails
himself John Robinson’s
‘perception’ of conflict
18-19 Jan 2017 Emails between Eoin Rooney,
Mike Brennan and David
Sterling raising concerns of
Máirtín Ó Muilleoir re RHI
non-domestic business case;
Mike Brennan response
18 Jan 2017 Email from Stephen Mc
Murray to Michael Woods
forwarding reply letter to
Robin Swann MLA re PAC
Inquiry on RHI Scheme
18 Jan 2017 Email from Mike Brennan
to David Sterling attaching
emails from August 2015 re
increase in RHI AME in 
2015-16
18 Jan 2017 Emails between Timothy
Johnston, Andrew Crawford,
Clive McFarland and others
relating to allegations
against Andrew Crawford
18 Jan 2017 Email from Angela Millar
to Pamela Galloway, Michelle
Scott and Emer Morelli re
emails from August 2015
and AME position for RHI
18 Jan 2017 Email from Mike Brennan
to Andrew McCormick re
thoughts for possible PAC 
questions on RHI
18 Jan 2017 Email between Michelle
Scott, Emer Morelli and
Angela Millar re further
comments on possible
PAC questions
18-19 Jan 2017 Email discussion between
Adele Willis, Examiner
for Statutory Instruments
and Stephen McMurray re
state aid
19 Jan 2017 Email from Martin Gibson
to Lucy Marten enclosing
Simon Hamilton’s annotated
copy of an Assembly
question/proposed answer
19 Jan 2017 Email from Stephen Moore
to Examiner of Statutory
Instruments re state aid
19 Jan 2017 Hansard Report of Andrew
McCormick’s evidence to
the ETI Committee
19 Jan 2017 RHI Impact Analysis
document sent to the
Examiner of
Statutory Rules
19 Jan 2017 Media query to DUP re
information being shared
with industry in July 2015
19 Jan 2017 Email from Michelle Scott
to Mike Brennan re tiered
tariff, attaching note of
meeting on 17 October 2016
19 Jan 2017 Email from Michelle Scott
to Emer Morelli re RHI PQs
19 Jan 2017 Email from Alison Caldwell
to Mike Brennan re update
on RHI - DfE fact finding 
exercise
19 Jan 2017 Email from Jill Downie to
DoF private office attaching
memo from Mike Brennan
to Máirtín Ó Muilleoir re
RHI non domestic business
case – concerns
19 Jan 2017 Email from Richard Bullick
to Clive McFarland re media
briefing note
19 Jan 2017 Hansard official report:
RHI scheme: Renewable Heat
Association
20 Jan 2017 Transcript of David
Thomson's PwC interview
20 Jan 2017 Email from Paul Montgomery
to Stuart Wightman re RHI -
development of long term
approach – proposed analysis
20 Jan 2017 Email from Michelle Scott
to Mike Brennan and Emer
Morelli attaching email from
Noel McNally with update
on RHI meeting
20 Jan 2017 Email from Stephen McMurray
to Andrea Quail and Ronan
Murtagh re RHI technical
points to be checked 
following committee meeting
20 Jan 2017 Irish News report ‘Who are
DUP special advisers in the
eye of the RHI storm?’
20 Jan 2017 Email Teri Clifton to Karen
Boyle re suspected fraud
case closure report 
21 Jan 2017 Emails between Máirtín
Ó Muilleoir, Eoin Rooney,
Mike Brennan and Emer
Morelli re EU state aid
renotification and the
coming into force of the
regulations
22 Jan 2017 Report of the Examiner on
Statutory Rules re 2017
regulations and emails
regarding same
22 Jan 2017 Email from Clive McFarland
to Richard Bullick, Timothy
Johnson, Arlene Foster and
Nigel Dodds discussing Jim
Wells’ interview with the
Sunday Life
22 Jan 2017 Emails  between Lucy
Marten, Emer Morelli, Victoria
Reid and Terence Coyne re
letter from Stephen Murray
to Emer Morelli re
non-domestic RHI
23-27 Jan 2017 Internal DUP emails re
members having relations
benefiting from the scheme
23 Jan 2017 Email from Terence Coyne
to Siobhan Tweedie attaching
Minister’s closing statement
for Assembly debate
23 Jan 2017 Extract from Hansard
Report of the NI Assembly
23 Jan 2017 Memo from David Sterling 
to Máirtín Ó Muilleoir re
RHI cost control business
case
23 Jan 2017 ETI Committee Chrperson’s
Brief for meeting held on 
23 January 2017
23 Jan 2017 Hansard report of Andrew
McCormick’s evidence to
ETI Committee
23 Jan 2017 Email from Emer Morelli
to Stephen McMurray re
state aid re-notification
process; Stephen's draft
response
23 Jan 2017 DUP press statement re
Carla Lockhart and William
Irwin
23 Jan 2017 Emails between Arlene Foster,
Clive McFarland and David
O'Dornan re questions from
BBC Nolan Show
23 Jan 2017 Email from Mike Brennan
to David Sterling
23 Jan 2017 Email from Stuart Wightman
to Paul Montgomery with
minor comments on RHI -
development of long term
approach – proposed analysis
23 Jan 2017 Emails between Chris Poulton,
James Kilmartin and Edmund
Ward re draft email to
Andrew McCormick
23 Jan 2017 Email Janette O’Hagan to
Lucia Wilson, forwarded
by Lucia Wilson to others
including Darren Weir [parts
of email are indecipherable]
re RHI Inquiry
23 Jan 2017 NI Assembly Hansard Report,
Volume 123, No 3
23 Jan 2017 Media report ‘RHI Scandal:
claimants details to be
made public on Wednesday’
23 Jan 2017 Media report: RHI Scandal:
DUP MLAs Carla Lockhart
and William Irwin reveal
family members have
boilers under the botched
green energy scheme’
23 Jan 2017 Irish News report ‘Executive
Office refuses to say if
Brimstone got pay-off’
23 Jan 2017 News Letter report ‘Allister:
I tried to rein in SpAads’
23 Jan 2017 Email chain between Mike
Brennan, Stephen Moore,
Stephen McMurray, and
Emer Morelli re RHI
regulations state aid
23 Jan 2017 Email from Emer Morelli
to Eoin Rooney re state
aid re-notification RHI,
DfE's advice
Circa
Jan 2017
Non-domestic RHI related
correspondence 26.8.13-
12.3.15 [Correspondence
timeline document compiled
by Janette O’Hagan – differs
slightly from document at
PAC-01826 to PAC-01830]
24 Jan 2017 Email from Máirtín Ó
Muilleoir re meeting with
Simon Hamilton
24 Jan 2017 Copy of Mártín Ó Muilleoir's
statement to the Assembly
on the inquiry into the 
non-domestic RHI scheme
24 Jan 2017 The Renewable Heat Incentive
Scheme (Amendment)
Regulations (Northern
Ireland) 2017
24-30 Jan 2017 Emails between Peter
Briggs and Lucy Marten
re CAFRE’s tariff on RHI
scheme
24 Jan 2017 Belfast Telegraph report
‘Former DUP aide ‘ripped
off RHI’'
24 Jan 2017 Irish News report ‘Claim
ex-DUP adviser using ‘non
-domestic’ RHI boiler to
heat his home’
24 Jan 2017 Irish Times report ‘DUP
dismisses claim over
heating scandal’
24 Jan 2017 News Letter report ‘DUP
Spad ‘ripped off’ RHI
scheme for his home’
25 Jan 2017 Email from Emer Morelli to
Private Office attaching
revised draft of DoF
approval letter
25 Jan 2017 Irish News report ‘Former
DUP special adviser stays
silent on RHI allegations’
25 Jan 2017 News Letter report ‘Party
won’t say if Brimstone
remains a member’
25 Jan 2017 Email from Stephen
McMurray to Claire Archbold
attaching details of RHI
taskforce and oversight
board
25 Jan 2017 Letter from Emer Morelli
to Stephen McMurray re
the business case for
addressing the deficiencies
in the non-domestic RHI
scheme
25 Jan 2017 Email from Arlene Foster
to Clive McFarland in
response to media query
re rate relief
25 Jan 2017 DUP press release
re Stephen Brimstone
25 Jan 2017 Emails between Cathal Ellis,
Eric Long, Martin McKendry
and George Mathers re new
scheme tariffs
25 Jan 2017 UFU memo to all Rural
Enterprise Policy Committee
members with agenda for
meeting to be held on
1 February 2017; minutes
of the Executive Committee
meeting held on 25 January
2017; President's report
25 Jan 2017 Emails between Chris
Osborne and Chris Stewart
re meeting between
DfE and UFU
25-30 Jan 2017 DfE emails re State Aid
26 Jan 2017 Emails between Timothy
Johnston, Stephen Brimstone
and Clive McFarland re Arlene
Foster’s interview
26 Jan 2017 Impartial Reporter report 
'Allister claims Kesh-born
ex-DUP adviser heats
home under RHI’
26 Jan 2017 Irish News report ‘Police
probe into Brimstone
while still Spad’
27 Jan 2017 News Letter report ‘Brimstone
– still not clear if Spad
remains DUP member’
27-28 Jan 2017 Email from Chris Johnston
to Mark Anderson re Irish
News article
27 Jan 2017 Pre–notification paper:
revision of state aid
SA.34140 – RHI (NI)
28 Jan 2017 News Letter report ‘Hard
questions for the DUP,
but also for the Civil Service’
29 Jan 2017 Sunday World NI Edition
report ‘Brimstone had
links to funding’
30 Jan 2017 Email with draft letter from
Máirtín Ó Muilleoir to Simon
Hamilton re concerns about
the delay with closing the
scheme
30 Jan 2017 Media query to the DUP
re Arlene Foster’s comments
in NI Energy Institute
Yearbook 2012
30 Jan 2017 Email from Jim Wells to
Sammy Wilson, Clive 
McFarland, William Irwin,
Chris Stalford and Edwin
Poots attaching media
article re Department
for Agriculture promoting
RHI scheme
30 Jan 2017 Media query to DUP Press
Office re comments made
by Lord Morrow
30 Jan 2017 Email from Lynne O’Neill to
Martin McKendry and Cathal
Ellis attaching press article
30 Jan 2017 Email chain between Ronan
Henry, Terence Patton, Peter
Scott, Lynne O’Neill and
others re query from Conor
Macauley
30 Jan 2017 Emails between Lynne
O’Neill, Martin McKendry,
Cathal Ellis and others re
BBC Nolan Show questions
31 Jan 2017 Draft submission from 
Stephen McMurray to
Andrew McCormick and
Simon Hamilton re proposal
to engage external resource-
comprehensive audit of non-
domestic RHI installations
1 Feb 2017 Draft letter from Andrew
McCormick to Chris Poulton
re need for audit
Circa
Feb 2017
Emails from concerned
citizen: timelines
1 Feb 2017 Email from Amanda Murray
to Stephen McMurray
confirming submission
of state aid notification
1 Feb 2017 State Aid Notification
1 Feb 2017 State Aid Notification
validation
1 Feb 2017 UFU Rural Enterprise
Committee minutes
1 Feb 2017 Email from Stephen Moore
to Andrew McCormick re
NI RHI state aid pre-
notification (attached)
2 Feb 2017 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Terrence
Coyne  forwarding
concerned citizen timeline 
for checking
2 Feb 2017 Email from Terence Coyne 
to Andrew McCormick 
attaching concerned citizen
timeline and emails relating
to Janette O’Hagan
2 Feb 2017 Email chain between Peter
Scott, Terence Patton, Lynne
O’Neill, Cathal Ellis, Martin
McKendry and others re
Press Office amended RHI
line from DE
2 Feb 2017 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Simon
Hamilton forwarding
concerned citizen
timeline and emails in
relation to Janette O’Hagan
3 Feb 2017 Email from Máirtín Ó Muilleoir
to Eoin Rooney re timeline
3 Feb 2017 DETI emails discussing
response to press query from
The Times re Fiona Hepper’s
role in RHI
6 Feb 2017 Email from Lucia Wilson
Darren Weir forwarding
Janette  O’Hagan’s email
dated 23 Jan 2017 re
RHI Inquiry
6 Feb 2017 Emails between Stephen
Moore and Lynsey Moore
re advice for discussions 
with Colette Fitzgerald
8 Feb 2017 Email from Chris Johnston
to Mark Anderson re BBC
News article
9 Feb 2017 Email from EU Commission
listing questions re state
aid pre-notification paper
9 Feb 2017 Emails between Stephen
Moore, Lucy Marten, John
Simms and Andrew
McCormick re Andrew
McCormick's email to John
Simms on state aid and
the role of the NI Executive
and Ministers
9 Feb 2017 Email from Stephen Moore
to Steven McGregor and
Arnold Daniel re phone
call from Kate Kelliher re
NI RHI state aid
pre-notification
12 Feb 2017 Sunday Life report ‘RHI
cash swelling coffers of
puppy farm’
13 Feb 2017 Email from Joanne Adair
to Andrew McCormick
and Stephen McMurray
attaching draft responses
to EU Commission’s
questions
13 Feb 2017 Emails between Alistair
Moffett, Terence Coyne and
others re Assembly written
question AQW-9690-16-21
from Jim Allister asking how 
much was loaned to
businesses for the purchase
of RHI boilers through
financial transaction capital
loans
13 Feb 2017 Letter from Stephen Moore
to Kate Kelliher re SA.47501
RHI amendments
pre-notification
14 Feb 2017 Texts between Arlene Foster
and Glynis Aiken asking for
her notes on cost controls
14 Feb 2017 Email from Ruth Galwey
to Richard McCreedy re
note from Minister’s meeting
with Moy Park on 28
September 2016
16 Feb 2017 Email from EU Commission
seeking further clarification
17 Feb 2017 Internal DUP email discussion
re media query of UFU
contact with officials and
SpAds regarding cost
controls
17 Feb 2017 Emails between Sam McBride,
Deborah Cummings, Taryn
McHenry, Richard Wright,
Barclay Bell, Wesley Aston
and Andrew Crawford re
media enquiry – UFU’s
RHI meetings
21 Feb 2017 Email from Richard Bullick
to DUP Press Office
commenting ‘The first
rule of fight club’
22 Feb 2017 Email chain between Emer
Morelli and Mike Mullan re
release of details of meeting
between DoF and Moypark
under FoI request
23 Feb 2017 Minutes of non-domestic
RHI update meeting
between DfE and DoF
23 Feb 2017 Irish News report ‘The role
of DUP special advisers’
24 Feb 2017 Email from Aidan McAteer
to Máirtín Ó Muilleoir re
timeline
24 Feb 2017 Final Version of Letter from
Stephen Moore to Kate Kelliher
re SA.47501 RHI amendments
pre-notification
24 Feb 2017 Emails between Stephen
Moore, Jonathan McAdams,
Jill Hawthorne and Peter
Briggs  re internal audit rec –
domestic RHI ESCOs – advice
from DfE State Aid Unit
28 Feb 2017 Email from Joanne Adair
to Andrew McCormick
indicating draft Submission
of 15 June 2015 was never
sent to the Minister
28 Feb 2017 Email from Jonathan
McAdams to David Glover
re lines to take for the
meeting between Andrew
McCormick and Director-
General Ofgem
28 Feb 2017 Email from Cathal Ellis 
to George Mathers re
accreditation
28 Feb 2017 Email from Brendan McCann
to Michael Woods re RHI
inspections – attaching
specification
Mar 2017 Moy Park internal statement
about RHI regarding
allegations
1 Mar 2017 Emails between Andrew
Crawford and Clive McFarland
following Andrew Crawford’s
request for information on
who cleared Nigel Dodd’s
press release
3 Mar 2017 Emails between Stephen
Moore, Andrew McCormick,
Lucy Marten and Jonathan
McAdams re draft response
to questons raised by the
Commission during
teleconference on
28 February 
3 Mar 2017 Letter from Stephen Moore
to Kate Kelliher re SA.47501
RHI amendments
pre-notification
6 Mar 2017 Email from Stephen Moore
to EU Commission attaching
response to DG queries
6 Mar 2017 Emails between Stephen
Moore, Jonathan McAdams
and Lucy Marten re 
additional questions from
DG Comp re the 2015
decision to introduce
biomass tier 1314 hours
6 Mar 2017 Email from Kate Kelliher to
Stephen Moore re
outstanding data
7 Mar 2017 Emails between Máirtín
Ó Muilleoir and Ted Howell
re DUP meeting
7 Mar 2017 Email from Eoin Rooney
to Máirtín Ó Muilleoir re
overview of objectives
7 Mar 2017 Email from Stephen Moore
to several DfE staff
summarising telephone
conversation with EU
Commission
7 Mar 2017 Email from Stephen Moore to
Victor Dukelow and Andrew
McCormick re CAFRE’s tariff
on RHI scheme
7 Mar 2017 Email chain between Stephen
Moore, Lucy Marten, Jonathan
McAdams, Daniel Arnold,
Joanne Adair and Alan Smith
re CAFRE tariff on RHI scheme
7-8 Mar 2017 Internal DfE email discussion
re CAFRE’s tariff on RHI
scheme
8 Mar 2017 Email from Linda Walsh to
William Macalpine re
Rothamsted research
9 Mar 2017 A selection of slides from
a presentation on the
Biomass Processing
Challenge Fund
9 Mar 2017 UFU Poultry Committee
minutes
9 Mar 2017 Emails between Alan Smith
and Victoria Reid re
outstanding internal audit
recommendations
February 2017
10 Mar 2017 Letter from Stephen Moore
to Kate Kelliher re SA.47501
RHI amendments
pre-notification
16 Mar 2017 Email from EU Commission
to Stephen Moore advising
pre-notification is complete
16 Mar 2017 Email from Terence Coyne
to Andrew McCormick
attaching February 2017
Judicial Review: additional
analysis
16 Mar 2017 State Aid Application Form
17 Mar 2017 Emails between John
Robinson and Clive McFarland
re Highgate Poultry
21 Mar 2017 Emails between Sandra
Thompson, Chris Stewart,
Jonathan McAdams and
Lorraine Crozier authorising
payment to Ofgem for
administration costs
21 Mar 2017 Letter from Ofgem to Stephen
Brimstone re site audit
22 Mar 2017 Emails between Paul
Grimal and Mark Cockburn
re multiple boiler statistics
27 Mar 2017 Emails between Stephen
Moore, Cathal Ellis, RHI
Notifications, Teresa Mc
Carney and others re
Loughry biomass boiler
withdrawal
29 Mar 2017 Email from Andrew
McCormick to TEO HOCS
re RHI emails, attaching
‘note for the record:
RHI - newly discovered
emails’
30 Mar 2017 Media query to DUP re
Arlene Foster’s letter
to Greg Barker in
December 2013
30 Mar 2017 Emails between Stephen
McMurray, Brian O’Neill
and Tomas Wilkinson re
agenda for meeting with
Stephen McMurray on
31 March 2017
31 Mar 2017 EU Commission decision
granting state aid approval
1 Apr 2017 Email from Andrew
McCormick to Alison
Caldwell and Brendan
McCann re Ofgem’s
interpretation of the
regulations together
with draft letter
4 Apr 2017 Email from Stephen Moore
to Jonathan McAdams
attaching the European
Commission's decision on
2017 revisions to non-
domestic RHI scheme, with
request to the RHI team for
comments on whether
redactions are required
5 Apr 2017  Email from Stephen Moore 
to Lucy Marten re discussions 
on the query from the RDC 
on double funding
10 Apr 2017 Andrew McCormick’s
amended note for the record
5 May 2017 Deloitte Report on
Ofgem Internal Audit
25 May 2017 UFU Poultry Committee
minutes
26 May 2017  Letter via email from Joy and
David Mark to Patrick Butler
re request for information
15 Jun 2017 Email from Chris Osborne to
Caroline Bermingham re
inclusion of attached email
chain into RHI file/timeline
26 Jun 2017 Deloitte Report of Factual
Findings
2018 Northern Ireland Guide to
Expenditure Appraisal and
Evaluation (NIGEAE) Guidance
as at 2018; documents
received with NIGEAE
Guidance
23 Feb 2018 National Audit Office
GB RHI report
21 Mar 2018 PAC House of Commons,
Dermot Nolan and Chris
Poulton evidence
31 May 2018 News Letter report ‘Arlene
Foster’s Spad defends passing
insider RHI information to
huge poultry farm’
Jun 2018 Report by the Comptroller
and Auditor General for NI:
Department for the Economy
Resource Accounts 2017-18
6 Jun 2018 Emails between Emer Morelli
and Paul Conway re query on
DETI engagement with poultry
industry through Invest NI
11 Jun 2018 Nolan Show transcript
14 Jun 2018  DfE’s public consultation
paper: The Future of the
Northern Ireland
Non-Domestic RHI
Scheme
20 Jun 2018 Letter to RHI Inquiry from
Ofgem re media material
5 Jul 2018 NIAO media release
  Extract from legislation
relating to functions of
district councils in relation
to energy efficiency
  Briefing paper on RHI
by DETI to ETI Committee
  CHP Mechanical Biomass
proposal for Thomas Forgrave
  Policy/Legislation screened
out during the period 1 April
to 30 September 2011
  Statistics relating to energy
efficiency of owner occupied
and social housing sectors
  Consultation document on
the development of the
NI RHI 20 July – 3 October 2011
  Comments on SL1 Renewable
Heat Regulations by Action
Renewables
  DETI paper on Renewable
Heat Incentive for Northern
Ireland
  The Renewable Heat Incentive
Schemes (Amendment)
Regulations 2016 Regulatory
Impact Assessment
  Draft Regulatory Impact
Assessment for the 2017
Regulations
  Assembly Recess Dates
2015/2016
  Paper by Peter Hutchinson:
Developing the Renewable
Heat Market in Northern
Ireland
  DARD document – Agenda
Item 5: Renewable Energy
  Document entitled questions
for Peter Hutchinson for the
purposes of drafting
instructions
  Advice proforma - invitation
to meet with John Gilliland
  Extract from DETI Website
on how tariffs have been
designed
  Introduction to the
Northern Ireland Guide
to Expenditure Appraisal
and Evaluation (NIGEAE)
and other documents from
DFE website re Economic
Appraisals
Circa
Autumn 2015
DAERA published article
on Tom Forgrave’s use
of multiple boilers
2016 Draft CAFRE Renewable
Energy Programme from
2005 to 2016
Circa
late 2015
Presentation by Chris Stewart
‘Renewable Energy – The Art
of the Possible’
  Letter from Jonathan
McGroggan to Jonathan
Bell re closure of RHI scheme 
  Notes on RHI Phase 2
consultation events
  Paper by Peter Hutchinson
- The Northern Ireland
Renewable Heat Incentive
  Summary of key regulatory
changes to GB non-domestic
RHI scheme since launch
  Charts setting of rates of
return and budget spend
  Samples of completed state
aid declaration forms
  RHI State Aids – Commission
preliminary feedback
  Presentation from Cathal Ellis
– Heat from Biomass & the
Renewable Heat Incentive
  Sample RHI application form
  Hand written notes titled RHI
  Biomass advertising
  Synopsis of the case for a
RHI and RHPP
  2015-16 Control Annex Check
  Synopsis of the case for
a domestic RHI for NI
  Phase 2 consultation
document
  Synopsis of the case for a
domestic RHI for NI
  Draft Report by the
Comptroller and Auditor
General for NI
 

TRIM metadata for:-

  • Submission to Minister on
    Renewable Heat April 2009
  • Sign off by Minister on
    Renewable Heat submission
  • Executive summary of
    Renewable Heat Study
  • CEPA Report
  • CEPA Addendum Report
  • State Aid Notification
  • State Aid Addendum
  • Final synopsis for casework
  • RHI Business Case
  • AAA letter to Ofgem
  • Dec 12 Admin management
    agreement
  • Baseline scope document
  • NI RHI FAQ
  • GB & NI comparison
    spreadsheet
  • DECC organisational chart
  • Janette O’Hagan email of
    12/05/14
  • April 2011 HMT funding
    email
  • Finance email of 8/01/14
  • CEPA 3
  • Phase 2 consultation
    document
  • Consultation policy response
  • Draft DECC consultation
    response
  TRIM meta data for Annex A –
Domestic RHI final policy
- DT1/14/0083031
  TRIM meta data – domestic
RHI – final – DT1/14/0034730
  RHI audit update for DECC
Project Board
Circa
Jul 2012
Draft E Serve quarterly report
Quarter 1 April - June 2012-13
Circa
Sep 2012
Memo with Joanne 
McCutcheon business
telephone number
Circa
Oct 2012
DSO undated handwritten
notes re regulations
Circa
Nov 2012
Draft administration
arrangements
Circa
Jan 2014
Guidance factsheet and
State Aid Declaration
template for de minimis aid
for use by persons in receipt
of Carbon Trust Loans
  Email from Rachel Linton
to RHI Inquiry on 10 May
2018 confirming DfE unable
to locate minutes or notes
of the Issues Meeting held
on 24 August 2015
  Extract from BBC news
website giving dates during
which Minister Bell did not
hold office in September-
October 2015
Circa
Nov 2016
Internal DfE discussion
paper re RHI
  NI RHI forecast operating
costs 2013/14-2015/6
presentation – shows
comparison of NI RHI
volume projection as
percentage against GB
installations as 2013/14
(7%), 2014/15 (6%) and
forecast for 2015/16 (8%)
as compared to 3% in
feasibility study
  Undated presentation
document slide - differences
between assumptions in
feasibility study and current
situation
  Presentation – NI RHI scheme
analysis of 2013/14-2015/16
outyear costs
  Presentation - NI RHI scheme
analysis of 2013/14-2014/15
outyear costs
  Project Woodwork issues for
new scheme development
(issues with DETI costs)
  Presentation on NI RHI
scheme forecast 2013/14-
2015/16 operating costs
and analysis
  Draft DETI Internal Audit
Service report on NI RHI
  NI RHI Strategic Outline Case
  Synopsis of the case for a
Renewable Heat Incentive
and Premium Payment
scheme for NI Version 1-9
  Draft final funding analysis
  Draft final funding analysis
  Energy Division risk register
  Draft administrative
arrangements agreement
(deals with Carbon Trust
loan issue)
  Draft 2015 regulations
with comments
  Ofgem paper – GB v NI
RHI changes November 2015
2010-2017 In-Year monitoring positions
(RHI financial data provided
by DETI/DfE to DfP/DoF,
extracted from the resource
budgeting management
(RBM) system that holds
the financial data for the
NI Executive)
2010-2017 Outturns and forecast
outturns (RHI financial
data provided by DETI/
DfE to DfP/DoF, extracted
from the resource budgeting
management (RBM) system
that holds the financial data
for the NI Executive.  The
information relates to
forecast outturn collected
every month and provided
to HMT)
  Heat from biomass & the
renewable Heat Incentive
- presentation by Cathal Ellis
  Heat from Biomass and the
Renewable Heat Incentive
- presentation by Cathal Ellis
  Introduction to Renewable
Energy – A Presentation
by Cathal Ellis
  UFU contents page and
timeline running from
15 December 2014 –
17 July 2015
  Ofgem E-Serve evidence
submission to PAC – sample
of weekly data extracts sent
from Ofgem to DETI
  The development of the NI
RHI – Review, Analysis and
recommendations by
Michael Doran
  Moy Park image – “And finally
the perfect chicken house!”
  Nutts Corner biomass
proposal
  NI RHI issues by Moy Park
  Analysis of Mark Anderson’s
Twitter account
  Brian Moreland –
presentation notes
  Best Practice in Energy
Efficiency – CB engineering
consultancy presentation
  Introduction to Invest NI’s
resource efficiency guide
for hotel sector in NI -
Robert Duncan presentation 
  Invest NI funding options –
energy efficiency and
renewables presentation by
Ciaran O Reilly
  Invest NI: a resource efficiency
guide for the hotel sector in NI
  Invest NI: biomass: a best
practice guide for businesses
in NI
  Moy Park Plan to Grow Slides
  Moy Park Plan to Grow Slides
  Moy Park Plan to Grow Slides
  DETI risk register – domestic
RHI
  Invest NI resource and energy
efficiency events November
2012 – February 2016
  DETI – NI RHI presentation
  DfE - managing public money
NI: responsibilities
  DfE - managing public money
NI: working with others
  DfE - managing public money
NI: use of public resources;
Accounting Officers
  DfE - managing public money
NI: standards of behaviour
  NI energy industry –
general background
  Energy division risk register
  Annex 10 – NI PAC Ofgem
E-Serve Evidence Submission
Coversheet (Intentionally left
blank) 
  Ofgem table – actions to be
taken while Keith is on leave
  Appendix 1 – detailed
breakdown of IT costs
  DETI – Phase 2 of NI RHI
  Business Case
  Business case addendum
for NI RHI
  Various drafts of the
Administrative Arrangement
Agreements between DETI
and GEMA
  NI RHI: briefing with
comments
Circa mid
Jun 2012
NI RHI: briefing with
comments
Circa mid
Jun 2012
Presentation on NI RHI
scheme analysis of
2013/14 – 2015/16
outyear costs
Circa Aug 
2012
Notes on the UFU’s comments
in respect of RHI
  UFU comments on the
RHI implementation
  Handwritten notes on the RHI
  “Feeling Hot, Hot, Hot,” an
article by Chris Osborne, UFU
Senior Policy Officer
  Newspaper article and
accompanying notes on
the consultation on
Phase 2 of the NI RHI
  Facts about green
energy and biomass in NI
  Business case 
table of contents
  Various drafts of the NI RHI
– state aid approval position
  RHI applicant with Carbon
Trust loans form – Lusty Beg
  RHI applicants with Carbon
Trust loans form – 
SPA Nursing Home
  RHI applicant with Carbon
Trust loans form –
Fairlawns Care Home
  RHI applicant with Carbon
Trust loans form – Redburn
Nursing Home
  Directive 98/43/EC
  Business Case for NI RHI to
be administered by Ofgem
  Business Case Addendum
for the NI RHI
  Notification of Amendments
to the UK RHI Scheme
  Background to the NI RHI
  Commodity Watch report –
Chris Osborne - NI ROC
Closure
  UFU raise pig sector
expansion concerns with NIEA
by Geoff Thompson
  Commodity Watch report –
Chris Osborne re time to
think outside the box –
microgrid and storage
solution in South East Down
  Report written by Senior
Policy Officer Aileen Lawson
re: GHGIP ‘Phase 1’ report
  Report by Chris Osborne re
impact of RP5 electricity
price control on NI farmers
and land owners
  Report by Chris Osborne:
Feeling hot hot hot! re
non domestic NI RHI
  Report by Kate Cairns re
UFU welcome new
planning proposal
  Report by Chris Osborne 
re budget 2012 and the NI
renewables sector
  Report on policy goals for
UFU Rural Enterprise
Committee in 2011
  Report on wind turbines
– advice for landowners
  Report on proposed
changes to the Northern
Ireland Renewables
Obligation (NIRO)
  Commodity Watch report
re anaerobic digestion
  Report – UFU welcomes
launch of NIE farm solar
water heating grant scheme
  Impact of 2009 budget
on renewable energy
  Notification Paper –
Revision of State Aid
SA.34140 RHI (NI)